01Facts
The parties married on 19.05.2014 and have two sons.
¶ 2The Appellant-wife alleged that the Respondent-husband subjected her to cruelty, including abuse and physical assault, developed an adverse attitude without cause, and left the matrimonial home for his parental house.
¶ 2.1, 17, 17.1The Appellant-wife further alleged that community elders and panchayats failed to reconcile the parties because the Respondent refused to resume cohabitation.
¶ 2.2, 17.1The Respondent filed a statement of objections alleging that the Appellant attempted suicide by hanging with their child, threatened drowning in the Krishna River, and kept a knife at night, and that he was therefore under constant threat.
¶ 2.3, 2.4The Respondent did not lead any evidence, did not enter the witness box, and relied only on cross-examination of PW-1.
¶ 2.5, 17.2, 19The Appellant examined herself as PW-1 and produced Exs. P-1 to P-3.
¶ 2.5The Family Court dismissed the Section 9 petition (M.C. No. 91/2024, judgment dated 16.12.2024), relying on a finding that PW-1 admitted in cross-examination to three suicide attempts, which it treated as indicating mental illness.
¶ 2.6, 23The Respondent contended that the petition was filed after nearly six years of separation.
¶ 25A divorce petition (M.C. No. 61/2024) is pending.
¶ 17.102Issues
i.1. Whether the Family Court's dismissal of the Appellant's petition under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 warrants interference by the High Court.
¶ 6ii.2. Whether the Respondent discharged the burden under the Explanation to Section 9 of proving a reasonable excuse for withdrawing from the Appellant's society.
¶ 20–22iii.3. Whether the Family Court's finding that PW-1 admitted to three suicide attempts is supported by the evidence on record.
¶ 23–24iv.4. Whether delay in instituting the petition, by itself, defeats the claim for restitution of conjugal rights.
¶ 25–2603Law Applied
Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 permits the aggrieved spouse to seek restitution of conjugal rights where the other spouse has withdrawn from society without reasonable excuse, subject to the court's satisfaction as to the truth of the petition and the absence of any legal ground for refusal.
¶ 8–9Under the Explanation to Section 9, the burden of proving reasonable excuse lies on the spouse who withdrew, while the petitioner must first establish withdrawal.
¶ 10–11T.V. Nagarthnamma v. P.C. Renuka Prakash (2000 SCC OnLine Kar 923) holds that the burden of reasonable excuse shifts to the withdrawing spouse.
¶ 12(Dr) Smitha v. Sathyajith (2009 SCC OnLine Kar 456) holds that reasons for withdrawal must be grave and weighty and that "reasonable excuse" must be a ground that would support judicial separation, nullity, or divorce.
¶ 13Praveen Etta v. Savithri Etta (2017 SCC OnLine Kar 6461) holds that "excuse" must be something more than a mere whim and is assessed by the respondent's state of mind.
¶ 14Rajesh Kumar Swarnkar v. Girja Swarnkar (First Appeal Nos. 177 and 178 of 2024) sets out the requirements of Section 9 and the principle that restitution is a positive remedy.
¶ 15, 157G. Ramakrishna Pillai v. J. Vijayakumari Amma (1989 SCC OnLine Ker 1) holds that delay is not an absolute bar and is a discretionary factor to be assessed with reference to explanation, conduct, and circumstances.
¶ 26Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Family Courts Act, 1984 Section 19
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 Section 9Section 13Section 23
04Reasoning
PW-1's examination-in-chief established withdrawal by the Respondent, which he did not dispute.
¶ 17, 21The Respondent's defence rested on allegations of suicide attempts and threats with a knife. These were put to PW-1 only as suggestions, which she denied.
¶ 17.3, 18Suggestions in cross-examination are not substantive evidence, and the Respondent neither testified nor produced any document or witness.
¶ 19The Respondent therefore failed to discharge the statutory burden under the Explanation to Section 9.
¶ 21–22The Family Court's "admission" finding was unsupported. PW-1 answered one suggestion as "partly true" but immediately clarified that she made no attempt, and an isolated part of an answer cannot be read apart from its explanation.
¶ 23–24The inference of mental illness drawn from that finding had no cogent basis.
¶ 24The six-year gap did not defeat relief, because PW-1's evidence showed repeated reconciliation efforts through panchayats and the Respondent did not return, and the Respondent did not establish a reasonable excuse.
¶ 26The Family Court misappreciated the evidence and failed to apply the statutory burden.
¶ 2705Holding
The High Court answered the question in the affirmative and held that the Family Court's dismissal warranted interference, as the Respondent failed to prove reasonable excuse and the Family Court's finding of admitted suicide attempts was not borne out by the record.
¶ 7, 27–29The Court allowed the Miscellaneous First Appeal, set aside the judgment and decree dated 16.12.2024 in M.C. No. 91/2024, allowed the Appellant's Section 9 petition, and granted a decree for restitution of conjugal rights in her favour against the Respondent. The Registry was directed to draw the decree accordingly.
¶ 30(i)–(v)Original Court PDF
NEELAVENI @ RAKSHAvsRAGHVENDRA B
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
