01Facts
The petitioner, Hari Singh, received land measuring 1 kanal 4 marlas (706 sq. yards) from his cousin, Ajmer Singh, under Release Deed No. 6889 dated 28.03.2016.
¶ 2The deed was registered without payment of stamp duty or registration fee on the basis that the executant had relinquished rights in ancestral property.
¶ 3Both parties descend from a common paternal grandfather, Bhagmal, and are first cousins.
¶ 4-5, 16The Audit Department objected that land under 1000 sq. yards must be treated as residential and valued at the prevailing abadi rate.
¶ 6On a reference from the Sub-Registrar, the Collector, Charkhi Dadri, by order dated 30.11.2018, assessed deficient stamp duty of Rs. 2,28,670/- and registration fee of Rs. 14,950/-.
¶ 6The Commissioner, Rohtak Division, dismissed the statutory appeal on 15.10.2019.
¶ 6The petitioner challenged these orders and the Financial Commissioner's clarification dated 29.12.2008 on Article 55 of Schedule I-A.
¶ 1, 7-8The petitioner contended that the clarification extends concessional treatment to transfers by female relatives (e.g., widowed mother, bhanja, bhanji, bhabhi) but not to male descendants, and is therefore discriminatory under Article 15(1) and violative of Article 14.
¶ 1, 7-8The State contended that the deed falls under Article 55(b), and that land below 1000 sq. yards is treated as residential.
¶ 10-1102Issues
i.1. Whether a release deed executed between first cousins falls within Article 55(a) of Schedule I-A (concessional duty of Rs. 15/-) or Article 55(b) (duty as a conveyance on market value) of the Indian Stamp (Haryana Amendment) Act, 2000.
¶ 2 · ¶ 16-17, 22ii.2. Whether the clarification dated 29.12.2008 of the Financial Commissioner, which extends concessional treatment to certain female-relative transfers, is discriminatory and violative of Articles 14 and 15(1) of the Constitution.
¶ 7-8 · ¶ 21iii.3. Whether the impugned orders of the Collector and the Commissioner suffer from illegality, perversity, or jurisdictional error warranting interference under Articles 226/227.
¶ 2303Law Applied
The Court applied Article 55 of Schedule I-A to the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, as substituted by the Indian Stamp (Haryana Amendment) Act, 2000 (Haryana Act No. 10 of 2000). Sub-clause (a) grants a concessional duty of Rs. 15/- only where ancestral property is released in favour of enumerated relatives (brother, sister, son, daughter, father, mother, spouse, grandchildren, nephew, niece, or coparcener of the renouncer), and sub-clause (b) is a residuary entry imposing conveyance duty under Article 23(a) on the market value of the interest renounced.
¶ 13-15Nomenclature is not conclusive. A deed of release may operate as a conveyance or gift under Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, as relied upon in Kuppuswamy Chettiar v. A.S.P.A. Arumugam Chettiar, AIR 1967 SC 1395.
¶ 18Section 2(10) of the Stamp Act defines "conveyance" more widely than "sale" under Section 54 of the TPA.
¶ 19Section 9(1)(a) of the Stamp Act permits the State Government, by rule or order published in the Gazette, to reduce or remit duty, and the Financial Commissioner lacks competence through administrative circular to alter the statutory categories in Article 55(a).
¶ 20Articles 14, 15(1), 226 and 227 of the Constitution governed the constitutional challenge and the scope of writ review.
¶ 21, 23Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Stamp Act, 1899 Section 2Section 9
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 123Section 54
04Reasoning
The Court first held that the petitioner, as a first cousin, does not fall within any relationship enumerated in Article 55(a).
¶ 16The Court rejected the "coparcener" limb because the petitioner neither pleaded nor proved that the land was unpartitioned joint family coparcenary property, as opposed to property held by separate co-sharers or collaterals.
¶ 16The Court declined to decide whether the deed was a true release or a conveyance, reasoning that the outcome is the same either way: on the petitioner's own case the deed falls under Article 55(b), and if treated as a conveyance under Article 23(a) the duty is identical.
¶ 19Because the instrument falls within the residuary category, the petitioner could not claim the benefit of the concessional clause, and the constitutional challenge to the 2008 clarification became academic and was not adjudicated.
¶ 20-21The Court noted that the Financial Commissioner cannot amend the statutory categories through a circular, but observed that this issue was not raised before it.
¶ 20The Court did not separately rule on the State's contention that land below 1000 sq. yards must be valued as abadi land.
The Court found no perversity, illegality or jurisdictional error in the Collector's and Commissioner's orders.
¶ 2305Holding
A release deed executed between cousins is not covered by Article 55(a) and is chargeable under Article 55(b) of Schedule I-A, as amended by Haryana Act No. 10 of 2000.
¶ 17, 22The Court did not adjudicate the constitutional validity of the Financial Commissioner's clarification dated 29.12.2008, as the petitioner could not challenge it once the instrument fell within the residuary entry.
¶ 21The Court found no grounds for interference with the orders of the Collector (30.11.2018) and the Commissioner (15.10.2019) under Articles 226/227.
¶ 23The writ petition was dismissed, and pending applications were disposed of.
¶ 24-25Original Court PDF
Hari SinghvsState Of Haryana And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
