01Facts
The petitioner applied for Constable/General Duty in CRPF under Advertisement No. 01/2009 as a general category candidate and scored 43 marks.
pp. 3–4 · ¶ 3He was declared medically unfit in the medical examination of 11.01.2010 but was found fit on review medical held on 26.07.2010.
p. 4 · ¶ 3Because many candidates had 43 marks, he was not appointed, and the respondents communicated that appointment would go to older candidates by letter dated 08.02.2011.
p. 4 · ¶ 3.1In WP(C) No. 2131/2011, the respondents disclosed 65 normal wastage vacancies for general category candidates in 2009.
pp. 4–5 · ¶ 3.2The petitioner's subsequent claim was rejected on 05.02.2015.
p. 5 · ¶ 3.2In WP(C) No. 2497/2015, this Court on 02.03.2016 directed that he be treated as a selected candidate against normal wastage vacancies and offered consequential appointment within three months.
p. 5 · ¶ 3.3The Court noted that 29 of 36 available normal wastage vacancies had been filled, the marks of those appointees were undisclosed, and the petitioner had secured the same marks as the last selected general category candidate.
pp. 5–6 · ¶ 3.4The review petition against that order (No. 142/2016) was dismissed on 24.10.2016.
p. 6 · ¶ 3.5The petitioner was offered appointment by letter dated 20.11.2016 and joined on 31.01.2017.
p. 6 · ¶ 3.6 · p. 7 · ¶ 4He sought seniority and pay fixation at par with his 2009 batch mates, relying on Surendra Narain Singh and Keshab Ch. Paul.
p. 7 · ¶ 3.7The respondents contended that under Rule 8(f) of the CRPF Rules, 1955, seniority runs from the date of first appointment, i.e., 31.01.2017.
p. 7 · ¶ 402Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner, appointed under the 2009 recruitment process pursuant to a judicial direction, is entitled to seniority as per his merit position in the Advertisement No. 01/2009 merit list, notwithstanding Rule 8(f) of the CRPF Rules, 1955.
p. 7 · ¶ 4 · pp. 8–9 · ¶ 6 · pp. 10–11 · ¶ 8ii.2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to notional pay fixation from 2010 and to arrears or other financial benefits at par with his batch mates.
pp. 11–12 · ¶ 9–1003Law Applied
Rule 8(f) of the CRPF Rules, 1955 provides that constables take seniority from the date of first appointment, subject to confirmation.
p. 7 · ¶ 4The CRPF Recruitment Guidelines (Stage V, cl. 3) provide that candidates found fit on review medical are recruited against normal wastage vacancies.
p. 8 · ¶ 6Circular dated 15.07.2005, cl. (n)–(o), and Letter dated 08.09.2005, cl. (9), require vacancies to be kept for temporarily unfit candidates and provide that candidates later found fit are recruited against normal wastage.
pp. 8–9 · ¶ 6The Court relied on its own earlier orders dated 08.11.2014 and 02.03.2016 as having already fixed the petitioner's status as a selected candidate.
p. 9 · ¶ 6C. Jayachandran v. State of Kerala, AIR 2020 SC 3846, which, following Sanjay Dhar and Lakshmana Rao Yadavalli, holds that a wrongfully excluded appointee is deemed appointed along with others and placed in seniority consistent with merit.
pp. 9–10 · ¶ 7A wrongfully non-appointed candidate is entitled to notional seniority from the date he should have been appointed.
pp. 10–11 · ¶ 8Under UPPSC v. Satya Narayan Sheohare, (2009) 5 SCC 473, relief for wrongfully omitted candidates is prospective under the "no work, no pay" principle.
p. 11 · ¶ 9Ranjan Jyoti Sarma v. State of Assam, 2016 5 GLT 489, applies the "next below" rule for seniority, with notional pay from the date of appointment and actual pay from the date of joining.
p. 11 · ¶ 9Provisions in the judgment · 4
Dte letter of even number dated 15/07/2005 (alias, unresolved) Section 3Section 9nSection 0
04Reasoning
Rule 8(f) could not be invoked, because the petitioner's case had already been adjudicated in WP(C) Nos. 2131/2011 and 2497/2015. In those proceedings, the petitioner, having been found fit on review, was directed to be treated as a selected candidate against normal wastage vacancies under the 2005 circulars and guidelines.
p. 9 · ¶ 6Since his non-appointment in 2010 was held to be wrongful, the Jayachandran principle applies: a wrongfully excluded candidate is entitled to seniority from the date he should have been appointed, placing him at par with his batch mates.
pp. 10–11 · ¶ 8Relying on Satya Narayan Sheohare and Ranjan Jyoti Sarma, notional pay fixation from 2010 is allowed, but arrears and actual pay for the period not served are denied on the "no work, no pay" principle.
pp. 11–12 · ¶ 9–10The reasoning distinguishes seniority and notional pay, which follow from the wrongful exclusion, from actual monetary benefits, which depend on actual service.
pp. 11–12 · ¶ 8–1005Holding
Rule 8(f) of the CRPF Rules, 1955 does not bar the claim, because the petitioner was wrongfully denied appointment against 2009 normal wastage vacancies.
p. 9 · ¶ 6 · pp. 10–11 · ¶ 8The respondents are directed to (i) grant the petitioner notional seniority from the date of selection under Advertisement No. 01/2009, at par with his batch mates; and (ii) notionally fix his pay at par with his batch mates from 2010.
p. 11 · ¶ 8 · pp. 11–12 · ¶ 10Actual monetary benefits and arrears are denied for the period not served, and are payable only from the date of joining, i.e., 31.01.2017.
p. 12 · ¶ 10The petition is allowed to the extent indicated. No order as to costs.
p. 12 · ¶ 11Original Court PDF
Force No. 175130032 Constable (Gd) Moinuddin AhmedvsThe Union Of India And 4 Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
