CAT - ['Ahmedabad']Administrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Genuine emergency treatment at a non-empanelled hospital cannot be restricted to package rates.

m d patelv.BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED

Genuine emergency treatment at a non-empanelled hospital cannot be restricted to package rates.. m d patel vs BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED. CAT - ['Ahmedabad']. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the treatment of the applicant’s wife was taken in circumstances constituting a genuine medical emergency.

The court held

The Tribunal allowed the OA and directed the respondents to process and release the applicant’s reimbursement claim of ₹11,56,459 for the treatment from 2 to 20 October 2019, deducting any amount already paid.

It also directed

The respondents were directed to complete the exercise within 90 days of receiving a certified copy of the order.

No interest was expressly awarded, and there was no order as to costs.

01Facts

The applicant, a retired BSNL Sub-Divisional Engineer, sought reimbursement of ₹11,56,459 for his wife’s treatment for brain haemorrhage/aneurysm at Bhailal Amin General Hospital, Vadodara, from 2 to 20 October 2019.

¶ 2.2–2.12, 4.2–4.6, 13

The hospital was not empanelled under BSNL’s medical scheme, but the applicant relied on hospital records certifying the emergency and on a departmental communication, sent during the hospitalisation, requesting an officer to visit the hospital.

¶ 2.2–2.12, 4.2–4.6, 13

After the claim was submitted, the respondents raised documentary objections and, in March 2024, approved reimbursement of only ₹1,28,772 at CGHS package rates.

¶ 2.2–2.12, 4.2–4.6, 13

The claim remained unresolved despite the applicant’s repeated representations and the matter being placed before a Medical Adalat.

¶ 2.2–2.12, 4.2–4.6, 13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the treatment of the applicant’s wife was taken in circumstances constituting a genuine medical emergency.

¶ 7(i)

ii.2. Whether treatment at a non-empanelled hospital justified denying full reimbursement in the circumstances of the case.

¶ 7(ii)

iii.3. Whether alleged deficiencies in certificates, the medical-card renewal, and other formalities could be relied on against the applicant.

¶ 7(iii)

iv.4. Whether reimbursement could be restricted to ₹1,28,772 under CGHS package rates, and whether the applicant was entitled to the amount claimed with interest.

¶ 7(iv)–(v)

03Law Applied

The application was brought under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985.

¶ 1

The Tribunal applied the principle in Shiva Kant Jha v. Union of India, 2018 (3) SLR 328 (SC), that a medical claim should not be denied solely because treatment was taken at a hospital not included in the relevant government order, where the fact of treatment is established by duly certified records.

¶ 9

It also considered the respondents’ 20 December 2012 instruction, which recognised life-saving treatment requiring immediate hospitalisation as a genuine emergency category.

¶ 8

The governing principle was that non-empanelment and procedural requirements should not defeat reimbursement for established emergency treatment on technical grounds.

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 Section 19

04Reasoning

The hospital records supported the applicant’s account that his wife had a serious neurological condition requiring urgent treatment, and the respondents did not dispute her admission or the treatment period.

¶ 8, 11

The contemporaneous departmental request for a hospital visit showed that the authorities had been notified; any failure to conduct or document that visit could not fairly be attributed to the applicant.

¶ 10

The treatment and expenditure were supported by medical records and payment receipts, and the respondents produced no evidence that the treatment was fictitious, unnecessary, or fabricated.

¶ 11, 15

The Tribunal therefore found no sustainable basis to deny the claim merely because the hospital was non-empanelled or to restrict reimbursement to CGHS package rates.

¶ 9, 15

It also noted the prolonged delay in processing the claim.

¶ 14

05Holding

The Tribunal allowed the OA and directed the respondents to process and release the applicant’s reimbursement claim of ₹11,56,459 for the treatment from 2 to 20 October 2019, deducting any amount already paid.

¶ 16(i)–(ii)

The respondents were directed to complete the exercise within 90 days of receiving a certified copy of the order.

¶ 16(i)–(ii)

No interest was expressly awarded, and there was no order as to costs.

¶ 17
CAT - ['Ahmedabad']

Original Court PDF

m d patelvsBHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED

CAT - ['Ahmedabad'] · September 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment