Karnataka High CourtCivil LawInsurance Law

Negligence apportionment cannot rest on Sections 117 and 122 MV Act without corroborative evidence.

SAMYUKTHAv.VIJAYAN V

Negligence apportionment cannot rest on Sections 117 and 122 MV Act without corroborative evidence.. SAMYUKTHA vs VIJAYAN V. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in apportioning negligence at 60% against the car driver and 40% against the maxi cab driver, and in fixing the corresponding insurer liability.

The court held

The court partly allowed all appeals. The negligence apportionment was modified to 90% against the car driver and 10% against the maxi cab driver.

It also directed

Insurer liability is recorded in the order as National Insurance (maxi cab insurer) at 90% and New India (car insurer) at 10%.

Compensation was reassessed with 6% interest from the date of claim petition until deposit. MVC 685/2015 (Samyuktha, injury): Rs.61,60,200.

MVC 686/2015 (Renuka): Rs.25,000.

MVC 688/2015 (dependant of Sumi): Rs.86,59,000.

Rs.20,00,000 is released to Samyuktha for medical and future medical expenses. The balance is placed in a five-year fixed deposit with monthly interest payable to the guardian, subject to periodic affidavits and additional release on medical need.

The entire MVC 686 compensation is released to Renuka.

In MVC 688, 40% is released and 60% is held in a five-year fixed deposit.

01Facts

On 02.11.2013 at about 2:00 p.m., Car No. KA-51-Z-9269, driven by Shabu, carried claimant Samyuktha (then a minor child), her mother Sumi and Renuka.

¶ 2

The car rear-ended Maxi Cab No. KA-13-6615 near Ranganathapura Gate on NH-75.

¶ 2

Samyuktha sustained severe head injuries and is rendered 100% disabled. Renuka was injured, and Sumi died.

¶ 2 · ¶ 24

Claims were filed under Section 166 of the MV Act: MVC 685/2015 (Samyuktha, injury), MVC 686/2015 (Renuka, injury), and MVC 688/2015 (Samyuktha as dependant of Sumi).

¶ 2

Owners were placed ex parte; only insurers contested.

¶ 3

The Tribunal held the accident caused by negligence of both drivers, apportioned negligence 60% (car) and 40% (maxi cab), and awarded Rs.15,50,000 (685), Rs.25,000 (686) and Rs.64,45,000 (688), with 9% interest.

¶ 5

The maxi-cab insurer challenged the 40% apportionment and the 9% interest rate.

¶ 6

Claimants sought enhancement, specifically for the Samyuktha claim (disability, attendant charges, and loss of amenities/marriage prospects) and for failure to add future prospects in MVC 688.

¶ 6–10

Police records (Exs. P1–P5) showed a charge sheet against the car driver alone, and the spot mahazar and MVI report indicated the maxi cab was stationary on the left side, with rear damage to the cab and front-left damage to the car.

¶ 16–17

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in apportioning negligence at 60% against the car driver and 40% against the maxi cab driver, and in fixing the corresponding insurer liability.

¶ 16

ii.2. Whether the compensation awarded calls for modification.

¶ 16

03Law Applied

Sections 117 and 122 of the MV Act, which respectively require public service vehicles to stop at designated places and prohibit stopping or parking a vehicle in a dangerous position on a road.

¶ 19

Negligence must be established by evidence, and the claimant's version must be corroborated.

¶ 16–18, 20

Master Mallikarjun v. Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. (2013 ACJ 2445), as superseded by Hitesh Najibhai Patel v. Bababhai Najibhai Rabari (2025 SCC OnLine SC 3446), under which a non-earning minor's income is taken as the notified minimum wage for skilled workers, with future prospects, a multiplier of 18, and awards for marriage prospects and loss of amenities.

¶ 8, 24–26

Future prospects of 40% for age below 40 and the conventional heads ceiling follow National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680.

¶ 27–28

Attendant charges are computed under the multiplier method per Kajal v. Jagdish Chand (2020) 4 SCC 413.

¶ 25

Interest is reduced to 6% on the claimants' concession.

¶ 28

Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166Section 117Section 122

04Reasoning

The claimants' version, that the maxi cab suddenly swerved and stopped without signal and that the car braked and swerved, was uncorroborated.

¶ 18, 20

The Tribunal's reliance on Sections 117 and 122 was unsupported, since nothing showed the maxi cab blocked the road or stopped at a non-designated, dangerous spot.

¶ 19

The cab was stopped on a national highway without signal, which attracts some negligence given high highway speeds.

¶ 20

The 40% negligence against the maxi cab was held excessive and reduced to 10%, with 90% against the car driver.

¶ 21–22

The court accepted the medical evidence (PW-4) of 100% permanent disability and found the Tribunal's Rs.6,00,000 disability award inadequate under Hitesh.

¶ 24

Absent evidence of notified skilled wages for 2013, a notional income of Rs.8,000 was adopted: (Rs.8,000 + 40%) × 12 × 18 = Rs.24,19,200.

¶ 24

Attendant charges were computed as Rs.8,000 × 12 × 18 = Rs.17,28,000.

¶ 25

Pain and suffering was enhanced to Rs.5,00,000, loss of amenities was set at Rs.3,00,000 and marriage prospects at Rs.3,00,000.

¶ 25–26

The Rs.7,13,000 medical reimbursement and Rs.2,00,000 future medical award were sustained, as no evidence was adduced on the nature or cost of future treatment.

¶ 25–26

For MVC 688, the court accepted the Tribunal's income of Rs.45,000 per month, multiplier 17, and one-third deduction, adding 40% future prospects: (Rs.45,000 + 40%) × 2/3 × 12 × 17 = Rs.85,68,000.

¶ 27–28

Conventional heads in MVC 688 were reduced to Rs.70,000 plus 30% escalation (Rs.21,000).

¶ 27–28

For MVC 686, the award of Rs.25,000 was maintained without separate reasoning.

¶ 29(iv)

05Holding

The court partly allowed all appeals. The negligence apportionment was modified to 90% against the car driver and 10% against the maxi cab driver.

¶ 22, 29

Insurer liability is recorded in the order as National Insurance (maxi cab insurer) at 90% and New India (car insurer) at 10%.

¶ 29(vi)

Compensation was reassessed with 6% interest from the date of claim petition until deposit. MVC 685/2015 (Samyuktha, injury): Rs.61,60,200.

¶ 26 · ¶ 29(iii)–(v)

MVC 686/2015 (Renuka): Rs.25,000.

¶ 29(iv)

MVC 688/2015 (dependant of Sumi): Rs.86,59,000.

¶ 28

Rs.20,00,000 is released to Samyuktha for medical and future medical expenses. The balance is placed in a five-year fixed deposit with monthly interest payable to the guardian, subject to periodic affidavits and additional release on medical need.

¶ 29(ix)–(xii)

The entire MVC 686 compensation is released to Renuka.

¶ 29(xiii)

In MVC 688, 40% is released and 60% is held in a five-year fixed deposit.

¶ 29(xiv)
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SAMYUKTHAvsVIJAYAN V

Karnataka High Court · November 12, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment