Karnataka High CourtAdministrative and Public LawContract Law

Public authority cannot retrospectively withdraw an acted-upon licence fee concession without affording licensees a hearing

KSMZ PROPERTIES PRIVATE LIMITEDv.DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER

Public authority cannot retrospectively withdraw an acted-upon licence fee concession without affording licensees a hearing. KSMZ PROPERTIES PRIVATE LIMITED vs DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the writ petitions are maintainable despite the arbitration clause (Clause 12.3.1) in the Concession Agreement.

The court held

The writ petitions are maintainable only insofar as they challenge the common administrative decisions. Individual contractual monetary claims remain subject to arbitration.

It also directed

The communication dated 01.09.2021 granted a binding concession of 70% for April and June 2021 and 100% for May 2021 on licence fee, which extended to sub-lessees but not GST.

COVID-19 and the strike constituted force majeure events, but the petitioners failed to comply with Article 8.3 and are not entitled to further Article 8 relief; the frustration plea is rejected.

Continued occupiers cannot claim suspension of rent under Section 108.

The resolutions dated 21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024 and consequential demands are quashed insofar as they recover the licence fee component for April–June 2021, but GST and other periods are not disturbed.

WP 35467/2025 partly allowed; notices dated 18.08.2025, 01.09.2025 and 16.10.2025 are quashed to the extent of the ₹37,17,642 licence fee component, but GST of ₹6,69,176 and other periods remain recoverable.

WP 10460/2022 and WP 13395/2022 partly allowed; the letter dated 06.04.2022 and related notices are quashed as to the licence fee for April–June 2021.

WP 20426/2022 partly allowed; Annexure-F is quashed for the licence fee component, and KSRTC must refund petitioners 9 and 10's deposits after lawful adjustment, with 6% simple interest.

WP 7641/2023 partly allowed; the demands and resolutions are quashed for the licence fee component, and KSRTC must refund ₹22,38,596 after lawful adjustment, with 6% simple interest from 01.07.2022.

WP 27997/2023 partly allowed; KSRTC is restrained from adjusting the ₹6,68,668 deposit against the quashed April–June 2021 licence fee, but may adjust other lawful dues.

All other demands are left intact and recoverable in accordance with law.

01Facts

KSRTC executed a registered Concession Agreement dated 27.06.2012 in favour of KSMZ Properties Pvt. Ltd. ("KSMZ") for operation and maintenance of commercial-cum-retail space at Shivamogga Bus Terminal, extended until 15.03.2025.

¶ 7

KSMZ granted back-to-back sub-leases to the other petitioners, under which the Concession Agreement terms applied mutatis mutandis.

¶ 7

Article 8 (Force Majeure) and Article 9.4 (termination following force majeure) are the relevant clauses.

¶ 8 · ¶ 15.5

During COVID-19, the petitioners claimed a strike by KSRTC employees (07.04.2021–21.04.2021), a lockdown (21.04.2021–20.06.2021), and no bus services, causing business closure.

¶ 10.1, 10.11 · ¶ 11.1

A communication dated 01.09.2021 issued by the Chief Traffic Manager to all Divisional Controllers, referring to a CCG meeting of 27.08.2021, granted a concession in monthly licence fee for April–June 2021 for all licensees except ATM and mobile tower licensees, expressly excluding GST.

¶ 20.8

The petitioners' case is a 70% reduction for April and June 2021 and 100% for May 2021.

¶ 11.2 · ¶ 20.9

KSRTC's position is that this was an internal recommendation of the CCG, rejected by the Board at its 447th meeting on 21.03.2022, which resolved to collect full licence fee.

¶ 15.7–15.9 · ¶ 19.10

Following a letter dated 06.04.2022 and notices in April–May 2022, KSRTC issued demand notices on 18.08.2025, 01.09.2025 and 16.10.2025 aggregating ₹43,86,818 (licence fee ₹37,17,642 plus GST ₹6,69,176).

¶ 10.8–10.10

A Board resolution dated 13.11.2024 also reaffirmed the position.

¶ 23.18

The petitioner in WP 7641/2023 surrendered premises, accepted by KSRTC on 31.01.2022, and claims refund of a ₹22,38,596 security deposit with 2% monthly interest.

¶ 13.3–13.4

The petitioner in WP 27997/2023 seeks protection of a ₹6,68,668 deposit from adjustment.

¶ 6(ii) · ¶ 24.3

02Issues

i.1. Whether the writ petitions are maintainable despite the arbitration clause (Clause 12.3.1) in the Concession Agreement.

¶ 17(i) · ¶ 19.14

ii.2. Whether the communication dated 01.09.2021 constituted a final and binding concession for April–June 2021, whether the issuing authority was competent, and whether the concession extended to GST.

¶ 17(ii) · ¶ 20.24–20.25

iii.3. Whether COVID-19 and its consequences attracted Article 8 (Force Majeure), and whether the petitioners complied with the notice, consultation and mitigation procedure and Article 9.4.

¶ 17(iii) · ¶ 21.29–21.30

iv.4. Whether continued possession of the premises disentitled the petitioners from claiming suspension or waiver of licence fee under the Concession Agreement and Sections 108(B)(e) and 108(B)(l) of the TPA.

¶ 17(iv) · ¶ 22.16

v.5. Whether the resolutions dated 21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024 and the consequential demands are sustainable, having regard to KSRTC's authority, natural justice, promissory estoppel and legitimate expectation.

¶ 17(v) · ¶ 23.36

vi.6. Whether the petitioners are entitled to refund of security deposits, protection against adjustment, and interest.

¶ 17(vi) · ¶ 24.12–24.14

03Law Applied

The court applied Article 8.1.1 and Article 8.3 of the Concession Agreement, which define force majeure events including epidemics, state-wide strikes and analogous events, and prescribe a seven-day notice and consultation procedure.

¶ 8 · ¶ 21.8–21.10

It applied Article 9.4, which permits termination after prolonged force majeure only on notice of intention to terminate.

¶ 15.5 · ¶ 21.23

Clause 12.3.1 provided for arbitration before the MD of BMTC.

¶ 19.3

Section 108(B)(e) and (l) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provide that a lessee must pay rent unless it exercises the option to avoid the lease for substantial and permanent unfitness, as explained in Ramanand v. Girish Soni.

¶ 22.2–22.5

The court applied the doctrine of promissory estoppel and legitimate expectation, drawing on GNCT of Delhi v. Naresh Kumar and, on the ingredients of estoppel, Kasinka Trading v. Union of India and Monnet Ispat.

¶ 12.6 · ¶ 13.11 · ¶ 23.14

The court relied on Pratima Chowdhury v. Kalpana Mukherjee, which requires representation, reliance, alteration of position and inequity.

¶ 23.22

The court considered Dattatraya v. Rangnath on admissions.

¶ 23.19–23.20

Against the government-estoppel objections, the court considered P.H. Avari, Rachapudi Subrahmanyam, P.C. Sethi and Central Coalfields Ltd. v. SLL-SML, applying the Nazir Ahmad principle that prescribed procedures must be followed.

¶ 15.12–15.18 · ¶ 23.25–23.29

Article 14 was considered.

¶ 23.30–23.32

The court relied on the principle that a writ court exercises discretion where an arbitration clause exists, but may intervene where state action is arbitrary or violates natural justice.

¶ 19.5–19.8

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 108

04Reasoning

The court held that the arbitration clause does not bar writ jurisdiction over the challenge to the Board resolutions, which raise a public-law element of arbitrariness and natural justice, but individual contractual claims (licence fee computation, deposits, interest) remain subject to arbitration.

¶ 19.9–19.14

On the merits, the court held that the 01.09.2021 communication was an administrative decision, not a mere internal recommendation: it was addressed to field officers for implementation, it was acted upon, and KSRTC began demanding balances only in 2022.

¶ 20.10–20.11, 20.17

KSRTC produced no rules or delegation establishing want of authority of the CCG or Chief Traffic Manager.

¶ 20.12–20.13 · ¶ 23.27

The concession, being linked to the principal lease, extended to sub-lessees under the back-to-back arrangement. However, the concession expressly excluded GST, and the claimed later GST waiver of 04.09.2021 was not established on the record.

¶ 20.19–20.21 · ¶ 20.22–20.23

On force majeure, the court held that the pandemic, the lockdown and the strike fell within Article 8.1.1(c), (e) and (g). The petitioners, however, did not issue Article 8.3 notices or participate in consultation, so they could not claim further relief under Article 8 beyond the independent concession.

¶ 21.11–21.15 · ¶ 21.16–21.22

Article 9.4 was not invoked, and frustration was rejected because the parties had expressly provided for force majeure consequences.

¶ 21.23–21.26

Under Section 108(B)(e) and (l), the petitioners who remained in possession did not establish destruction or permanent unfitness, nor dispossession, so suspension of rent was unavailable. The surrendering petitioner in WP 7641/2023 stands differently for the period after accepted surrender.

¶ 22.5–22.10 · ¶ 22.14

On the Board resolutions, the court applied promissory estoppel and legitimate expectation. The concession was specific, quantified and acted upon, with reduced payments accepted and demands raised only later, so the elements of representation, reliance and alteration of position were established.

¶ 23.15 · ¶ 23.23–23.24

The Board's retrospective withdrawal for a period that had ended, without notice or hearing to the affected licensees, was unfair and arbitrary, and the 18.05.2022 representation left unanswered did not cure this defect. The Court was not persuaded that the withdrawal was impermissible for future policy, as the Board may change policy prospectively.

¶ 23.16–23.18 · ¶ 23.33 · ¶ 23.16

On refunds, the court found the disputed ₹10,19,317 demand for the quashed component could not be used to withhold deposits. Interest was fixed at 6% p.a. rather than the 2% per month claimed.

¶ 24.5–24.7 · ¶ 24.9–24.10

05Holding

The writ petitions are maintainable only insofar as they challenge the common administrative decisions. Individual contractual monetary claims remain subject to arbitration.

¶ 19.14

The communication dated 01.09.2021 granted a binding concession of 70% for April and June 2021 and 100% for May 2021 on licence fee, which extended to sub-lessees but not GST.

¶ 20.24–20.25

COVID-19 and the strike constituted force majeure events, but the petitioners failed to comply with Article 8.3 and are not entitled to further Article 8 relief; the frustration plea is rejected.

¶ 21.29–21.30

Continued occupiers cannot claim suspension of rent under Section 108.

¶ 22.16

The resolutions dated 21.03.2022 and 13.11.2024 and consequential demands are quashed insofar as they recover the licence fee component for April–June 2021, but GST and other periods are not disturbed.

¶ 23.34–23.37

WP 35467/2025 partly allowed; notices dated 18.08.2025, 01.09.2025 and 16.10.2025 are quashed to the extent of the ₹37,17,642 licence fee component, but GST of ₹6,69,176 and other periods remain recoverable.

¶ 25.1(i)

WP 10460/2022 and WP 13395/2022 partly allowed; the letter dated 06.04.2022 and related notices are quashed as to the licence fee for April–June 2021.

¶ 25.1(ii)

WP 20426/2022 partly allowed; Annexure-F is quashed for the licence fee component, and KSRTC must refund petitioners 9 and 10's deposits after lawful adjustment, with 6% simple interest.

¶ 25.1(iii) · ¶ 24.13

WP 7641/2023 partly allowed; the demands and resolutions are quashed for the licence fee component, and KSRTC must refund ₹22,38,596 after lawful adjustment, with 6% simple interest from 01.07.2022.

¶ 25.1(iv) · ¶ 24.12

WP 27997/2023 partly allowed; KSRTC is restrained from adjusting the ₹6,68,668 deposit against the quashed April–June 2021 licence fee, but may adjust other lawful dues.

¶ 25.1(v) · ¶ 24.14

All other demands are left intact and recoverable in accordance with law.

¶ 25.1(vi)
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

KSMZ PROPERTIES PRIVATE LIMITEDvsDIVISIONAL CONTROLLER

Karnataka High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment