Karnataka High CourtAdministrative and Public LawProperty and Real Estate Law

Karnataka HC Orders MESCOM To Pay Udupi Mutt Arrears of Rs 275 Annual Rent Withheld Since 2017

SRI. BHIMASETHU MUNIVRUNDA MATHAv.THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka HC Orders MESCOM To Pay Udupi Mutt Arrears of Rs 275 Annual Rent Withheld Since 2017. SRI. BHIMASETHU MUNIVRUNDA MATHA vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether a writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable for recovery of arrears of lease rent, or whether the Mutt must be relegated to a civil suit under Section 108 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

The court held

The writ petitions are maintainable, and MESCOM, as a State instrumentality, cannot avoid its contractual rent obligation by relegating the lessor to a civil suit or by citing an unrelated GST/PAN requirement.

It also directed

The writs are allowed. MESCOM must pay all arrears of rent due under the Lease Deed dated 27.11.1937 within four weeks of receiving a certified copy of the order.

MESCOM must maintain the nature and character of the land as per the Lease Deed, make no alteration, and not establish any sub-station until fair and reasonable rent is fixed, for the remainder of the lease period.

The Deputy Commissioner, Udupi, must decide the representations dated 14.02.2023, 07.12.2023 and 08.09.2026 within four weeks.

MESCOM must pay Rs. 25,000 as litigation costs to the Mutt.

01Facts

The petitioner, a religious Mutt, leased 1 acre 35 cents in Sy. No. 130/2A3, Mudanidamburu Village, Udupi Taluk, to the predecessors of respondent No. 4 (MESCOM) under a registered Lease Deed dated 27.11.1937 for 99 years at an annual rent of Rs. 275.

¶ 4

Electricity distribution passed from the nationalised Udupi Electric Supply Corporation to the Karnataka Electricity Board, then to KPTCL (respondent No. 3), and finally to MESCOM, which is in possession.

¶ 5 · ¶ 20

The Mutt alleges that MESCOM has not paid rent since 2017, has cut trees on the land, and has erected an electric sub-station without its consent, despite the land being non-agricultural, in a flood-prone, densely populated area.

¶ 6–8, 20–21

MESCOM's stated defence is that the rent was withheld because the Mutt had not furnished GST and PAN details, a demand made only after the Mutt's legal notice.

¶ 26, 32

MESCOM states that the sub-station occupies about 33.94 cents and that it is fenced.

¶ 25

Earlier interim orders dated 14.02.2025 and 21.02.2025 directed MESCOM to make a written offer of enhanced rent, and MESCOM's request to put up a structure was rejected in view of a 05.12.2022 restraint order.

¶ 28–29

MESCOM's writ appeal (W.A. No. 290 of 2023) was dismissed on 20.06.2023, and the Supreme Court in SLP (C) No. 22621 of 2025 (04.08.2025) granted liberty to approach the High Court for final disposal.

¶ 30

The Court recorded that MESCOM had shown no steps to pay arrears despite these orders.

¶ 30

The Mutt also filed W.P. No. 29451/2026 seeking a direction to the Deputy Commissioner, Udupi, to decide its representations dated 14.02.2023, 07.12.2023 and 08.09.2026.

¶ 1, 9

02Issues

i.1. Whether a writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable for recovery of arrears of lease rent, or whether the Mutt must be relegated to a civil suit under Section 108 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

¶ 16, 27, 36–37

ii.2. Whether MESCOM, as a statutory body and instrumentality of the State under Article 12, may withhold the annual rent and fail to negotiate enhancement, in violation of Article 14 and the Lease Deed.

¶ 31–33, 37

iii.3. Whether MESCOM's establishment of a sub-station on the leased land, without the lessor's consent and without enhancement of rent, can be sustained under the Lease Deed.

¶ 21–22, 38(iii)

iv.4. Whether the Deputy Commissioner is required to decide the Mutt's pending representations.

¶ 9, 38(iv)

03Law Applied

Article 12 of the Constitution treats MESCOM as a State instrumentality bound by Article 14.

¶ 21, 37

The lessee's obligation to pay rent regularly under the Lease Deed and Section 108 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

¶ 11, 20, 27

Article 226 and the principle that the alternative-remedy bar is a rule of discretion, not compulsion, as stated in Neha Chandrakanth Shroff v. State of Maharashtra (2025).

¶ 36

Writ jurisdiction may be exercised in lease/contract disputes involving immovable property where no complicated factual investigation is needed, as stated in Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Dollydas (1999) 4 SCC 450.

¶ 35

A fair and reasonable rent must be ensured to the lessor, and arrangements that become unreasonable over time must be revisited, as stated in Malpe Vishwanath Acharya v. State of Maharashtra (AIR 1998 SC 602).

¶ 31, 34

A statutory corporation continuing occupation without paying rent acts unbecomingly and must pay market-rate arrears, as stated in National Company v. Territory Manager, Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. (AIR Online 2021 SC 1014).

¶ 33

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 108

04Reasoning

The writ remedy was maintainable because the dispute concerned a registered lease of a State instrumentality and turned on documentary material, not on complex fact-finding.

¶ 35–37

Rejecting MESCOM's plea that the Mutt should file a civil suit for a meagre Rs. 275 annual rent, the Court held that such relegation would be unjust, since civil litigation would take years to conclude.

¶ 36

The GST/PAN explanation was an afterthought, raised only after the legal notice, and could not justify withholding rent on the entire 1 acre 35 cents that MESCOM continued to occupy.

¶ 32

Applying Malpe Vishwanath Acharya and the principle that a statutory body must not act arbitrarily, the Court treated MESCOM's conduct, including non-compliance with the earlier orders of 14.02.2025 and 21.02.2025 and its failure to negotiate enhancement, as contrary to fairness and legitimate expectation.

¶ 30–31, 33, 38

On the sub-station, the Court noted that the land is non-agricultural, that the sub-station was built without the lessor's consent, and that the 2005 correspondence did not show any permitted use.

¶ 22, 26

The Court restrained further alteration and the establishment of the sub-station until a fair rent is fixed.

¶ 38(iii)

The Court did not decide the separate question of planning or land-use compliance under the Karnataka Land Revenue Act or the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, which were raised in argument.

¶ 11

05Holding

The writ petitions are maintainable, and MESCOM, as a State instrumentality, cannot avoid its contractual rent obligation by relegating the lessor to a civil suit or by citing an unrelated GST/PAN requirement.

¶ 37–38

The writs are allowed. MESCOM must pay all arrears of rent due under the Lease Deed dated 27.11.1937 within four weeks of receiving a certified copy of the order.

¶ 38(ii)

MESCOM must maintain the nature and character of the land as per the Lease Deed, make no alteration, and not establish any sub-station until fair and reasonable rent is fixed, for the remainder of the lease period.

¶ 38(iii)

The Deputy Commissioner, Udupi, must decide the representations dated 14.02.2023, 07.12.2023 and 08.09.2026 within four weeks.

¶ 38(iv)

MESCOM must pay Rs. 25,000 as litigation costs to the Mutt.

¶ 38(v)
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SRI. BHIMASETHU MUNIVRUNDA MATHAvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court · November 12, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment