Karnataka High CourtCivil LawInsurance Law

Future prospects are not awardable in injury claims where the permanent disability is below 20%.

THE MANAGERv.K V BYREGOWDA

Future prospects are not awardable in injury claims where the permanent disability is below 20%.. THE MANAGER vs K V BYREGOWDA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Tribunal's multiplier of 13 was correct for a claimant aged 49 years.

The court held

The claimant is entitled to total compensation of Rs. 6,47,748, comprising pain and suffering Rs. 50,000, loss of amenities Rs. 50,000, medical expenses Rs. 1,24,053, attendant, conveyance and diet charges Rs. 4,000, and loss of future income Rs. 4,19,695.

It also directed

The appeal is allowed in part.

The award carries 6% interest per annum from the date of petition until realisation.

The insurer must deposit the amount with interest before the Tribunal within six weeks.

The claimant is entitled to release of the entire amount, and the deposit is to be transmitted to the Tribunal.

01Facts

The claimant, aged 49 at the time, was injured in a road traffic accident on 04.06.2022 involving an Ashok Leyland lorry (KA-43-A-0618), which he alleged was caused by the driver's rash and negligent driving.

¶ 2 / p.3

The Tribunal (MVC No. 69/2022, IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Doddaballapura) awarded Rs. 7,75,255/- under six heads: loss of future income (Rs. 5,16,202), medical expenses (Rs. 1,24,053), pain and suffering and loss of amenities (Rs. 50,000), attendant and transport (Rs. 25,000), diet (Rs. 10,000), and mental shock (Rs. 50,000), with 6% interest from the date of petition.

¶ 2 / pp.3–4 · ¶ 3 / p.4

The insurer appealed under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

p. 2

The claimant's wound certificate (Ex.P7) recorded abrasions over the right shoulder and right tibial shin with swelling and tenderness.

¶ 6 / p.4

He was hospitalised for four days.

¶ 7 / p.5

PW-2, the treating doctor, assessed 48.87% disability to the right lower limb, equivalent to 16.29% to the whole body.

¶ 8 / p.5

The claimant's avocation as a driver was supported by Ex.P22 (driving licence) and Ex.P20 (letter from Travel Desk Solutions).

¶ 9 / p.6

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Tribunal's multiplier of 13 was correct for a claimant aged 49 years.

¶ 5 / p.4

ii.2. Whether the award of Rs. 50,000 for pain and suffering and a separate Rs. 50,000 for mental shock was proper, and whether loss of amenities was payable.

¶ 6 / pp.4–5

iii.3. Whether attendant and diet charges of Rs. 35,000 were justified, or should be restricted to the period of hospitalisation.

¶ 7 / p.5

iv.4. Whether future prospects at 25% could be added where the assessed disability was below 20%.

¶ 8 / pp.5–6

v.5. Whether the notional monthly income of Rs. 16,250 was correct, or should be fixed at the applicable minimum wage for a car driver in Zone-I.

¶ 9 / pp.6–7

03Law Applied

Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, which governs appeals against Tribunal awards.

p. 2

For computation, a multiplier linked to the claimant's age is applied, with age 49 taking multiplier 13.

¶ 5 / p.4

A lower-limb disability is converted to whole-body disability at one-third.

¶ 8 / pp.5–6

Future prospects are not added where disability is below 20%.

¶ 8 / p.6

Compensation under a head already covering the same loss (here, mental shock within pain and suffering) is not awarded separately.

¶ 6 / pp.4–5

The notified minimum wage for a car driver in Zone-I (Rs. 16,515.36 per month) is relied on to fix notional income.

¶ 9 / p.6

The judgment cites no precedents.

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173

04Reasoning

The court upheld multiplier 13 as correctly applied to the claimant's age.

¶ 5 / p.4

On injuries, the court treated the abrasions and tenderness in Ex.P7 as supporting Rs. 50,000 for pain and suffering. It awarded an additional Rs. 50,000 for loss of amenities, as the Tribunal had not awarded it. It then removed the separate Rs. 50,000 for mental shock, holding that the claimant is not separately entitled to it once pain, suffering and amenities are compensated.

¶ 6 / pp.4–5

Medical expenses of Rs. 1,24,053 were upheld as proved by documents.

¶ 6 / p.5

For attendant and diet charges, the court tied the award to the four-day hospitalisation at Rs. 1,000 per day, giving Rs. 4,000 in place of Rs. 35,000.

¶ 7 / p.5

On disability, the court accepted the 16.29% whole-body figure derived from PW-2's testimony. Because that figure is below 20%, it denied the 25% future-prospects addition the Tribunal had made.

¶ 8 / pp.5–6

On income, the Tribunal had adopted Rs. 16,250 per month. The court held the claimant worked as a driver in Bengaluru (Zone-I) and applied the minimum wage of Rs. 16,515.36 per month. Loss of future income was then computed as Rs. 16,515.36 × 12 × 13 × 16.29% = Rs. 4,19,695.

¶ 9 / pp.6–7 · ¶ 9 / p.7

The total was revised to Rs. 6,47,748. The court noted that the claimant had not appealed, so the higher notional income was applied without any enhancement claim from him.

¶ 10 / p.7

05Holding

The claimant is entitled to total compensation of Rs. 6,47,748, comprising pain and suffering Rs. 50,000, loss of amenities Rs. 50,000, medical expenses Rs. 1,24,053, attendant, conveyance and diet charges Rs. 4,000, and loss of future income Rs. 4,19,695.

¶ 10 / p.7 · ¶ 11 / p.7

The appeal is allowed in part.

¶ 12(i) / p.7

The award carries 6% interest per annum from the date of petition until realisation.

¶ 12(ii) / p.8

The insurer must deposit the amount with interest before the Tribunal within six weeks.

¶ 12(iii) / p.8

The claimant is entitled to release of the entire amount, and the deposit is to be transmitted to the Tribunal.

¶ 12(iv)–(v) / p.8
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

THE MANAGERvsK V BYREGOWDA

Karnataka High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment