01Facts
The respondent, a Sub-Inspector appointed on 23.11.1996, was promoted as Inspector on 30.09.2013.
¶ 2–3On 16.12.2017, 29.06.2019 and 18.06.2021 he was awarded three minor penalties of censure under Rule 14(i) of the Rajasthan Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1958 ("Rules of 1958").
¶ 3He appealed; the Appellate Authority granted an interim order.
¶ 4A combined seniority list dated 26.04.2022 placed him at Serial No. 58.
¶ 4When the Police Headquarters sought his record for promotion to the Rajasthan Police Service (Junior Scale), he filed S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 13239/2024.
¶ 4–5The learned Single Judge allowed consideration, relying on Pradeep Singh Charan and Raghuveer Singh and holding that the circular dated 04.06.2008 cannot deny seniority-cum-merit consideration on account of censure or withholding of increment.
¶ 5–6The State filed a special appeal, while the Government issued a further circular on 22.10.2024.
¶ 7, 12Finding a conflict on whether minor penalties within seven years bar promotion, the Division Bench referred two questions to a Full Bench on 27.08.2025.
¶ 802Issues
i.1. Whether a Government servant who has suffered censure or stoppage of one grade increment without cumulative effect (minor penalties under Rule 14 of the Rules of 1958) within seven years can be considered for promotion.
¶ 1, Part II(I) · ¶ 30, 39ii.2. Whether, where promotion is on seniority-cum-merit criteria, a penalty awarded within seven years can be taken into account to deny promotion.
¶ 1, Part II(II) · ¶ 38, 39iii.3. Whether a circular issued by the State can create a bar to promotion that the statutory Rules do not provide.
¶ 1303Law Applied
Rule 14 of the Rules of 1958 lists censure and withholding of increments or promotion as penalties, prescribes no period of ineligibility for promotion after a minor penalty, and its Explanation (iii) excludes non-promotion only where the case has been "considered" for a post for which the employee is eligible.
¶ 9–10, 15, 17Rule 15(2) requires Public Service Commission consultation for penalties other than censure and withholding of increments.
¶ 16Rule 27(1) of the Rajasthan Police Service Rules, 1954 provides for selection on seniority-cum-merit, and no provision makes censure a disqualification.
¶ 11Sant Ram Sharma (1967) and Guman Singh (1971) hold that executive instructions may fill gaps but cannot amend or supersede statutory Rules.
¶ 19–21Sarva U.P. Gramin Bank v. Manoj Kumar Chak (2013) holds that a penalty cannot be made a threshold disqualification by circular, while the DPC may consider penalties in assessing suitability.
¶ 23K.V. Jankiraman (1991) holds that there is no right to promotion, only a right to be considered, and that the whole record, including penalties, may be weighed; B.V. Sivaiah (1998) explains the meaning of seniority-cum-merit.
¶ 31–32Shankar Lal Parmar (2011) and Ucchab Lal Chhanwal (2014) were also relied upon.
¶ 27, 29, 33The Division Bench decisions in Dr. Ashok Singhvi (2013) and Manoj Kumar Machra (2022) were relied upon.
¶ 24–25, 34–36Provisions in the judgment · 1
the said Memorandum (alias, unresolved) Section 3
04Reasoning
Withholding of promotion is an enumerated penalty under Rule 14(ii), which can be imposed only by the disciplinary authority following Rule 17.
¶ 14, 17A seven-year bar operating through the circulars of 26.07.2006 and 04.06.2008 therefore imposes a penalty without the procedure, notice, or time limits that the Rules prescribe for enhancement.
¶ 17–18Because the Rules do not disqualify censured employees, the circulars impermissibly supplant the Rules.
¶ 20–23The State's own circular dated 22.10.2024 accepts that promotion should not be deferred on account of censure.
¶ 21Under K.V. Jankiraman and Manoj Kumar Chak, the DPC may consider a penalty as part of the overall service record in judging minimum merit and suitability.
¶ 31–37The penalty therefore affects suitability assessment but cannot operate as an automatic bar or automatic finding of unsuitability.
¶ 37–38Earlier decisions (Raghuveer Singh, Pradeep Singh Charan, Dr. Ashok Singhvi, Manoj Kumar Machra) are consistent with this reasoning.
¶ 24–2605Holding
The Full Bench answered Question 1 in the affirmative: a Government servant who suffered censure or withholding of one grade increment without cumulative effect under Rule 14(i) and 14(ii) within seven years can be considered for promotion, and unless the statutory Rules themselves prescribe a disqualification, a circular cannot exclude an otherwise eligible officer from the zone of consideration.
¶ 30, 39The Full Bench answered Question 2 by holding that, under seniority-cum-merit, a penalty within seven years may be considered by the DPC as part of the overall record in judging minimum suitability. However, a minor penalty does not by itself create an automatic bar or an automatic finding of unsuitability, and it cannot be an automatic ground for denying promotion merely because a circular provides so.
¶ 38–39The reference was disposed of accordingly, and the matter is to be placed before the appropriate roster Bench to decide the writ petition in light of these answers.
¶ 40–41Original Court PDF
STATE OF RAJASTHANvsAJAY KANT RATUDI (SHARMA) S/O SHRI ANUSUYA PRASAD RATUDI,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
