01Facts
The Principal of Gurucharan College, Silchar, advertised posts of Assistant Professor in several subjects, including Bengali, with applications due within 15 days.
pp. 3–4The Bengali post related to roster point 91, reserved for OBC/MOBC candidates. The selection was to follow the relevant office memoranda, and no party alleged any violation of those guidelines.
pp. 3–4Seventeen applications were received, and eight candidates, including the petitioner, were found eligible and called for document verification and interview.
p. 4 · ¶ 6The Director of Higher Education's affidavit gave a different figure (37 applications, 7 called), which the Court attributed to a probable typographical error.
¶ 7–8At least seven candidates received call letters, but only the petitioner appeared on the interview date, 17.11.2022.
p. 4 · ¶ 9The Selection Committee found her fit and forwarded her name through the Governing Body.
pp. 4–5 · ¶ 11On 30.05.2023, the Director kept her case pending because of a complaint that the Hon'ble Minister had recommended for investigation.
p. 5On 12.12.2023, the Director published the approved list, which omitted her name, and two other candidates from the same college's pending list were later appointed.
p. 5On 27.12.2023, the Director permitted re-advertisement of the post, stating that only a single candidate had appeared for interview. The petitioner was informed of this by communication dated 30.05.2024.
pp. 5–6She contended that she was never supplied the complaint and was not heard before the decision was taken.
¶ 3The Director's affidavit alleged no illegality, only a lack of "healthy competition".
¶ 1002Issues
i.1. Whether the cancellation of the selection process and the direction for fresh re-advertisement can be sustained where only the petitioner appeared for a duly conducted interview, all eligible candidates were called, and no illegality was alleged.
¶ 10–12 · pp. 11–12ii.2. Whether the petitioner, who was found fit by the Selection Committee, can be denied appointment because other candidates chose not to appear.
¶ 11, 13–15 · pp. 11–1203Law Applied
The advertisement required selection in accordance with the office memoranda, and no violation of those guidelines was alleged.
pp. 3–4A candidate who is eligible, called for interview, and evaluated cannot be faulted for the absence of other candidates. The "healthy competition" rationale would have merit only if no applications were received or call letters were not dispatched to eligible candidates.
¶ 11–12Applying general principles of equity and fairness, a candidate who has been duly assessed and found fit should not be denied a fair chance of consideration because of the conduct of others.
¶ 13–1404Reasoning
The Court accepted the college's records showing that all eligible candidates were called, that postal receipts existed, and that the petitioner alone appeared.
¶ 6, 9 · p. 4The Court found that the Director's affidavit identified no illegality or irregularity and no leniency shown to the petitioner.
¶ 10Eligibility and qualifications were not disputed, and the Selection Committee had found the petitioner fit.
¶ 14–15The Court held that the non-appearance of others did not vitiate the process, and that the Director's concern about competition, though bona fide, could not justify cancelling a process the petitioner had diligently completed.
¶ 11–13The Court treated the re-advertisement as an unfair penalty on the petitioner, which made the Director's decision unsustainable.
¶ 1405Holding
The cancellation of the selection process and the insistence on a fresh selection, based solely on the absence of other candidates, could not be sustained.
¶ 13–14The writ petition was allowed, and the Director's directions to re-advertise the post were interfered with. The Director was directed to process the Selection Committee's minutes dated 17.11.2022 in accordance with law, and final approval was to be granted within four weeks of receipt of a certified copy, absent any impediment. Any impediment to the petitioner's appointment was to be communicated to her within the same four weeks, with an opportunity to rectify it. Parties were directed to bear their own costs.
¶ 16–18Original Court PDF
Dr Nandita PaulvsThe State Of Assam And 3 Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
