01Facts
The petitioner filed a return for AY 2014-15. A search under Section 132(1) was conducted on 28.09.2017, and an assessment was completed under Section 153A read with Section 143(3) on 24.12.2019.
¶ 3, 21The Assessing Officer made additions for alleged unexplained investment in house construction, based on a Departmental Valuation Officer (DVO) report.
¶ 3, 21The parties' accounts differ on the original return date: the petitioner states 17.07.2014, while the respondents state 08.08.2018.
¶ 3, 10The CIT(A) deleted the additions on 30.11.2023, holding that no incriminating material had been found during the search, relying on PCIT v. Abhisar Buildwell.
¶ 4, 11, 21Thereafter, a show-cause notice under Section 148A(b) was issued on 13.03.2024 (the respondents say 12.03.2024) solely on the basis of the DVO report.
¶ 4, 12, 22The Section 148A(d) order and Section 148 notice followed on 29.04.2024.
¶ 4, 12, 22The petitioner filed a return declaring the originally disclosed income and then filed objections on 11.08.2025, alleging the use of CPWD rates instead of State PWD rates, which would bring the escapement below the Rs. 50 lakh threshold under Section 149(1)(a).
¶ 5, 7The objections were rejected by order dated 11.09.2025, and a notice under Section 142(1) was issued on 25.07.2025.
¶ 2, 5The petitioner challenged these actions by writ petition. The respondents objected that an efficacious alternative statutory remedy was available.
¶ 13–1502Issues
i.1. Whether a writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable despite the availability of an alternative statutory remedy, where the challenge goes to the assumption of jurisdiction.
¶ 17–20ii.2. Whether reassessment proceedings can be sustained where the initiation rests solely on the DVO's opinion, which is not "information" under Section 147/148 of the Act.
¶ 22–24iii.3. Whether the Revenue was required to consider the objection that State PWD rates, rather than CPWD rates, should have been applied, and whether the consequential limitation under Section 149 was affected.
¶ 25–28iv.4. Whether the impugned order disposing of the objections, which was non-speaking and failed to consider binding precedent, is legally sustainable.
¶ 29–32, 35–3603Law Applied
The Court applied Sections 132, 148A, 148, 149(1)(a), 153A, 143(3) and 142(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, to the reassessment process.
¶ 2–3, 33Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trade Marks (1998) 8 SCC 1 holds that an alternative remedy is not an absolute bar where proceedings are without jurisdiction, natural justice is violated, fundamental rights are enforced, or vires are challenged.
¶ 17Radha Krishan Industries v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2021) 6 SCC 771 treats exhaustion of remedies as a rule of policy and discretion, and CIT v. Chhabil Das Agarwal (2014) 1 SCC 603 was distinguished.
¶ 14, 17, 18ACIT v. Dhariya Construction Co. (2010) 328 ITR 515 (SC) holds that the DVO's opinion per se is not "information" for reopening under Section 147, and the AO must independently apply mind to material and form a belief.
¶ 22–23, 24CIT, Ajmer v. Sunita Mansingha (2017) 393 ITR 121 (SC) holds that local PWD rates, not CPWD rates, are to be applied for cost of construction.
¶ 25–26GKN Driveshafts (India) Ltd. v. ITO (2003) 259 ITR 19 (SC) requires a speaking order disposing of objections to reasons before the assessment proceeds.
¶ 29Kranti Associates v. Masood Ahmed Khan (2010) 9 SCC 496 makes reasons an essential component of natural justice and application of mind.
¶ 31Sachin Panchal (D.B. CWP No. 14368/2025) was distinguished, with the Court holding that extended limitation under the amended Section 149 does not cure the absence of a valid jurisdictional foundation.
¶ 33Provisions in the judgment · 16
Income Tax Act, 1961 16 provisions
Section 132Section 139Section 142Section 142ASection 142ASection 143Section 147Section 148Section 148Section 148ASection 148ASection 149Section 149Section 153ASection 153CSection 260A04Reasoning
The challenge went to the Assessing Officer's jurisdiction, including the initiation of reassessment beyond limitation, so the Whirlpool exception applied and the alternative remedy objection failed.
¶ 19–20The reassessment rested exclusively on the DVO report. Under Dhariya Construction, that report was not valid "information," and the record did not show that the AO independently applied mind to any other material.
¶ 23–24, 35The PWD-rate objection was not a technical point. It went to whether the escaped income exceeded the Rs. 50 lakh threshold under Section 149(1)(a) and therefore whether the notices were time-barred.
¶ 27The Revenue could not dismiss the PWD-rate objection without reasoned consideration.
¶ 28The impugned order disposed of these objections in a cryptic and mechanical manner, did not engage with Dhariya Construction, and failed the speaking-order requirement under GKN Driveshafts.
¶ 30–32Sachin Panchal did not give the AO an unrestricted power to reopen, and the Revenue still had to prove compliance with the statutory conditions and limitation.
¶ 33The Court expressly declined to decide the actual cost of construction, confining itself to the legality of the assumption of jurisdiction.
¶ 3405Holding
The writ petition is maintainable despite the alternative remedy, because the challenge goes to the root of jurisdiction.
¶ 17–20Reassessment cannot be sustained solely on the DVO report without independent application of mind.
¶ 23–24, 35The objection on the applicability of State PWD rates and its effect on limitation required reasoned consideration, which was not given.
¶ 27–28, 35The order dated 29.04.2024 under Section 148A(d), the Section 148 notice, the subsequent reassessment proceedings, and the Section 142(1) notice dated 25.07.2025 are quashed and set aside. The order is applied mutatis mutandis to all connected petitions, and the Revenue is directed to act in accordance with the statute and Supreme Court precedent. No order as to costs.
¶ 36–38Original Court PDF
MAHAVEER KUMAR JAIN (AY 2014-15) S/O LATE KALYAN MAL JAINvsDEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
