01Facts
The deceased, Nishchint Rao, was driving his car with his friend Mayank Dagar (PW2) from Surajkund Road towards Sector 21-C, Faridabad, on 12 October 2019 at about 9:30 a.m.
¶ 1-2An offending vehicle coming from the opposite direction hit the deceased's car in the middle of the road.
¶ 1-2The road had no divider.
¶ 3The site plan showed the offending vehicle veering from its lane towards the middle of the road, while the deceased's car remained approximately in the middle.
¶ 3-4PW2 attributed the deceased's position to a depression on the left side of the road, but his testimony was inconsistent and he could not confirm whether the small car could have avoided it.
¶ 4The offending vehicle's driver alleged in his written statement that the deceased moved to the right, but he did not enter the witness box and no other proof of contributory negligence was led.
¶ 7The deceased was a B.Tech. (2nd year) student at Manav Rachana University, who was allegedly earning Rs. 15,000/- per month through tuitions. No proof of tuition income was placed on record.
¶ 11, 20The Tribunal (MACT, South East, Saket) awarded Rs. 12,49,276/- with 9% interest, after applying a 50% contributory negligence deduction and assessing income on minimum wages of a skilled person in Haryana.
¶ 1, 11, 22The claimants appealed for enhancement and against the 50% deduction. Additional placement records (2022) were admitted, but were objected to by the insurer as unproven.
¶ 12-1302Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in attributing 50% contributory negligence to the deceased, where the insurer did not establish negligence on the part of the deceased.
¶ 7-10ii.2. Whether the notional income of the deceased, a non-graduate student, should be assessed at minimum wages of a skilled worker or at a higher figure based on his potential earnings.
¶ 11, 16-20iii.3. Whether the unproven placement record, adduced as additional evidence, can be relied upon to determine notional income.
¶ 13-15iv.4. Whether the future prospects percentage awarded by the Tribunal (50%) is sustainable in the absence of proof of permanent employment.
¶ 2103Law Applied
The principle that contributory negligence must be proved by the party alleging it and cannot be assumed, as held in Yashwant Krishna Kumbar v. Divisional Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (SLP (C) No. 22599/2024, SC, 25 Nov 2025), where the burden of proving negligence lies on the party alleging it and absent cogent material, no deduction can be sustained.
¶ 8For notional income, the Court referred to Uttar Pradesh SRTC v. Seema Rustagi (2026:DHC:4289), where income was assessed on the basis of documentary evidence of batchmates' actual employment pay slips.
¶ 16-17Navjot Singh v. Harpreet Singh (2020 SCC OnLine SC 1562), where the Supreme Court, under Article 142, fixed notional income of Rs. 10,000/- per month for an engineering student instead of unskilled minimum wages.
¶ 16-17ICICI Lombard v. Dharmender Khurana (2026:DHC:5199), which assessed notional income of students on the basis of provisional offer letters and testimony of the employer.
¶ 18-19The rule from National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680, under which future prospects are set at 40% where permanent employment is not proven.
¶ 21The principle that unproven documents cannot be relied upon absent a supporting witness.
¶ 1504Reasoning
The site plan and PW2's testimony showed that the offending vehicle crossed into the deceased's side of the road.
¶ 5The Tribunal had misread the site plan in the award by treating the deceased's car as the vehicle that changed direction.
¶ 6The insurer, which bore the burden, led no admissible evidence, because the offending driver did not testify and PW2's account of the depression was inconsistent and inconclusive.
¶ 4, 7-8Relying on Yashwant Krishna Kumbar, the Court held the 50% deduction unsustainable and set it aside.
¶ 8-10On income, the placement record was excluded because it was unproven and no college witness supported it, despite its admission as additional evidence.
¶ 13-15The Court distinguished Seema Rustagi, where actual pay slips of batchmates were on record, and found Navjot Singh to be a guide for a student's potential income.
¶ 16-17The Court, taking into account the Dharmender Khurana principles and the mother's testimony that the deceased taught 5-6 students daily at Rs. 1,000 per student, fixed notional income at Rs. 15,000/- per month, reasoning that but for the accident the deceased would have become an engineer in permanent employment.
¶ 18-20Given the absence of proof of permanent employment, future prospects were reduced from 50% to 40%.
¶ 21Applying a multiplier of 18 and deducting personal expenses at one-half, the Court recomputed the loss of dependency at Rs. 30,24,000/-, and total compensation at Rs. 31,45,000/- (with consortium, estate and funeral heads unchanged) with no contributory negligence deduction.
¶ 2205Holding
The 50% contributory negligence finding was unsustainable for want of proof and was set aside.
¶ 8-10Notional income should be assessed at Rs. 15,000/- per month on the basis of the deceased's potential as a student and the mother's testimony, and the unproven placement record could not be relied upon.
¶ 15, 20Future prospects were reduced to 40%.
¶ 21The Court enhanced compensation from Rs. 12,49,276/- to Rs. 31,45,000/-, an enhancement of Rs. 18,95,724/-, with 9% interest.
¶ 22-23The enhanced amount with 9% interest from the date of filing the petition is to be deposited before the MACT within six weeks. Rs. 10,00,000/- is to be released to the claimants within two weeks thereafter, and the balance is to be placed in FDRs of Rs. 25,000/- each with staggered maturities, with interest credited to the claimants' savings account.
¶ 24The appeal is disposed of accordingly.
¶ 25Original Court PDF
Smt Sunita Devi & Anr.vsTata Aig General Insurance Co. Ltd & Anr.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
