01Facts
The appellant was convicted by the Special Sessions Judge, Barpeta, in Special (POCSO) Case No. 29/2018, under Section 450 IPC (one year RI) and Section 4 POCSO Act (seven years RI).
¶ 2The judgment dated 20.03.2021 was challenged under Section 374 CrPC.
¶ 2The prosecution alleged that on 08.08.2017, while the informant was away and the victim's mother was washing clothes behind the house, the appellant entered the house and sexually assaulted the victim, a five-year-old girl.
¶ 3The FIR (Barpeta PS Case No. 1379/2017) was registered under Section 450 IPC read with Section 6 POCSO Act.
¶ 4The charge-sheet was filed on 09.07.2018, and charges were framed under Section 450 IPC and Section 4 POCSO Act, to which the appellant pleaded not guilty.
¶ 4The prosecution examined eleven witnesses: the informant (PW1), the mother (PW2), neighbours (PW3, PW4), the grandmother (PW5), a relative (PW6), two Investigating Officers (PW7, PW9), the doctor (PW8), the victim (PW10) and the Section 164 CrPC Magistrate (PW11).
¶ 5–16The appellant was examined under Section 313 CrPC, denied the allegations, and led no defence evidence.
¶ 5–16The appellant contended that the case was motivated by a land/boundary dispute.
¶ 1702Issues
i.1. Whether the victim's testimony, examined across the police statement, the Section 164 CrPC statement and the trial testimony, was consistent and reliable enough to sustain conviction without corroboration.
¶ 20–25ii.2. Whether the contradictions in the testimony of the mother, grandmother, neighbours and the victim were duly proved in accordance with Section 145 of the Evidence Act, such that the corroborative evidence could be relied upon.
¶ 26–29iii.3. Whether the medical evidence and the alleged extra-judicial confession of the appellant corroborated the prosecution case.
¶ 12, 2903Law Applied
In sexual offences the evidence of the prosecutrix is the core evidence and conviction may rest on it alone if it is consistent and inspires confidence, as laid down in Rai Sandeep v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2012) 8 SCC 21, which requires a "sterling witness" whose version is consistent from the initial statement to the trial, is natural, and is corroborated by other material.
¶ 20Where the victim's statement does not inspire confidence, the Court must look for corroboration from other evidence.
¶ 26The procedure for proving contradictions under Section 145 of the Evidence Act, as explained in V.K. Mishra v. State of Uttarakhand, (2015) 9 SCC 588: the witness must be confronted with the relevant part of the earlier police statement; if denied, the Investigating Officer must prove it; unproved contradictions cannot be used by the court suo motu.
¶ 28The statutory framework under Section 4 POCSO Act and Section 450 IPC was the basis of conviction.
¶ 2Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 374Section 313Section 164Section 161
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 450
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 Section 4Section 6
04Reasoning
The Court first examined the victim's statements chronologically. Her police statement (28.05.2018) was vague, her Section 164 statement (01.06.2018) alleged an act on the anus with saliva, and her trial testimony (02.09.2019) described a penetrative act on the vagina.
¶ 22–25The Court held these discrepancies to be material and not attributable merely to the victim's young age, since they were not minor variations but differed in the nature of the alleged act.
¶ 22–25Because the victim's testimony did not inspire confidence, the Court examined corroboration.
¶ 26The mother's claim that she saw the appellant committing rape and the victim naked was contradicted by her police statement; the contradiction was put to her, denied, and then proved through PW7 under the V.K. Mishra procedure, so her evidence could not support the victim.
¶ 26The grandmother's testimony was similarly inconsistent: her examination-in-chief claimed rape, but her cross-examination and police statement differed, and the contradiction was proved through PW9.
¶ 27The Court also found a sequence contradiction, since the victim stated she told her grandmother immediately, whereas the grandmother said she came only on hearing cries, and the mother reached first.
¶ 29The alleged extra-judicial confession was inconsistent across the villagers' testimonies, and PW7 contradicted PW4 on that point.
¶ 8, 11, 29The medical evidence did not corroborate penetration: PW8 found no sign of sexual intercourse and no injury on the private part, and the victim named "Yasad Ali" rather than the appellant during medical examination.
¶ 12, 29The Court did not separately address the appellant's land-dispute motive or his submission on the period of sentence already served.
¶ 17, 3005Holding
The cumulative discrepancies in the victim's statements, the proved contradictions in the testimony of PW2 and PW5, the inconsistent extra-judicial confession evidence, and the medical evidence and naming discrepancy rendered the prosecution case unreliable.
¶ 29The judgment and order dated 20.03.2021 in Special POCSO Case No. 29/2018 is set aside and quashed.
¶ 30The appellant is acquitted of the charges under Section 450 IPC and Section 4 POCSO Act and is to be released forthwith if not required in any other case. The LCR is to be sent back. No order as to costs is made. The Legal Services Authority is directed to pay the remuneration of the Amicus Curiae. The Criminal Appeal is disposed of.
¶ 31–35Original Court PDF
Esahaqe AlivsThe State Of Assam
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
