01Facts
The respondent, an Artist appointed on 30.06.1995, was transferred to Udaipur in 2003 and then back to Jaipur in 2006 as a special case. At both places she was posted in the Editorial Department.
¶ 3–4After advisory and warning letters, two charge sheets (03.10.2007 and 04.12.2007) containing eight charges under Clause 20(2) of the Certified Standing Orders were issued.
¶ 5–8Both charge sheets were entrusted to the same Enquiry Officer, Mr. Rupin Kala, an advocate, in common proceedings to which the employee did not object at that stage.
¶ 9The Presenting Officer deposed as a management witness.
¶ 11–12, 27The employee was refused a Defence Assistant of her choice and documents, and she stopped attending after 19.01.2008.
¶ 10–12The Enquiry Officer held all charges proved on 25.12.2008.
¶ 13The Disciplinary Authority removed the employee on 27.02.2009.
¶ 14A terminal benefits cheque of ₹1,56,821.20, including gratuity, was encashed.
¶ 15The Labour Court held the enquiry fair by interim order dated 24.03.2015 and answered the reference against the employee by award dated 31.05.2016.
¶ 16–18The Enquiry Officer had by then appeared as management counsel defending the enquiry before the Labour Court and the writ court.
¶ 31The Single Judge quashed the enquiry, the removal order and the Labour Court orders, and directed reinstatement with full back wages.
¶ 20, 2402Issues
i.1. Whether the domestic enquiry stood vitiated by a real likelihood of bias, given the Enquiry Officer's later role as management counsel defending his own findings?
¶ 27(a), 28–36ii.2. Whether the employee's abstention from the enquiry, or her failure to object earlier, saves the enquiry from bias?
¶ 27(b), 37–40iii.3. Whether the Single Judge validly recorded a final finding of victimisation on the merits of the charges?
¶ 27(c), 41–4303Law Applied
Bias means a departure from even-handed justice, requiring a real likelihood of bias rather than a mere apprehension, assessed from the standpoint of a reasonable and honest person, as laid down in State of Punjab v. V.K. Khanna, (2001) 2 SCC 330, and International Airports Authority v. K.D. Bali, (1988) 2 SCC 360, and Ranjit Thakur v. Union of India, as cited therein.
¶ 28–29An employer may engage a lawyer as Enquiry Officer without bias being presumed, following Saran Motors v. Vishwanath and Dalmia Dadri Cement v. Murari Lal Bikaneria.
¶ 30, 34Bias, unlike a defect in opportunity, concerns the neutrality of the forum, so participation or abstention by the employee cannot cure it; waiver requires knowledge of the bias-causing facts, as distinguished in U.D. Lama v. State of Sikkim, (1997) 1 SCC 111.
¶ 37–39A finding on victimisation requires examination of the merits of all charges, and a finding that the charges are unproved does not follow from the vitiation of the enquiry.
¶ 42–43On remedies, the employer may prove misconduct on fresh evidence before the Labour Court, as in Shankar Chakravarti v. Britannia Biscuit, (1979) 3 SCC 371, Shambhu Nath Goyal v. Bank of Baroda, (1983) 4 SCC 491, and KSRTC v. Lakshmidevamma, (2001) 5 SCC 433, or may hold a fresh enquiry from the defective stage, as in Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar, (1993) 4 SCC 727.
¶ 44–45Back wages are not automatic: the employee must assert non-employment, shifting the burden to the employer, and the court may mould relief on the facts, as in Deepali Gundu Surwase v. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya, (2013) 10 SCC 324, and Hindustan Tin Works v. Employees, (1979) 2 SCC 80.
¶ 4704Reasoning
The court accepted that mere engagement of a lawyer as Enquiry Officer does not establish bias.
¶ 30The Enquiry Officer subsequently acted as management counsel, defending his own findings and the removal order before the Labour Court and the writ court. This was a matter of record and not disputed. Since the Labour Court was reviewing the fairness of that very enquiry, an adjudicator who later became advocate for his own verdict gave a reasonable person grounds to doubt his open mind. The apprehension was therefore not fanciful, and the V.K. Khanna test was met.
¶ 31–33The court distinguished Saran Motors and Dalmia Dadri on the ground that neither concerned an Enquiry Officer who later defended the enquiry.
¶ 34The Labour Court's failure to address this was an error apparent on the face of the record, justifying interference under Article 226.
¶ 36The bias was not known until after the enquiry, and the employee raised it in her 2009 show-cause replies, so waiver failed. Her walkout was relevant only to back wages, not to the validity of the enquiry.
¶ 37–39The Single Judge's victimisation finding rested on one charge (review of editions), while eight charges, including insubordination and refusal to receive communications, were left unexamined. A finding on merits could not rest on one charge, and vitiation of an enquiry does not establish that the charges are disproved.
¶ 41–43Other grievances (Defence Assistant, documents, Presenting Officer as witness) were left open.
¶ 40Because the defect lies in the choice of Enquiry Officer, a fresh enquiry from the appointment stage was the proper remedy. Reinstatement was impractical at about 60 years of age. Full back wages could not be awarded without determining whether the charges are true and whether the employee was gainfully employed. The management had not shown gainful employment, but the employee had also not pleaded non-employment, so these issues required evidence.
¶ 45–4805Holding
The enquiry was vitiated by a real likelihood of bias arising from the Enquiry Officer's later role as management counsel defending his own findings. Abstention and failure to object did not cure the bias.
¶ 31–36, 37–39The finding of victimisation was set aside as premature.
¶ 43The Single Judge's quashing of the enquiry, removal order, and Labour Court orders was upheld.
¶ 49The direction for reinstatement with continuity and full back wages was set aside. The matter was remanded to the Labour Court to inquire into the respondent's gainful employment from removal (27.02.2009) till superannuation, and to pass a fresh order on back wages. If a favourable order is passed, the management shall decide back wages from 27.02.2009 till superannuation, adjusting the ₹1,56,821.20 already paid. No costs were awarded.
¶ 50(i)–(ii), 51Paras 45 and 49 refer to a fresh enquiry before a neutral Enquiry Officer, while the operative direction at para. 50(i) refers only to a Labour Court inquiry on gainful employment. The scope of any fresh domestic enquiry on the charges is therefore not clearly settled in the operative part.
¶ 45, 49, 50Original Court PDF
MANAGER RAJ PATRIKA PVT LTDvsMS KUMKUM SHARMA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
