01Facts
The petitioner challenged the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal’s dismissal of his application concerning his non-qualification in the physical standards test for recruitment as an Inspector of Motor Vehicles.
Although his name appeared in the final select list, he alleged discrepancies in the measurement of his height at the test conducted on 20 August 2022.
The Tribunal dismissed his application as “not maintainable & barred by time”.
pp. 4–5Before the High Court, the petitioner also argued that height was not a relevant selection requirement, while acknowledging that he had not raised that issue before the Tribunal.
pp. 6–7The High Court measured his height during the proceedings and found it to be 165.5 cm, below the prescribed minimum of 168 cm.
p. 602Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal’s dismissal of the petitioner’s application concerning the physical standards test warranted interference under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution
pp. 3–5ii.2. Whether the petitioner could, at the writ stage, challenge the relevance of the prescribed height requirement when he had not raised that challenge before the Tribunal or in a separate proceeding
pp. 6–803Law Applied
The petition was brought under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, which confer writ and supervisory jurisdiction on the High Court.
p. 3The Court applied the procedural principle that a challenge to a recruitment requirement cannot be introduced for the first time at a later stage, particularly after the candidate has been tested against that requirement, when the requirement was neither challenged before the Tribunal nor through an independent petition.
pp. 7–8The judgment cites no statute, regulation, or precedent setting out this principle; the Court relied on its application to the facts of this case.
pp. 7–804Reasoning
The Court found that the petitioner’s measured height was 165.5 cm, below the 168 cm minimum prescribed for male candidates.
p. 6The petitioner’s argument that height was irrelevant to the post was not raised before the Tribunal, and he had not independently challenged the recruitment notification’s height requirement.
pp. 7–8In those circumstances, the Court declined to consider that argument when raised in the writ proceedings, particularly after the Court’s own measurement confirmed that the petitioner did not meet the prescribed standard.
pp. 6–805Holding
The Court rejected the petitioner’s challenge to the height requirement as an issue raised too late and dismissed the writ petition.
p. 8The Tribunal’s order was therefore left undisturbed.
p. 8Original Court PDF
MR. VISHWANATH B WALIKAR,vsTHE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
