01Facts
The appellant's son ("deceased") held a valid journey ticket for the Chandigarh–Rampur journey by Chandigarh–Lucknow Express on 17.06.2017.
¶ 2The appellant alleged that the deceased accidentally fell from the train near Roorkee Railway Station and sustained fatal injuries.
¶ 2The Railways contested the claim, relying on a DRM inquiry report which concluded there was no evidence that the deceased had fallen from the train.
¶ 2The Tribunal (Railway Claims Tribunal, Principal Bench, Delhi) dismissed the claim by judgment dated 19.08.2020 in OA/II(u)/GZB/2017/332.
¶ 1AW-1 (Usman Ali) stated he purchased his ticket at about 3:45 p.m., whereas the CRIS verification placed on record showed issuance of tickets from Chandigarh at 20:35 and 20:40 hours.
¶ 6By order dated 20.01.2020, the Tribunal directed CRIS verification of Ticket Nos. 96511827 and 96511839.
¶ 8By order dated 10.07.2019, the Tribunal noted that the RPF report recorded seizure of Ticket No. 96511839 from the deceased's body, although the panchnama and other contemporaneous documents recorded no such recovery.
¶ 9The post-mortem report records the cause of death as shock and haemorrhage due to ante-mortem injuries.
¶ 1002Issues
i.1. Whether the deceased was a bona fide passenger holding a valid ticket.
¶ 3 · ¶ 6 · ¶ 11ii.2. Whether the incident constituted an "untoward incident" within the meaning of Section 123(c) of the Railways Act, 1989.
¶ 3 · ¶ 10 · ¶ 11iii.3. Whether the Tribunal properly examined the CRIS verification, the discrepancy in ticket numbers and timings, and the RPF report regarding recovery of the ticket, in light of the other material on record.
¶ 8 · ¶ 9 · ¶ 1103Law Applied
The appeal is maintained under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987.
¶ 1Section 123(c) of the Railways Act, 1989 defines the "untoward incident" that founds a compensation claim.
¶ 3Under Union of India v. Rina Devi, (2019) 3 SCC 572, the claimant bears the initial burden of proving that the deceased was a bona fide passenger, the burden then shifts to the Railways once discharged, and the question must be decided on the evidence on record. The absence of a recovered ticket is not, by itself, conclusive against the claimant.
¶ 7A tribunal's inquiry directions and the contemporaneous documentary record (CRIS verification, RPF report, panchnama, inquest proceedings, and inquiry reports) are material that must be weighed together rather than in isolation.
¶ 8 · ¶ 9 · ¶ 10Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 Section 23
Railways Act, 1989 Section 123
04Reasoning
The Tribunal rejected the claim principally because AW-1's stated time of ticket purchase (about 3:45 p.m.) conflicted with the CRIS timings (20:35 and 20:40 hours) and treated this as rendering AW-1's entire testimony unreliable.
¶ 6Under Rina Devi, a discrepancy regarding purchase time is a relevant circumstance but must be considered together with the documentary verification, not in isolation.
¶ 7 · ¶ 8The Tribunal had not examined the ticket numbers or their corresponding CRIS entries, despite its own direction for CRIS verification of Ticket Nos. 96511827 and 96511839.
¶ 8The Tribunal did not discuss whether the RPF report's recording of ticket seizure from the body, which the panchnama did not corroborate, had been explained, even though it had itself ordered an inquiry on this point.
¶ 9On the untoward incident, the Tribunal relied mainly on the DRM report's finding of no evidence of a fall.
¶ 10The post-mortem finding, while not establishing the precise manner of injury, required consideration alongside the inquest proceedings and inquiry reports.
¶ 10The Tribunal's findings on both bona fide passenger status and untoward incident were not sustainable as recorded, since the CRIS, ticket-discrepancy, RPF and subsequent inquiry material required fuller examination.
¶ 1105Holding
The court did not decide the merits of either issue. It held that the Tribunal's findings on bona fide passenger status and untoward incident "cannot be upheld in their present form" and required a more detailed examination of the material.
¶ 11The impugned judgment dated 19.08.2020 is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the Tribunal to assess the compensation payable in accordance with law. The Tribunal is directed to list the matter on 16.12.2026, and the authorities are to disburse any compensation within two months of receipt of the order.
¶ 12The appeal is allowed and disposed of in these terms.
¶ 13Original Court PDF
Mohd. AhmadvsUnion Of India
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
