Karnataka High CourtCivil LawInsurance Law

Average of income tax returns forms the income basis for computing compensation in fatal accident claims.

THE MANAGER, HDFC ERGO GIC LTD.,v.SMT. RATHNAMMA,

Average of income tax returns forms the income basis for computing compensation in fatal accident claims.. THE MANAGER, HDFC ERGO GIC LTD., vs SMT. RATHNAMMA,. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Tribunal erred in attributing 20% contributory negligence to the deceased, who was allegedly crossing the road where the rider was at fault.

The court held

The 20% contributory negligence attributed to the deceased was upheld, and the claimants' appeal on this point was rejected.

It also directed

The average of the ITR incomes is the correct income basis, and loss of dependency was recalculated at Rs.44,40,040/-.

The loss of love and affection award was set aside as duplicative of consortium, and consortium was enhanced to Rs.2,40,000/-.

Total compensation was reduced to Rs.37,72,832/- from Rs.49,24,368/- awarded by the Tribunal, with 6% interest from the date of petition.

Both appeals were allowed in part. The Insurer must deposit the amount, including the sum already deposited, within six weeks. The Tribunal's apportionment and deposit/release orders remain unaltered. The deposit is to be transmitted to the Tribunal. Claimant No. 5's share is to go to Claimant No. 4. The shares of Appellants 1–4 are fixed at 40:25:25:10.

01Facts

Lakshmaiah died in a road traffic accident on 16.02.2023 at about 9:15 p.m. on the Tumakuru–Kunigal road, allegedly caused by the rash and negligent riding of motorcycle KA-06/HK-7510.

¶ 3, 9

The charge sheet (Ex.P7) was filed against the rider under Sections 279, 338 and 304A IPC.

¶ 9

The spot mahazar and sketch (Ex.P3) record that the accident occurred on the left side of the road, near a crossroad, and that tyre marks of about 10 metres indicated the rider had applied brakes.

¶ 9

The claimants (wife, two minor sons, and parents of the deceased) filed MVC No. 1390/2023.

¶ 3

The Tribunal (XIX Addl. Judge, COSC & ACMM, Bengaluru, SCCH-17) awarded Rs.61,55,460/- in total, reduced it by 20% for the deceased's contributory negligence, and granted Rs.49,24,368/- with 6% interest from the date of petition.

¶ 3–4

The deceased's income was taken from ITRs Ex.P10 (AY 2019-20: Rs.2,46,574/-) and Ex.P11 (AY 2020-21: Rs.4,82,048/-).

¶ 10

Claimants challenged the 20% contributory negligence (MFA 3068/2025).

¶ 4–7

The Insurer challenged the quantum and the negligence finding (MFA 7636/2024).

¶ 4–7

Claimant No. 5 died during the pendency of the appeal.

order para. vi

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in attributing 20% contributory negligence to the deceased, who was allegedly crossing the road where the rider was at fault.

¶ 5–6, 9

ii.2. Whether the Tribunal erred in computing the deceased's income and loss of dependency, specifically whether the average of income shown in ITRs Ex.P10 and Ex.P11 should be adopted.

¶ 7, 10

iii.3. Whether claimants are entitled to separate compensation for loss of love and affection once loss of consortium has been awarded, and whether the conventional heads require enhancement.

¶ 7, 11

03Law Applied

The court relied on the principle from Rashmirekha Tripathy & Anr. v. Branch Manager (Legal Claims), Sriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. (2026 SCC OnLine SC 1256), under which the average of income shown in multiple ITRs is to be adopted as the deceased's income.

¶ 7, 10

The court applied National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (AIR 2017 SC 5157) for the rule that conventional heads (consortium, funeral expenses, transportation of the body) are to be escalated, here at 20% because the accident occurred more than six years after that judgment.

¶ 11

Under Pranay Sethi, consortium is payable to each eligible claimant, and loss of love and affection is not awarded separately where consortium is granted.

¶ 7, 11

The court applied the settled principle that contributory negligence is determined from the circumstances of the accident, including the site, the traffic situation, and the physical evidence.

¶ 9

The statutory basis is Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, under which the appeals were filed.

p. 3

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 279Section 338

04Reasoning

On the negligence issue, the court relied on the charge sheet, spot mahazar, and sketch to find that the rider applied brakes after seeing the deceased, which shows the rider was aware of the pedestrian, yet still hit him. This establishes the rider's principal fault.

¶ 9

Because the accident occurred near a crossroad and the deceased was crossing the road, the court held that the deceased also failed to take reasonable care. The 20% apportionment was therefore upheld.

¶ 9

On income, applying Rashmirekha Tripathy, the court averaged the two ITRs to obtain Rs.3,64,311/- per year.

¶ 10

Loss of dependency was computed by applying a multiplier of 13 (Rs.47,36,043/-), deducting one-fourth (Rs.35,52,032/-), and adding 25% future prospects, yielding Rs.44,40,040/-.

¶ 10

For conventional heads, the court enhanced the rate to 20% and awarded consortium of Rs.48,000/- to each of five claimants (Rs.2,40,000/-), noting that the Tribunal's Rs.27,500/- for loss of love and affection could not be retained alongside consortium.

¶ 11

Funeral expenses and transportation of the body were each fixed at Rs.18,000/-.

¶ 11

The total of Rs.47,16,040/- was reduced by 20% for contributory negligence, giving Rs.37,72,832/-.

¶ 12

05Holding

The 20% contributory negligence attributed to the deceased was upheld, and the claimants' appeal on this point was rejected.

¶ 9

The average of the ITR incomes is the correct income basis, and loss of dependency was recalculated at Rs.44,40,040/-.

¶ 10

The loss of love and affection award was set aside as duplicative of consortium, and consortium was enhanced to Rs.2,40,000/-.

¶ 11

Total compensation was reduced to Rs.37,72,832/- from Rs.49,24,368/- awarded by the Tribunal, with 6% interest from the date of petition.

¶ 12

Both appeals were allowed in part. The Insurer must deposit the amount, including the sum already deposited, within six weeks. The Tribunal's apportionment and deposit/release orders remain unaltered. The deposit is to be transmitted to the Tribunal. Claimant No. 5's share is to go to Claimant No. 4. The shares of Appellants 1–4 are fixed at 40:25:25:10.

Order cl. i–vii
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

THE MANAGER, HDFC ERGO GIC LTD.,vsSMT. RATHNAMMA,

Karnataka High Court · November 12, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment