Karnataka High CourtArbitration and MediationCivil Procedure and Evidence

Karnataka HC Upholds Order Requiring Tenants To Deposit Rent, As Award Debtor Disputed Arbitration Costs But Did Not Pay Under Protest

MRS. DEEPA. Bv.ABHISHEK PACHASIA

Karnataka HC Upholds Order Requiring Tenants To Deposit Rent, As Award Debtor Disputed Arbitration Costs But Did Not Pay Under Protest. MRS. DEEPA. B vs ABHISHEK PACHASIA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Execution Court’s direction requiring tenants to deposit rents should be set aside because the signed award had not been furnished and the petitioners had not yet been able to pursue a Section 34 challenge.

The court held

The Court declined to interfere with the orders rejecting the applications and directing the tenants to deposit rents, finding no error or infirmity warranting writ intervention.

It also directed

It disposed of the writ petition and clarified that the petitioners may seek adjustment of the amounts deposited before the Execution Court against any deposit condition imposed in Section 34 proceedings; that request is for the jurisdictional court to decide in accordance with law.

01Facts

An arbitral award dated 16 October 2024 was followed by execution proceedings in Ex.P. No. 1308/2026.

pp. 3–8

The petitioners challenged the Execution Court’s order dated 28 September 2026, which rejected their applications under Section 47 CPC and Section 151 CPC read with Section 36 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and directed tenants to deposit rents.

pp. 3–8

The petitioners argued that they had not received the signed award because the Arbitration Centre was withholding it pending payment of disputed costs, and therefore could not pursue a Section 34 challenge.

pp. 3–8

A related writ petition challenging the costs demand was pending.

pp. 3–8

The petitioners sought to set aside the Execution Court’s order.

p. 3

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Execution Court’s direction requiring tenants to deposit rents should be set aside because the signed award had not been furnished and the petitioners had not yet been able to pursue a Section 34 challenge.

pp. 4–6, 11–12

ii.2. Whether non-payment of disputed arbitration costs, in circumstances where the signed award was withheld, could indefinitely postpone enforcement of the award.

pp. 8–11

03Law Applied

Section 34(3) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 provides that the limitation period for challenging an award begins on receipt of the signed copy; under Section 36, an award becomes enforceable upon expiry of the statutory period for a Section 34 application, subject to the provision’s requirements.

p. 8, 12

The Court recognised that an award-debtor may challenge an unreasonable or otherwise disputed costs demand in appropriate proceedings, but held that the debtor cannot rely on non-receipt of the award to indefinitely defer enforcement where the non-communication is attributed to failure to comply with that demand and the debtor has not taken steps such as depositing the costs under protest.

pp. 9–10

The Court also treated conditional interim protection and the preservation of the decree-holder’s interests as equitable considerations.

pp. 10–12

Sections 47 and 151 CPC and Section 38(2) of the Act arose in the applications and submissions before the Court.

p. 3, 5

Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 47Section 151

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 34Section 36Section 38

04Reasoning

The Court accepted that limitation under Section 34(3) ordinarily runs from receipt of the signed award, but distinguished the case because the award had not been furnished due to the petitioners’ dispute over the costs demanded by the Arbitration Centre.

pp. 8–10

They could have deposited the costs under protest and pursued the pending challenge, but had not done so.

pp. 8–10

The Court held that allowing non-payment in these circumstances to prevent enforcement indefinitely would leave the decree-holder without effective protection and permit the award-debtor to control when limitation and enforceability commenced.

pp. 10–11

Requiring tenants to deposit rents was therefore an equitable arrangement pending the petitioners’ pursuit of their statutory remedy.

pp. 11–12

The Court also noted that, if a Section 34 court later required a deposit, the petitioners could seek adjustment of the sums already deposited before the Execution Court.

p. 12

05Holding

The Court declined to interfere with the orders rejecting the applications and directing the tenants to deposit rents, finding no error or infirmity warranting writ intervention.

pp. 12–13

It disposed of the writ petition and clarified that the petitioners may seek adjustment of the amounts deposited before the Execution Court against any deposit condition imposed in Section 34 proceedings; that request is for the jurisdictional court to decide in accordance with law.

p. 12
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

MRS. DEEPA. BvsABHISHEK PACHASIA

Karnataka High Court · November 03, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment