Karnataka High CourtCivil LawInsurance Law

Karnataka HC Raises Compensation To ₹17.44 Lakh For Woman Whose Left Hand Was Crushed In Truck Crash

SMT. SRIDEVI W/O BHIMASHI METIv.MR. AMISH NIRANJANBHAI MOMBAY

Karnataka HC Raises Compensation To ₹17.44 Lakh For Woman Whose Left Hand Was Crushed In Truck Crash. SMT. SRIDEVI W/O BHIMASHI METI vs MR. AMISH NIRANJANBHAI MOMBAY. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Tribunal erred in discarding Ex. P9 and in assessing Sridevi's permanent disability, warranting enhancement of compensation in MVC No. 2011/2014.

The court held

The award in MVC No. 2011/2014 requires interference, since the Tribunal wrongly discarded the corroborated disability certificate (Ex. P9) and under-assessed compensation.

It also directed

The award in MVC No. 2010/2014 does not require interference, because the insurers' arithmetical objection could not be entertained without a cross-objection, and the insurers were left to seek correction under Section 152 CPC.

MFA No. 102990/2018 (Sridevi) allowed in part. The award in MVC No. 2011/2014 is modified. Sridevi is entitled to ₹17,44,230/- with 9% interest per annum from the date of the petition until realisation.

The insurers (R2 and R4) must deposit the amount with interest in a 60:40 ratio before the jurisdictional Tribunal within eight weeks of receipt of a certified copy. The Registry is to transmit any deposit and the records to the Tribunal and draw a modified award.

MFA No. 102991/2018 (Bhimashi) dismissed, with liberty to R2 and R4 to apply under Section 152 CPC before the Tribunal. The Registry is to transmit the trial court records.

01Facts

On 25.07.2014, a truck (GJ-01-AY-8811) struck the claimants' motorcycle from behind. A car (MH-10-C-0070), overtaking the truck, then collided with the motorcycle.

¶ 3

The Tribunal (V Addl. DJ & VI Addl. MACT, Belagavi) fixed liability on the truck's insurer (R2, National Insurance) and the car's insurer (R4, United India) in a 60:40 ratio, with no dispute on this point.

¶ 2

The Tribunal awarded ₹3,02,500/- in MVC No. 2010/2014 (Bhimashi) and ₹1,71,000/- in MVC No. 2011/2014 (Sridevi).

¶ 4

Sridevi, an agricultural coolie, was hospitalised for 49 days.

¶ 5, 16

The Tribunal discarded her disability certificate (Ex. P9) because the issuing doctor was not examined, and it awarded no loss-of-earning-capacity or amenities compensation.

¶ 5, 10

Bhimashi's disability was assessed at 13.3%, and he sought enhancement under the heads of laid-up income, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities.

¶ 6

Both claimants appealed seeking enhancement. The insurers filed no appeal or cross-objection, but pointed to alleged arithmetic and multiplier errors in Bhimashi's award.

¶ 7–8

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in discarding Ex. P9 and in assessing Sridevi's permanent disability, warranting enhancement of compensation in MVC No. 2011/2014.

¶ 9(i), 10–12

ii.2. Whether the award in MVC No. 2010/2014 requires interference, given that the insurers filed no cross-objection while an arithmetical error in the disability computation was alleged.

¶ 9(ii), 18–20

iii.3. What order should be passed.

¶ 9(iii), 21

03Law Applied

Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is the statutory basis for enhancement appeals.

¶ 1

Schedule I of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, which assigns 60% permanent disability for loss of a thumb and four fingers of one hand, is used as a guide to assessing physical disability.

¶ 13

Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, (2011) 1 SCC 343: functional disability and loss of future earning capacity are assessed by reference to the claimant's occupation and employability.

¶ 14

The Karnataka State Legal Services Authority notional income chart is applied to fix income.

¶ 15

Puttamma v. K.L. Narayana Reddy, (2013) 15 SCC 45: interest requires consideration of inflation and RBI policy. United India Insurance Co. v. Malyadari, MFA No. 3895/2018 (Karn. HC): 9% is favoured in cases of death or serious injury.

¶ 17

Satya Prakash Dwivedi v. Munna @ Chandrabhan Yadav, 2021 INSC 491: a claimant's disability finding cannot be reduced in the absence of an appeal or cross-objection by the insurer, and a claimant cannot be worse off in his own appeal.

¶ 19

Correction of computational errors is available under Section 152 CPC.

¶ 20–21

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173Section 166

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 152

04Reasoning

The Tribunal wrongly discarded Ex. P9. The issuing doctor (PW-2) was examined, was cross-examined at length without any useful admission, and corroborated the certificate. Ex. P6 (wound certificate) and Ex. P10 (medical bills) further show that he was the treating doctor.

¶ 11–12

Read with Ex. P6 and Ex. P9, which record deformation and loss of movement of the left upper limb, the court found 80% permanent disability of the upper limb and 10% of the lower limb. Having regard to the Schedule I benchmark and Raj Kumar, it assessed 75% functional disability, because Sridevi's agricultural coolie work was no longer viable and she needed help with clothing and daily routine.

¶ 13–15

Income was fixed at ₹7,500/- per month, with a multiplier of 18, age being undisputed.

¶ 15

Future loss of earnings was computed at ₹12,15,000/- (7,500 × 12 × 18 × 75%). Heads were recast in light of the 49-day hospitalisation, including laid-up income, conveyance, and nourishment.

¶ 16

Interest was reduced from the claimed 12% to 9% from the date of petition, given the permanent disability.

¶ 17

As to Bhimashi (MFA No. 102991), the insurers did not appeal or file cross-objections. Although the court accepted that the disability computation contained an arithmetical error (the insurers contended 8.3% instead of 13.3%), it declined to revisit the Tribunal's finding. Under Satya Prakash Dwivedi, the claimant could not be placed in a worse position in his own appeal.

¶ 19–20

The insurers were instead left at liberty to seek correction under Section 152 CPC before the Tribunal.

¶ 20

The court did not separately address the enhancement claims under the laid-up, pain and suffering, and loss-of-amenities heads, nor the multiplier and income disputes, and its reasoning on these points is not stated.

05Holding

The award in MVC No. 2011/2014 requires interference, since the Tribunal wrongly discarded the corroborated disability certificate (Ex. P9) and under-assessed compensation.

¶ 9(i), 12–16

The award in MVC No. 2010/2014 does not require interference, because the insurers' arithmetical objection could not be entertained without a cross-objection, and the insurers were left to seek correction under Section 152 CPC.

¶ 9(ii), 19–20

MFA No. 102990/2018 (Sridevi) allowed in part. The award in MVC No. 2011/2014 is modified. Sridevi is entitled to ₹17,44,230/- with 9% interest per annum from the date of the petition until realisation.

¶ 21

The insurers (R2 and R4) must deposit the amount with interest in a 60:40 ratio before the jurisdictional Tribunal within eight weeks of receipt of a certified copy. The Registry is to transmit any deposit and the records to the Tribunal and draw a modified award.

¶ 21

MFA No. 102991/2018 (Bhimashi) dismissed, with liberty to R2 and R4 to apply under Section 152 CPC before the Tribunal. The Registry is to transmit the trial court records.

¶ 21
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SMT. SRIDEVI W/O BHIMASHI METIvsMR. AMISH NIRANJANBHAI MOMBAY

Karnataka High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment