01Facts
The appellant, whose wife—a primary school teacher—died in harness, sought compassionate appointment as her widower.
pp. 3–4He had twice approached the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal (KAT), which allowed his applications with directions; the authorities nevertheless rejected his claim by endorsements.
pp. 3–4He then challenged an endorsement and the validity of the applicable rule, which he contended did not provide for appointment of a widower, and sought age relaxation before the High Court.
pp. 3–4The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition, leaving him liberty to approach the Tribunal again.
pp. 3–4, 9The appellant appealed.
pp. 3–4, 902Issues
i.Whether the appellant could directly pursue before the High Court his challenge to the rule governing compassionate appointment, rather than first approaching the Tribunal.
pp. 4–6ii.Whether the learned Single Judge erred in dismissing the writ petition and relegating the appellant to the Tribunal.
pp. 3–4, 903Law Applied
In L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India, the Supreme Court held that tribunals are courts of first instance in matters within their jurisdiction, including cases involving challenges to the vires of legislation other than the statute establishing the tribunal; their decisions remain subject to review by a Division Bench of the High Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
pp. 4–7The Supreme Court reiterated this rule in Rajeev Kumar v. Hemraj Singh Chauhan.
pp. 7–9Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961 Section 4
04Reasoning
The appellant’s challenge concerned a service matter within the KAT’s jurisdiction.
pp. 4–9Under L. Chandra Kumar and Rajeev Kumar, the Tribunal was the proper forum of first instance even though the appellant questioned the validity of the applicable rule.
pp. 4–9The fact that the appellant had previously obtained Tribunal orders, followed by adverse endorsements, did not permit him to bypass that forum and directly seek relief from the High Court.
pp. 4–9The Division Bench therefore found no error in the Single Judge’s decision to leave the appellant to pursue the matter before the Tribunal; it did not determine the merits of his entitlement to compassionate appointment or age relaxation.
pp. 4–905Holding
The Court held that the appellant could not bypass the Tribunal, which was the court of first instance for his service-related claim.
pp. 9–10Finding no error in the Single Judge’s order, it affirmed that order and rejected the writ appeal.
pp. 9–10Pending interlocutory applications were disposed of as not calling for adjudication.
pp. 9–10Original Court PDF
MAHANTESH S/O BASAYYA KALLIMATHvsSTATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
