01Facts
On 25.07.2014, a truck (GJ-01-AY-8811) struck the claimants' motorcycle from behind. A car (MH-10-C-0070), overtaking the truck, then collided with the motorcycle.
¶ 3The Tribunal (V Addl. DJ & VI Addl. MACT, Belagavi) fixed liability on the truck's insurer (R2, National Insurance) and the car's insurer (R4, United India) in a 60:40 ratio, with no dispute on this point.
¶ 2The Tribunal awarded ₹3,02,500/- in MVC No. 2010/2014 (Bhimashi) and ₹1,71,000/- in MVC No. 2011/2014 (Sridevi).
¶ 4Sridevi, an agricultural coolie, was hospitalised for 49 days.
¶ 5, 16The Tribunal discarded her disability certificate (Ex. P9) because the issuing doctor was not examined, and it awarded no loss-of-earning-capacity or amenities compensation.
¶ 5, 10Bhimashi's disability was assessed at 13.3%, and he sought enhancement under the heads of laid-up income, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities.
¶ 6Both claimants appealed seeking enhancement. The insurers filed no appeal or cross-objection, but pointed to alleged arithmetic and multiplier errors in Bhimashi's award.
¶ 7–802Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in discarding Ex. P9 and in assessing Sridevi's permanent disability, warranting enhancement of compensation in MVC No. 2011/2014.
¶ 9(i), 10–12ii.2. Whether the award in MVC No. 2010/2014 requires interference, given that the insurers filed no cross-objection while an arithmetical error in the disability computation was alleged.
¶ 9(ii), 18–20iii.3. What order should be passed.
¶ 9(iii), 2103Law Applied
Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is the statutory basis for enhancement appeals.
¶ 1Schedule I of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, which assigns 60% permanent disability for loss of a thumb and four fingers of one hand, is used as a guide to assessing physical disability.
¶ 13Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, (2011) 1 SCC 343: functional disability and loss of future earning capacity are assessed by reference to the claimant's occupation and employability.
¶ 14The Karnataka State Legal Services Authority notional income chart is applied to fix income.
¶ 15Puttamma v. K.L. Narayana Reddy, (2013) 15 SCC 45: interest requires consideration of inflation and RBI policy. United India Insurance Co. v. Malyadari, MFA No. 3895/2018 (Karn. HC): 9% is favoured in cases of death or serious injury.
¶ 17Satya Prakash Dwivedi v. Munna @ Chandrabhan Yadav, 2021 INSC 491: a claimant's disability finding cannot be reduced in the absence of an appeal or cross-objection by the insurer, and a claimant cannot be worse off in his own appeal.
¶ 19Correction of computational errors is available under Section 152 CPC.
¶ 20–21Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 152
04Reasoning
The Tribunal wrongly discarded Ex. P9. The issuing doctor (PW-2) was examined, was cross-examined at length without any useful admission, and corroborated the certificate. Ex. P6 (wound certificate) and Ex. P10 (medical bills) further show that he was the treating doctor.
¶ 11–12Read with Ex. P6 and Ex. P9, which record deformation and loss of movement of the left upper limb, the court found 80% permanent disability of the upper limb and 10% of the lower limb. Having regard to the Schedule I benchmark and Raj Kumar, it assessed 75% functional disability, because Sridevi's agricultural coolie work was no longer viable and she needed help with clothing and daily routine.
¶ 13–15Income was fixed at ₹7,500/- per month, with a multiplier of 18, age being undisputed.
¶ 15Future loss of earnings was computed at ₹12,15,000/- (7,500 × 12 × 18 × 75%). Heads were recast in light of the 49-day hospitalisation, including laid-up income, conveyance, and nourishment.
¶ 16Interest was reduced from the claimed 12% to 9% from the date of petition, given the permanent disability.
¶ 17As to Bhimashi (MFA No. 102991), the insurers did not appeal or file cross-objections. Although the court accepted that the disability computation contained an arithmetical error (the insurers contended 8.3% instead of 13.3%), it declined to revisit the Tribunal's finding. Under Satya Prakash Dwivedi, the claimant could not be placed in a worse position in his own appeal.
¶ 19–20The insurers were instead left at liberty to seek correction under Section 152 CPC before the Tribunal.
¶ 20The court did not separately address the enhancement claims under the laid-up, pain and suffering, and loss-of-amenities heads, nor the multiplier and income disputes, and its reasoning on these points is not stated.
05Holding
The award in MVC No. 2011/2014 requires interference, since the Tribunal wrongly discarded the corroborated disability certificate (Ex. P9) and under-assessed compensation.
¶ 9(i), 12–16The award in MVC No. 2010/2014 does not require interference, because the insurers' arithmetical objection could not be entertained without a cross-objection, and the insurers were left to seek correction under Section 152 CPC.
¶ 9(ii), 19–20MFA No. 102990/2018 (Sridevi) allowed in part. The award in MVC No. 2011/2014 is modified. Sridevi is entitled to ₹17,44,230/- with 9% interest per annum from the date of the petition until realisation.
¶ 21The insurers (R2 and R4) must deposit the amount with interest in a 60:40 ratio before the jurisdictional Tribunal within eight weeks of receipt of a certified copy. The Registry is to transmit any deposit and the records to the Tribunal and draw a modified award.
¶ 21MFA No. 102991/2018 (Bhimashi) dismissed, with liberty to R2 and R4 to apply under Section 152 CPC before the Tribunal. The Registry is to transmit the trial court records.
¶ 21Original Court PDF
SMT. SRIDEVI W/O BHIMASHI METIvsMR. AMISH NIRANJANBHAI MOMBAY
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
