Facts
The writ petition concerned the employment-related rights and facilities of the respondents-workmen, including respondent no. 9, Mr. Gopal Krishna Kumar.
Source reference: paras. 1–4The Department of Health and Family Welfare, GNCTD, had issued an order dated 19 November 2012 and a circular dated 19 March 2021 providing, inter alia, medical facilities and Health Card facilities to the concerned respondents.
Source reference: paras. 1–4By order dated 27 February 2026, the Court had directed the petitioners to adhere to those instruments for purposes including payment/emoluments to the respondent-workmen.
Source reference: para. 5Respondent no. 9 subsequently initiated contempt proceedings, in which the Court directed that he be afforded the prescribed medical facilities, including a Health Card facility, under the circular dated 19 March 2021.
Source reference: paras. 6–9He then sought urgent directions in the present application, stating that he had approximately 95% arterial blockage and required immediate heart surgery.
Source reference: para. 10The broader issue concerning regularisation of the respondents remained pending before the Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal-II, in ID No. 05/2023.
Source reference: para. 11Issues
Whether respondent no. 9 was entitled to medical facilities, including a Health Card facility, under the Department of Health and Family Welfare’s order dated 19 November 2012 and circular dated 19 March 2021, notwithstanding the pendency of the regularisation dispute before the Industrial Tribunal.
Source reference: paras. 8–12Whether, in view of respondent no. 9’s stated medical urgency, the GNCTD should be directed to provide the requisite treatment and heart-surgery-related facilities.
Source reference: paras. 10–15Law Applied
The Court applied the binding effect of its earlier orders dated 27 February 2026 and 28 April 2026, which required the petitioners to comply with the Department of Health and Family Welfare’s order dated 19 November 2012 and circular dated 19 March 2021, including extending medical facilities and Health Card facilities to the respondents.
Source reference: paras. 5, 8–9The Court treated the existing judicial directions to provide such facilities as operative notwithstanding the pendency of the wider regularisation dispute before the Industrial Tribunal.
Source reference: paras. 11–12It also exercised its interim and supervisory jurisdiction in the peculiar facts of the case, particularly the asserted medical emergency, while clarifying that the order would not determine the pending final dispute.
Source reference: para. 13Reasoning
The Court found that its earlier orders had already conclusively required the GNCTD to extend the relevant medical facilities to the respondent-workmen, including Mr. Kumar.
Source reference: paras. 8–9The pending question of regularisation did not justify withholding those facilities because the entitlement arose from the Department’s order and circular as incorporated into the Court’s prior directions.
Source reference: paras. 11–12Given the applicant’s claim of 95% arterial blockage and the need for urgent heart surgery, the Court considered immediate implementation of the medical-facility directions necessary.
Source reference: paras. 10, 12, 14–15Since the GNCTD stated that the applicant had been referred to GB Pant Hospital, the Court directed him to approach that institution, where the prescribed facilities were to be provided.
Source reference: paras. 10, 12, 14–15The relief was granted on the peculiar facts and circumstances and without prejudicing the final adjudication of the regularisation dispute.
Source reference: para. 13Holding
The Court held that respondent no. 9 was entitled to medical facilities, including the Health Card facility, under the order dated 19 November 2012 and circular dated 19 March 2021, in accordance with the Court’s earlier directions.
The GNCTD was directed to extend all requisite medical facilities to Mr. Gopal Krishna Kumar, and he was directed to approach GB Pant Hospital for his treatment and heart surgery.
Source reference: paras. 14–15CM APPL. 47630/2026 was accordingly allowed and disposed of, without deciding the pending regularisation dispute.
Source reference: paras. 13, 16Original Court PDF
Messers Health And Family Welfare Department And AnrvsJitender Kumar And 11 Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
