01Facts
The petitioner, a landowner, executed a lease with Indian Oil Corporation Limited (IOCL) dated 16.03.2004 for 19 years and 11 months to operate a petroleum outlet, along with a dealership agreement dated 11.11.2008.
¶ 2Clause 1(j) provided for renewal up to 2034 "for which separate Lease deed shall be signed by both parties," and the word "automatic" was struck off by consent.
¶ 3, 53The lease expired by efflux of time on 15.02.2024.
¶ 2, 52The petitioner communicated closure of the outlet and demanded removal of fixtures and stock and handover of possession on 01.03.2024, 02.03.2024, 05.03.2024 and 14.05.2024.
¶ 4–5, 58IOCL remitted half-month rent for February 2024 and Rs. 25,899.52 on 13.03.2024; the petitioner returned the latter by demand draft.
¶ 5, 58IOCL filed Civil Suit No. 33/2024 seeking relief on renewal. The petitioner's Section 8 application in that suit, under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 ("the 1996 Act"), was allowed on 23.09.2024, and the order became final.
¶ 6–7IOCL's Section 9 application was dismissed on 07.11.2025, the Commercial Court noting the absence of proof of service of IOCL's alleged renewal notices dated 16.10.2023 and 12.01.2024.
¶ 8IOCL invoked arbitration (notice dated 13.05.2025; Arbitration Application No. 108/2025 pending).
¶ 7, 23Interim removal directions of 23.02.2026 were set aside by the Division Bench, and the Supreme Court, on 17.09.2026, relegated the parties to this Court for merits adjudication.
¶ 9, 4302Issues
i.1. Whether the arbitration clause in the lease, together with the petitioner's own Section 8 application in the civil suit, bars maintainability of the writ petition under Article 226.
¶ 29, 33–34ii.2. Whether the petitioner is estopped from maintaining the writ petition by its prior Section 8 conduct.
¶ 44–46iii.3. Whether the lease dated 16.03.2004 stood validly renewed beyond 15.02.2024, or IOCL continues in occupation without a subsisting lease.
¶ 51iv.4. Whether IOCL, a public sector instrumentality, can be directed to restore possession of the land in writ proceedings, notwithstanding the arbitration clause.
¶ 38–41, 6203Law Applied
The court relied on Section 5 (no judicial intervention except as provided in Part I) and Section 8 (referral to arbitration) of the 1996 Act, read with Section 2(1)(e) to hold that "Court" does not include the High Court's Article 226 jurisdiction, so neither provision is an absolute bar to writ relief.
¶ 31–32, 34The court applied the settled principle that alternative remedies are a rule of discretion, not compulsion, and that writs lie in contractual matters against State instrumentalities where action is arbitrary or where the case warrants public law relief (Harbanslal Sahnia v. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd., (2003) 2 SCC 107; ABL International Ltd. v. ECGC, (2004) 3 SCC 553; Unitech Ltd. v. TSIIC, (2021) 16 SCC 35; UPPTCL v. CG Power, (2021) 6 SCC 15).
¶ 35–36The court relied on National Company v. Territory Manager, BPCL, (2021) 13 SCC 121, which directed a petroleum corporation to vacate and pay market rent after lease expiry, and Hindustan Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. v. Dolly Das, (1999) 4 SCC 450.
¶ 39–41On renewal, the court applied the distinction between extension and renewal in State of U.P. v. Lalji Tandon, (2004) 1 SCC 1, holding that where a fresh lease deed is contractually required, a renewal without it does not come into existence.
¶ 55–56The court applied the principle that a lease must be read as a whole.
¶ 59The court applied the principle that estoppel cannot defeat a substantive legal right.
¶ 46Arbitrability was addressed through Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading Corp., (2021) 2 SCC 1 and Brij Raj Oberoi v. Secretary, Tourism and Civil Aviation, (2022) 17 SCC 81.
¶ 48–49Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 2Section 5Section 8Section 9Section 11Section 17Section 21Section 37
04Reasoning
The court held that the arbitration clause, though binding for contractual monetary disputes, cannot shield IOCL's continued occupation after expiry of the lease. Because restoration of possession of private land is a distinct relief, it was held to fall outside the arbitral mandate.
¶ 38–39, 50, 62The petitioner's Section 8 application did not waive its constitutional remedy, since the order merely relegated disputes within the arbitration agreement and did not adjudicate renewal.
¶ 44–45The pending Arbitration Application No. 108/2025 was held not to justify keeping the writ in abeyance, as the two proceedings operate in distinct fields.
¶ 47On renewal, the court found that Clause 1(j), read as a whole with the ink-inserted requirement of a "separate lease deed," required execution of a fresh deed for renewal, and that the deletion of "automatic" confirmed that renewal was not unilateral.
¶ 53–54, 59IOCL's claimed notices of 16.10.2023 and 12.01.2024 were unproven, as the Commercial Court had noted, and IOCL placed no material before the court.
¶ 57The petitioner's immediate return of the rent remittance and repeated closure demands weighed against any implied renewal.
¶ 58Given the expiry and the absence of a perfected renewal, the court found IOCL's continued occupation unjustified for a public sector body bound to act fairly, and it followed National Company in granting possession relief. Claims for rent, market rent, dealership dues, damages, interest and the value of petroleum stock were left open for the arbitral tribunal.
¶ 60–6105Holding
The writ petition is maintainable, and the preliminary objection under Article 226 and the Section 8 application (I.A. No. 2/2025) are rejected insofar as they seek restoration of possession and removal of IOCL's installations.
¶ 63The lease dated 16.03.2004 expired on 15.02.2024 and was not validly renewed, as no separate lease deed was executed.
¶ 52, 56–57The court directed: (i) IOCL to vacate the land at Ajmer Road, Madanganj, Kishangarh and hand over peaceful and vacant possession within 60 days of receipt of the certified copy; (ii) IOCL to remove all fixtures, equipment, installations and structures and restore the land, in coordination with PESO and in compliance with safety norms.
¶ 64(i)–(ii)The parties may pursue rent, market/occupation charges, dealership dues, damages, interest and the value of unsold stock before the arbitral tribunal in Arbitration Application No. 108/2025, which must decide these claims independently of the court's observations on possession.
¶ 64(iii)Original Court PDF
SUMA MINERALS PRIVATE LIMITEDvsINDIAN OIL CORPORATION LIMITED
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
