01Facts
The appellant (father) and Respondent No. 1 (mother) married on 28.06.2009 and had a son, Abdul Basit Ahmed @ Rehan. Their marriage was dissolved by a decree of divorce
¶ 3Respondent No. 1 remarried on 30.01.2014 and had two children from the second marriage. Respondents 2 and 3 are her parents and the child's maternal grandparents
¶ 4The appellant alleged that the child was living with the grandparents and that his health had deteriorated in their care. He had earlier filed G&WC No. 8/2014, in which an application to implead the mother was dismissed with liberty to file afresh
¶ 4He then filed G&WC No. 8/2017 under Sections 7 and 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, seeking guardianship and custody
¶ 4Respondents 2 and 3 opposed the petition, asserting that the mother was caring for the child, that the appellant lived and worked in Gujarat, and that no one would look after the child if custody were given to him
¶ 5Respondent No. 1 remained ex parte
¶ 10The appellant examined himself and two independent witnesses (PWs 1–3) and marked Exs. P1–P10. Respondent No. 2 deposed as RW-1
¶ 6The Family Court, by judgment dated 20.02.2019, held that the mother had custody since birth and that the father's residence in Gujarat was not in the child's interest, and dismissed the petition
¶ 7Pursuant to an interim arrangement (order dated 11.04.2023), the grandparents consented to Sunday visitation by the father
¶ 1202Issues
i.1. Whether the Family Court erred in relying on the statements of the grandparents (Respondents 2 and 3) to conclude that the child was in their custody, given that the mother (Respondent No. 1) remained ex parte and did not depose.
¶ 10ii.2. Whether the Family Court's judgment, which does not discuss Exs. P1–P10 or the oral evidence, is sustainable as a reasoned decision.
¶ 11iii.3. Whether, in the child's welfare, custody should be handed to the natural guardian father, given the mother's remarriage and the child's residence with the grandparents.
¶ 13–14iv.4. Whether the judgment of the Family Court warrants interference in appeal.
¶ 903Law Applied
The court relied on Sections 7 and 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, under which the petition was filed
¶ 1The court relied on Section 47 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 as the appellate provision
cover pageThe welfare of the minor is the paramount consideration in custody and guardianship adjudication
¶ 15A child should not be deprived of a father's love and affection, and a natural father should not be denied custody without consideration of the relevant conditions
¶ 14A court must give reasons supported by evidence and not rest findings on unsupported assertions
¶ 10–11No precedents were cited in the judgment
Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 Section 47Section 7Section 25
04Reasoning
Respondent No. 1, being ex parte, neither filed objections nor entered the witness box to assert that the child was with her. The Family Court therefore erred in relying on the grandparents' statements to conclude that the child was in their custody
¶ 10The Family Court's reasoning was cryptic. It did not discuss Exs. P1–P10 or the oral evidence, and rested solely on the child's residence since birth and the father's alleged inability to provide care
¶ 11–12The High Court held that this reasoning had "no basis" and rested on unsupported statements of the grandparents
¶ 11The subsequent daily orders of 11.04.2023, 13.12.2023 and 18.12.2023 showed that the child was in fact in the custody of the grandparents, not the mother
¶ 12The court further noted that the mother had remarried, had two children from that marriage, and that this fact was ignored by the Family Court
¶ 13Applying the welfare principle, the court concluded that the Family Court had "mechanically" rejected the father's petition without considering the relevant conditions. It held that handing custody to the father would serve the child's interest
¶ 14If the mother wished to see the child, a visitation arrangement, rather than dismissal of the petition, would have been the appropriate course
¶ 1505Holding
The court answered the issues in the affirmative. The judgment of the Family Court was found unsustainable because it relied on unsupported statements of the grandparents, was cryptic, and ignored material facts
¶ 9–14The appeal was allowed. The judgment and order dated 20.02.2019 in G&WC No. 8/2017 was set aside, and the petition was allowed as prayed for, with the appellant granted guardianship and custody of the minor child
¶ 17(a) · ¶ 17(b)The court observed that the mother could be granted visitation rights if she wished to see the child
¶ 15Original Court PDF
ABDUL BASHEER AHMEDvsHURMAT BEGUM AND ORS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
