01Facts
The Ministry of Power's VGF Scheme for Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS), supported through the PSDF, contemplated tariff-based bidding under the BOO model.
¶ 2.1Respondent No. 3, RVUNL, issued an RfS dated 08.08.2025 for 500 MW/2000 MWh standalone BESS projects in Rajasthan.
¶ 2.2–2.3The RfS and the draft BESPA contained no minimum local content condition.
¶ 2.6The petitioners were declared successful bidders at an identical tariff of Rs. 2,85,000/MW/month.
¶ 2.3A Letter of Intent (03.12.2025) and Letter of Award (19.12.2025) were issued, and the petitioners accepted the LoA on 23.12.2025.
¶ 2.4In two petitions, BESPA was also executed.
¶ 2.4On 24.12.2025 the Ministry of Power issued a communication requiring a minimum 20% local content, including indigenously developed EMS software, in BESS procurements under the VGF Scheme. Clause 6 permitted States, where tenders had been invited without local content stipulations, to obtain bidder undertakings and proceed with award.
¶ 2.7–2.8, 25On 07.01.2026 RVUNL directed successful bidders to comply and furnish an undertaking within seven days.
¶ 2.9All petitioners except MSL Solar (CWP 20211/2026) furnished an undertaking dated 10.01.2026.
¶ 2.10Extensions for PBG and BESPA followed, and the RERC adopted the tariff on 06.03.2026.
¶ 2.11–2.13On 10.04.2026 RVUNL issued a notice calling for PBG and showing cause on forfeiture of bid security.
¶ 2.15–2.16The petitioners challenged the 07.01.2026 communication and the 10.04.2026 notice.
¶ 2.1702Issues
i.1. Whether a writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable against a State instrumentality in a dispute arising from a contractual award, where the grievance concerns public-law fairness and Article 14.
¶ 9–15ii.2. Whether the respondents could impose the 20% local content and indigenous EMS software requirement, introduced by the Ministry's communication of 24.12.2025, upon bidders after the LoA had been issued and accepted (and BESPA executed in two cases).
¶ 8, 16–17, 24–55iii.3. Whether the undertaking dated 10.01.2026 constituted a valid novation or alteration of the concluded contract under Section 62 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
¶ 56–59iv.4. Whether the petitioners' rights were protected by promissory estoppel and legitimate expectation.
¶ 61–70v.5. Whether the notice dated 10.04.2026 and threatened cancellation or forfeiture could be sustained, and what relief should follow.
¶ 75–77, 79, 86–8803Law Applied
ABL International Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation (2004) 3 SCC 553 holds that writs against the State arising from contractual obligations are maintainable in appropriate cases, subject to the Article 14 standard and restraint on disputed facts.
¶ 10Unitech Ltd. v. TSIIC (2021) 16 SCC 35 and UPPTCL v. CG Power (2021) 6 SCC 15 hold that contractual disputes do not oust Article 226 jurisdiction.
¶ 12–13Sections 7 and 10 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, together with Padia Timber (2021) 3 SCC 24, Dresser Rand (2006) 1 SCC 751, and Mihan India Ltd. v. GMR Airports (2022 SCC OnLine SC 574), establish that an unqualified acceptance of an award creates a concluded contract.
¶ 18–21Reliance Energy (2007) 8 SCC 1, W.B. SEB v. Patel Engineering (2001) 2 SCC 451, and Surguja Bricks (2025 SCC OnLine SC 2916) require clarity, certainty, and a level playing field in public procurement.
¶ 38–40Clause 7 of the Public Procurement (Preference to Make in India) Order, 2017 requires local content to be specified in advance and not varied during a procurement transaction.
¶ 32Under Section 62 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, alteration of a contract requires mutual agreement, as held in Citi Bank (2004) 1 SCC 12, Suresh Kumar Wadhwa (2017) 16 SCC 757, BSNL v. BPL Mobile (2008) 13 SCC 597, and DDA v. Joint Action Committee (2008) 2 SCC 672.
¶ 50–54Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills (1979) 2 SCC 409 and IFGL Refractories (2026 SCC OnLine SC 28) govern promissory estoppel, while Hindustan Development Corp. (1993) 3 SCC 499 and Kamdhenu Cattle Feed (1993) 1 SCC 71 govern legitimate expectation.
¶ 62–68Prakash Asphaltings (2026) 4 SCC 310 and Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour (2024) 15 SCC 461 recognise the sanctity of tender conditions and public interest.
¶ 46, 72Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi (1991) 1 SCC 212 recognises the State's duty to act fairly in contract.
¶ 72Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 2Section 7Section 8Section 10Section 62
Electricity Act, 2003 Section 63
04Reasoning
The court rejected the objection that the dispute was purely contractual, holding that the State's duty to act fairly under Article 14 persists in contractual dealings and that the action here had a public-law element affecting procurement integrity.
¶ 9, 14–15A concluded contract existed by 23.12.2025, since the LoA identified the awardee, capacity, tariff and terms, and was accepted unconditionally. PBG and BESPA were only subsequent implementation milestones.
¶ 16–18, 22–23The Ministry's communication of 24.12.2025 came after that acceptance.
¶ 17, 24, 29Clause 6 of that communication contemplated undertakings only before award in tenders not yet awarded, not reopening of concluded awards.
¶ 26–28Clause 1.23 of the LoA, which requires due cognisance of Make in India rules, could not be read as an unlimited power to add substantive obligations after award.
¶ 30–31, 36The local content requirement was a substantive commercial condition affecting sourcing, cost and financial modelling, not a mere clarification.
¶ 35, 42–43The general VGF and GFR obligations did not supply the missing authority.
¶ 44Although the undertaking dated 10.01.2026 was furnished without express reservation, it was given in response to a time-bound direction from the controlling authority and was not a negotiated, informed novation under Section 62. An undertaking could not confer on RVUNL a power it lacked, and estoppel could not validate action contrary to law.
¶ 56–59The 07.01.2026 communication was misleading in suggesting that the Ministry's directions applied to awarded tenders.
¶ 58Promissory estoppel and legitimate expectation were established because the petitioners had participated, furnished bid security, and accepted the LoA on the basis of disclosed conditions, and the respondents identified no overriding public interest.
¶ 65–69The RERC tariff order and the petitioners' no-objection email did not waive the right to challenge the later condition.
¶ 71The petitioners were not excused from their original obligations and had engaged with the process, so the notice could not be treated as a blanket default bar.
¶ 75–76A mechanical cancellation or forfeiture that proceeded on the impermissible condition could not be sustained.
¶ 77The interference was limited to the additional condition, and the court disclaimed any review of the tariff or technical specifications.
¶ 80–8105Holding
The writ petitions are maintainable, and the respondents cannot impose the Ministry's 24.12.2025 20% local content and indigenous EMS software requirement on the petitioners under the concluded LoA dated 19.12.2025 or the BESPA.
¶ 18, 60, 85, 88(ii)The communication dated 07.01.2026 is quashed insofar as it imposes that requirement.
¶ 86, 88(i)The notice dated 10.04.2026 is quashed to the extent it seeks coercive action for non-compliance with that requirement. RVUNL must not cancel the allotted BESS capacity or forfeit bid security solely for failing to furnish the undertaking or comply with the additional condition.
¶ 88(iii), 88(iv)The petitioners remain bound by the original RfS and LoA, including PBG/Insurance Surety Bond and BESPA execution, and RVUNL must grant 15 days from receipt of a certified copy to complete those formalities.
¶ 87, 88(v)If the petitioners fail, RVUNL may proceed under the original terms after a reasoned order, but may not treat non-compliance with the local content condition as an independent default.
¶ 88(vi)The RERC tariff adoption orders are undisturbed, and pending applications stand disposed of.
¶ 88(viii), 89Original Court PDF
ULTRAVIBRANT INTEGRATED ENERGY LIMITEDvsSTATE OF RAJASTHAN
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
