01Facts
The plaintiff, K.K. Arora, a Canadian citizen, claimed sole ownership of D-1/10, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi (the "suit property"), inherited from his mother in 1996 and mutated in his name by the DDA.
¶ 3, 79The defendants, Ashok Puri (Defendant No. 1) and Akshay Puri (Defendant No. 2, the appellant), occupied the property with the plaintiff's permission from around 2000-01, granted out of love and affection for his sister, Promila Puri, without rent.
¶ 5-6, 83, 85After Promila Puri's death in 2013, the plaintiff proposed a rent agreement, which was not executed. He then withdrew permission by letter dated 08.03.2018 and email dated 10.03.2018, requiring vacation by 15.04.2018.
¶ 8-11, 88He filed CS No. 463/2018 for possession and mesne profits at Rs. 2,50,000 per month, later claimed at Rs. 3,00,000 per month via an application under S. 151 CPC supported by lease deeds of nearby properties.
¶ 2, 13, 29, 157The defence was struck off on 29.10.2018 and restored on 28.11.2022.
¶ 14The defendants pleaded a December 1999 oral family settlement, a 2013 post-demise agreement, a Will dated 11.04.2001, and, in the alternative, adverse possession.
¶ 16-25, 90-94The trial court decreed possession and mesne profits at Rs. 3,00,000 per month "till realisation" under O. XII R. 6 read with O. XV CPC on 10.02.2026.
¶ 33The appellant challenged the decree in RFA 327/2026.
¶ 34-3502Issues
i.1. Whether the defendants acquired ownership of the suit property under the alleged 1999 mutual/family settlement, including through payment of consideration.
¶ 95-116ii.2. Whether the defendants acquired ownership under the alleged 2013 post-demise agreement in consideration of relinquishing rights in the joint bank account.
¶ 117-125iii.3. Whether the Will dated 11.04.2001 conferred ownership rights on Promila Puri or the defendants.
¶ 126-131iv.4. Whether the defendants acquired ownership by adverse possession.
¶ 132-141v.5. Whether the suit is barred by delay, laches, acquiescence or estoppel.
¶ 142vi.6. Whether the suit property could be decreed for possession under O. XII R. 6 read with O. XV CPC without trial, and whether the defendants were denied a fair hearing.
¶ 143-151vii.7. Whether the grant of mesne profits at Rs. 3,00,000 per month "till realisation" is sustainable without an inquiry.
¶ 152-16003Law Applied
The court applied O. XII R. 6 CPC, which permits judgment on admissions at any stage, and the principle that admissions are gathered from the pleadings read as a whole, including constructive admissions, citing Uttam Singh Duggal & Co. v. United Bank of India (2000) 7 SCC 120 and Karam Kapahi v. Lal Chand Public Charitable Trust (2010) 4 SCC 753.
¶ 144The court applied S. 2(12) CPC and O. XX R. 12 CPC on mesne profits, under which profits of wrongful possession are determined by inquiry where rate is not admitted.
¶ 152-153, 158-159On family settlements, the court relied on Sahu Madho Das v. Pandit Mukand Ram (AIR 1955 SC 481) and Kale v. Deputy Director of Consolidation (1976) 3 SCC 119: a family arrangement presupposes an antecedent title or claim, and a non-owner can take only where the owner relinquishes title and acknowledges the other party as owner.
¶ 102-103The court applied S. 54 and S. 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, under which transfer of immovable property requires a registered instrument, and S. 53A, which protects only written contracts.
¶ 106, 124The court relied on S. 2(h) and S. 105 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925: a Will is ambulatory and takes effect only on death, and a legacy lapses if the legatee predeceases the testator.
¶ 128-129On adverse possession, the court applied the requirement that possession be nec vi, nec clam, nec precario, actual, open, continuous, exclusive and hostile for twelve years, with the date of hostility pleaded, citing S.M. Karim v. Bibi Sakina (AIR 1964 SC 1254), Karnataka Board of Wakf (2004) 10 SCC 779, and Narasamma v. A. Krishnappa (AIR 2020 SC 4178).
¶ 134-137The court applied Maria Margarida Sequeira Fernandes v. Erasmo Jack de Sequeira (2012) 5 SCC 370: gratuitous occupiers, even for decades, acquire no title and are liable to give possession on demand.
¶ 138-139The court applied Atma Ram Properties (P) Ltd. v. Federal Motors (P) Ltd. (2005) 1 SCC 705: after permission ends, the occupant is liable for damages at the rate the owner could have let the premises.
¶ 156Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96Section 151Section 2
Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 2Section 105
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 54Section 123
04Reasoning
The family-settlement plea failed at the threshold. The Written Statement itself admitted the plaintiff's title and that Promila Puri had no independent title, and it disclosed no dispute the settlement resolved.
¶ 104The pleaded "understanding" was described in inconsistent terms ("mutual settlement", "settlement agreement", "oral understanding") and, at most, reflected an intention to transfer, which did not transfer title without a registered instrument.
¶ 98-99, 105-106The "small sum" and "huge sums" pleaded as consideration were neither particularised nor linked to any identifiable right or asset, and the alleged joint account was not shown to hold any sum owned by the defendants.
¶ 114-115, 120-122The 2013 agreement was inconsistent with the 1999 settlement, since a second consideration would be unnecessary if ownership had passed earlier. On the defendants' own case, title had not passed even after 2013.
¶ 118-119The Will could not operate while the testator was alive, and the legacy to Promila Puri lapsed on her earlier death.
¶ 129-130The adverse possession plea failed because the defendants traced their possession to the plaintiff's consent and disclosed no hostile assertion or date of hostility, and alternative pleas cannot be sustained on a single consistent footing.
¶ 133, 136-137Delay was rejected because the suit was filed within limitation after the 2018 notice.
¶ 142On the O. XII R. 6 challenge, the court found that the admissions (title, permissive occupation without payment, and receipt of the withdrawal notice) were sufficient for possession, and that the defendants' defence, even if accepted, did not confer any right.
¶ 145-149The fair hearing objection failed because the defendants filed a written statement, written submissions opposing disposal without trial, and were heard.
¶ 150On mesne profits, the Rs. 3,00,000 rate rested on unproven copies of lease deeds, with no admission by the defendants, and the defendants had not been given a fair opportunity to rebut the rate by cross-examination or evidence. Liability for mesne profits after 15.04.2018 was upheld, but quantum required an inquiry under O. XX R. 12.
¶ 157-15905Holding
The court held that the defendants acquired no ownership under the 1999 settlement, the 2013 agreement, the Will, or adverse possession. Possession was rightly decreed under O. XII R. 6 on admissions.
¶ 131, 137, 141, 149, 151The appeal is partly allowed. The decree for possession dated 10.02.2026 is upheld. The mesne profits award of Rs. 3,00,000 per month "till realisation" is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the District Judge for determination of mesne profits/user and occupation charges under O. XX R. 12 CPC, after affording both parties an opportunity to lead evidence. The parties are directed to appear before the District Judge on 07.12.2026.
¶ 159-163Original Court PDF
Akshay PurivsKailash Kumar Arora
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
