01Facts
On 18 January 2011, the Horticulture Department issued a communication directing U.K. HOPCOMS, a registered co-operative society, to hand over its affairs—including day-to-day financial operations—to the Assistant Director of Horticulture.
pp. 3–4The Society challenged the communication by writ petition. The Single Judge quashed it, finding no basis to treat the Society as an “assisted society” and therefore no authority under Section 29-G of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959 to appoint an official to manage its affairs.
pp. 7–8The State appealed, relying in part on a later amendment to the definition of “assisted society”.
pp. 4–5 · ¶ 1902Issues
i.1. Whether, in the absence of the Society being an “assisted society” under Section 2(a-1-1), the State could invoke Section 29-G to direct it to hand over its management and affairs to the Assistant Director of Horticulture.
pp. 8–9ii.2. Whether the subsequent amendment to the definition of “assisted society” could retrospectively validate the 2011 communication.
¶ 1903Law Applied
Section 2(a-1-1) of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959 defines an “assisted society” as a co-operative society that has received Government or State assistance in the form of share capital, loan, grant, or guarantee for repayment of a loan or interest.
p. 9Under Section 29-G, a co-operative society ordinarily appoints and removes its own Chief Executive; the Government or Registrar may do so in the specified statutory circumstances, including for an assisted society, subject to the Act and rules.
pp. 10–14Executive instructions cannot enlarge statutory powers, and a later amendment cannot retrospectively validate an earlier action unless retrospective effect or validation is expressly or necessarily provided.
pp. 16–18 · ¶ 1904Reasoning
Section 29-G made the Society’s status as an assisted society a necessary basis for the State’s power to appoint a Chief Executive and assume the associated management functions.
pp. 15–16The State produced no material showing that the Society had received any of the forms of assistance specified in Section 2(a-1-1).
pp. 15–16Nor could the 2008 Government Order concerning implementation of the National Horticulture Mission supply statutory authority to displace the Society’s management.
p. 16The Court held that the later amendment could not cure the lack of authority when the communication was issued in 2011, absent retrospective operation or a validating provision.
pp. 17–18 · ¶ 1905Holding
The Court held that the Society was not shown to be an assisted society and that the State therefore lacked authority under Section 29-G to compel it to hand over its administration and affairs.
pp. 18–19 · ¶ 21Finding no error warranting appellate interference, the Court dismissed the writ appeal and left the Single Judge’s order quashing the communication undisturbed.
¶ 21–22Original Court PDF
The State Of KarnatakavsU K Jilla Totada Belagarara
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
