01Facts
The Wakf Board, by order dated 20 June 2024, approved an 11-member committee to manage several institutions in Chandawar, including Noorani Masjid, for three years or until further orders.
p. 7On 6 July 2024, the Board approved a separate 11-member committee to manage Noorani Masjid for the same period.
pp. 8–9The petitioner committee challenged the later order, contending that Noorani Masjid was already within its management. It also disputed the separate registration of Noorani Masjid, relying on a public notice identifying it as an additional institution under its management.
pp. 4–6, 9–1002Issues
i.Whether the Wakf Board could constitute a separate managing committee for Noorani Masjid when the subsisting order constituting the petitioner committee already included that institution.
pp. 9–10ii.Whether the separate registration of Noorani Masjid was valid.
pp. 9–1003Law Applied
The Board’s committee-constitution orders invoked Section 32(2)(g) of the Waqf Act, 1995, as amended in 2013, read with Rule 54(1) of the Karnataka Waqf Rules, 2017.
pp. 7–9The Court treated the subsisting committee order as operative: because it expressly included Noorani Masjid and had not been withdrawn, cancelled, or challenged, the Board could not appoint another committee to manage the same institution while that order remained in force.
p. 7 · pp. 9–10The Court did not determine the legal validity of Noorani Masjid’s separate registration.
p. 10Provisions in the judgment · 1
Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025 Section 32
04Reasoning
The Court compared the two Board orders and found that the 20 June 2024 order expressly included Noorani Masjid among the institutions assigned to the petitioner committee, while the 6 July 2024 order created a second committee for that same institution.
pp. 7–9Since the earlier order remained operative, the later appointment was inconsistent with it and created an anomaly warranting the quashing of the later order.
p. 10As the petitioner had not established that it objected to the public notice concerning Noorani Masjid, the Court declined to decide the validity of the separate registration and left that question for the Board to reconsider after hearing the parties.
p. 1005Holding
The writ petition was partly allowed.
p. 10The Court quashed the Wakf Board’s order dated 6 July 2024 constituting a separate committee for Noorani Masjid.
p. 10It remitted the question of the separate registration to the Board for rehearing and an appropriate decision after giving the concerned parties an opportunity to be heard, directing that the process be completed within six months.
p. 11The interim order was extended until the Board’s decision.
p. 11Original Court PDF
JAMATUL MUSALIMEEN COMMITTEE CHANDAWARvsTHE KARNATAKA STATE BOARD OF AUQAFS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
