01Facts
The petitioners are existing licence holders of fair price shops (FPS) in Yadgiri and Kalaburagi districts.
They challenged notifications issued by the Deputy Director, Food and Civil Supplies, inviting applications for establishment of new FPS. The notifications challenged are dated 14.07.2022 (WP 202268/2022), 01.01.2021 (WP 200316/2022), and 18.10.2022 (WP 202852/2022).
pp. 1–2, 4–6The petitioners' grievance is that establishing new shops would reduce the number of ration cards assigned to their existing shops.
¶ 3The petitions were heard with the learned AGA and the material on record was perused.
¶ 202Issues
i.1. Whether the establishment of new fair price shops, which may reduce the ration cards assigned to existing FPS, is impermissible under the Karnataka Essential Commodities (PDS) Control Order, 2016.
¶ 3, 5ii.2. Whether the impugned notifications are consistent with the minimum ration-card thresholds prescribed under Clause 11.
¶ 4–503Law Applied
Clause 11 of the Karnataka Essential Commodities (Public Distribution System) Control Order, 2016 provides that the Authorized Authority shall assign ration cards to a fair price depot after sanctioning authorization.
p. 7Clause 11(2) fixes minimum allocations of 500 cards for a rural depot and 800 for an urban depot, with a proviso allowing relaxation up to 100 cards for rural isolated settlements, for reasons recorded in writing.
pp. 7–8Clause 11(3) permits transfer of cards between shops on request, on reorganisation of jurisdiction with the Commissioner's permission, or where a shop's cards fall below 75% of the Clause 11(2) figure and the shop becomes economically unviable.
p. 8The court applied the reasoning in Vinayaka Consumers Co-operative Society Ltd. & Ors. v. Principal Secretary, Government of Karnataka & Ors., WP No. 11405 of 2022 (disposed of 07.03.2023), on a similar challenge.
pp. 8–9 & fn.1The detailed reasoning in Vinayaka is not reproduced in the order.
04Reasoning
The court read Clause 11 as setting minimum card thresholds (500 rural, 800 urban) for each FPS.
¶ 5It held that if the authorities invite fresh applications while maintaining these ratios, there is no legal impediment to the notifications continuing.
¶ 5The petitioners' apprehension of a reduction in their card allocation was therefore not, by itself, a ground for interference, since the statutory floor is preserved.
¶ 5Applying Vinayaka, the court dismissed all three petitions without further discussion.
¶ 5The order does not record any finding on the actual card numbers of the petitioners' shops or on whether the Clause 11(2) minimums were in fact met in the impugned notifications.
It also does not separately address the three different notification dates and numbers challenged.
05Holding
The holding is that the invitation of applications for new fair price shops is not vitiated merely because it may reduce the ration cards of existing shops, provided the minimum allocations under Clause 11(2) of the 2016 Control Order are maintained.
¶ 5The court dismissed WP Nos. 202268/2022, 200316/2022 and 202852/2022.
¶ 5No other relief was granted.
Original Court PDF
ADHYKSHRU BHOJALINGESHWAR THARUNA SANGHA SUGUR (N) AND ORSvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
