01Facts
The plaintiff (Ramchandra Gupta, now deceased, represented by his legal heirs) owned Plot No. 73, Rajamal Ka Talab, Jaipur.
On 31.01.1975 he executed a registered instrument (Ex. P-1) placing the plot in the defendants' possession for ₹19,999 on terms that the defendants would enjoy the property, that the plaintiff could redeem only after four years, and that the mortgagee would have no right to convert possession into ownership.
¶ 2, 16On 21.09.1975 the parties executed an agreement (Ex. P-2, the bikraranama) for sale of the plot at ₹1,02,500.
¶ 13, 15, 16The ₹19,999 mortgage amount was adjusted against the price, further sums of ₹15,700 and ₹5,100 were paid, and the balance of ₹61,000 was to be paid on registration within four months.
¶ 13, 15, 16No registered sale deed was executed.
¶ 13, 15, 16The plaintiff sued for redemption, contending that P-1 remained a mortgage and that P-2 was merely an unregistered agreement.
¶ 2The Trial Court (16.12.2003) decreed the suit: it held the mortgage subsisting, permitted redemption on payment of ₹19,999, and allowed the plaintiff to seek a final decree for execution of a sale deed.
¶ 3, 5, 14The defendants appealed under Section 96 CPC.
¶ 2902Issues
i.1. Whether Ex. P-1 is a mortgage deed or a conditional sale, and whether the defendants' rights under it survive after the parties executed the P-2 agreement.
¶ 11, 15ii.2. Whether the unregistered agreement to sell (Ex. P-2) extinguished the plaintiff's equity of redemption under Section 60 TPA, so that the mortgage ceased to exist.
¶ 11, 17, 21iii.3. Whether the Trial Court was correct in holding that the mortgage subsisted and that the plaintiff could redeem and recover the property on payment of ₹19,999.
¶ 11, 14, 25iv.4. Whether a fresh final decree for execution of a sale deed, and mesne profits, were available to the plaintiff.
¶ 25–2803Law Applied
Section 60 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, which confers a right to redeem a mortgage, subject to the proviso that the right is not extinguished by the act of the parties or by decree of court.
¶ 15Section 54 TPA, under which a contract for sale of immovable property creates no interest in the property, and a sale of tangible immovable property of ₹100 or more requires a registered instrument.
¶ 15, 18Vayyaeti Srinivasrao v. Gaineedi Jagajyothi (2026 INSC 59), in which the Supreme Court held that an agreement to sell is not compulsorily registrable under Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908.
¶ 18Soni Lalji Jetha v. Soni Kalidas Devchand (1966) and Hamzabi v. Syed Karimuddin (2000), which hold that a mortgagor may sell the mortgaged property to the mortgagee, merging the mortgage estate, and that part performance of such a contract can extinguish the equity of redemption.
¶ 22The principle that a mortgagee's estate ends where the mortgage is redeemed or merged, and the sale price may be adjusted against the mortgage money.
¶ 21Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 60Section 54
Registration Act, 1908 Section 47Section 17
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 41Section 151Section 96
04Reasoning
The Court held that P-1 was a mortgage with possession, and that its terms gave the plaintiff a right to redeem but also permitted sale on specified terms.
¶ 16It found that P-2 was a settlement under which the parties agreed to convert the mortgage into a sale: the ₹19,999 mortgage money was adjusted against the sale price, and the plaintiff accepted the balance.
¶ 17, 21Because both parties accepted and acted on P-2, the mortgage was merged and extinguished through the parties' own act, bringing the case within the proviso to Section 60 TPA.
¶ 21–22The Court rejected the Trial Court's view that the mortgage survived, holding that a mortgage cannot be treated as subsisting merely because a sale agreement was not registered, since Section 54 TPA makes an agreement to sell create no interest in the property.
¶ 15, 18, 20It also held that an unregistered P-2 does not affect the mortgagor's binding acceptance of the transaction, and that the absence of a registered sale deed does not revive the redemption right.
¶ 22On the price issue, the Court found that the Trial Court's valuation of the property at ₹19,999, against the agreed price of ₹1,02,500, was not sustainable.
¶ 20, 25It declined to grant mesne profits, because the property was not owned by the plaintiff and the plaintiff could not claim them in such circumstances.
¶ 26An application under Section 151 CPC to reserve mesne profits was rejected.
¶ 28The defendants did not file a counterclaim or a registered-deed plea for specific performance, so the Court did not direct registration of a sale deed.
¶ 2305Holding
The mortgage under P-1 was extinguished by the parties' execution of the P-2 agreement, which adjusted the mortgage money against the sale price, so the plaintiff had no right to redeem.
¶ 21–22The Trial Court's finding that the mortgage subsisted, and its direction permitting redemption on payment of ₹19,999 and a final decree for a sale deed, were set aside.
¶ 25, 29The appeal under Section 96 CPC was allowed and the judgment and decree dated 16.12.2003 were set aside.
¶ 29The plaintiff was left free to pursue recovery of the balance sale consideration from the defendants in separate proceedings.
¶ 27Parties were directed to bear their own costs.
¶ 29Original Court PDF
SMT SHANTI RANI W/O SHRI KISHAN LALJI,vsRAMCHANDRA GUPTA S/O SHRI SUKHDEV,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
