Karnataka High CourtCivil LawInsurance Law

Karnataka HC Enhances Compensation for Farm Worker With Crushed Left Hand to ₹17.44 Lakh

SRI. BHIMASHI S/O HANAMANT METIv.MR. AMISH NIRANJANBHAI MOMAY

Karnataka HC Enhances Compensation for Farm Worker With Crushed Left Hand to ₹17.44 Lakh. SRI. BHIMASHI S/O HANAMANT METI vs MR. AMISH NIRANJANBHAI MOMAY. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the judgment and award in MVC No. 2011/2014 (Sridevi) requires interference.

The court held

(i) Yes, MVC No. 2011/2014 (Sridevi) requires interference. MFA 102990/2018 is allowed in part.

It also directed

Sridevi is awarded ₹17,44,230 with 9% interest from the date of petition until realisation. R2 and R4 must deposit the amount with interest in a 60:40 ratio before the jurisdictional Tribunal within eight weeks of receiving a certified copy of the judgment, and the Registry must draw a modified award.

(ii) No, MVC No. 2010/2014 (Bhimashi) does not require interference. MFA 102991/2018 is dismissed, with liberty to R2 and R4 to file an application under Section 152 CPC before the Tribunal to correct the arithmetical error in the disability computation.

01Facts

On 25.07.2014, a truck (GJ-01-AY-8811) rear-ended the claimants' motorcycle. A car (MH-10-C-0070), overtaking the truck, then collided with the motorcycle.

¶ 2–3

Liability was fixed on the truck's insurer (R2, National Insurance) and the car's insurer (R4, United India) at 60:40.

¶ 2–3

Two claims were filed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act and decided together by the V Additional District and Sessions Judge and VI Additional MACT, Belagavi, on 06.04.2018.

¶ 4

The Tribunal awarded ₹3,02,500 in MVC No. 2010/2014 (Bhimashi) and ₹1,71,000 in MVC No. 2011/2014 (Sridevi).

¶ 4

In MFA 102990, Sridevi, an agricultural coolie, claimed 100% disability and a 49-day hospitalisation.

¶ 5, 16

The Tribunal discarded her disability certificate (Ex.P9) because the issuing doctor was not examined as a treating doctor.

¶ 5, 10

In MFA 102991, Bhimashi, an agriculturist, claimed enhancement for loss of income during the laid-up period, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities. The Tribunal had assessed his disability at 13.3%.

¶ 6, 18

The insurers filed no appeal or cross-objection, but pointed to an arithmetical error in the disability computation (25% of 1/3rd) and to errors in income, age and multiplier.

¶ 7, 19–20

02Issues

i.1. Whether the judgment and award in MVC No. 2011/2014 (Sridevi) requires interference.

¶ 9(i)

ii.2. Whether the judgment and award in MVC No. 2010/2014 (Bhimashi) requires interference.

¶ 9(ii)

03Law Applied

Sections 166 and 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act form the procedural basis for the claims and appeals.

¶ 1–2

For assessing permanent disability, Schedule I of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 assigns 60% permanent disability for loss of a thumb and four fingers of one hand.

¶ 13

Under Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (2011) 1 SCC 343, loss of earning capacity is assessed by reference to the nature of the claimant's work, the employment prospects and the injury's effect on those prospects.

¶ 14–15

On interest, Puttamma v. K.L. Narayana Reddy (2013) 15 SCC 45 makes inflation, economic conditions and RBI policy relevant, and a Co-ordinate Bench decision in United India Insurance Co. v. Malyadari (MFA 3895/2018) favours 9% for death and serious injury cases.

¶ 17 & fn. 3

Under Satya Prakash Dwivedi v. Munna @ Chandrabhan Yadav (2021 INSC 491), a claimant's appeal cannot reduce or disturb the Tribunal's findings where the insurer has not appealed or filed a cross-objection, and the claimant cannot be placed in a worse position.

¶ 19

Corrections of arithmetical or clerical errors are made under Section 152 CPC.

¶ 19–21

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 152

04Reasoning

In MFA 102990, the Court held that the Tribunal erred in disregarding Ex.P9. PW2, the doctor who issued it, was examined and cross-examined without any material being elicited against him. Ex.P6 (wound certificate) and Ex.P10 (medical bills) showed that he was the treating doctor.

¶ 12

Applying the Schedule I benchmark and the Raj Kumar principles, the Court held that the claimant's 80% upper-limb and 10% lower-limb disability, with the bleak prospect of continuing coolie work, amounted to 75% functional disability.

¶ 13–15

Using a notional income of ₹7,500 per month (KSLSA chart) and multiplier 18, the Court recomputed loss of future earnings at ₹12,15,000 and re-quantified the other heads, producing a total of ₹17,44,230.

¶ 15–16

Interest was reduced from the claimed 12% to 9% from the date of petition, given the permanent disability.

¶ 17

In MFA 102991, the Court found that the insurers had not appealed or cross-objected. Following Satya Prakash Dwivedi, the Tribunal's 13.3% disability finding could not be reduced at the claimant's instance, even though the insurers had pointed to an arithmetical error.

¶ 19–20

The judgment does not separately discuss the individual enhancement heads (laid-up income, pain and suffering, loss of amenities) raised in MFA 102991.

05Holding

(i) Yes, MVC No. 2011/2014 (Sridevi) requires interference. MFA 102990/2018 is allowed in part.

¶ 15–21

Sridevi is awarded ₹17,44,230 with 9% interest from the date of petition until realisation. R2 and R4 must deposit the amount with interest in a 60:40 ratio before the jurisdictional Tribunal within eight weeks of receiving a certified copy of the judgment, and the Registry must draw a modified award.

¶ 15–21

(ii) No, MVC No. 2010/2014 (Bhimashi) does not require interference. MFA 102991/2018 is dismissed, with liberty to R2 and R4 to file an application under Section 152 CPC before the Tribunal to correct the arithmetical error in the disability computation.

¶ 19–21
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SRI. BHIMASHI S/O HANAMANT METIvsMR. AMISH NIRANJANBHAI MOMAY

Karnataka High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment