01Facts
The respondent-plaintiff, D. Jaishankar, filed O.S. No. 1520 of 2016 (originally before the 12th Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai) seeking mandatory and permanent injunctions.
He alleged that the sole defendant had put up an unauthorised first-floor construction over a passage (ABCE & E) on Schedule A items 1 and 2 and Schedule C.
The plaint was later amended to claim that the construction covered Schedule A items 1 and 2 and Schedule C, obstructing the passage to the sky.
¶ 6The plaintiff traced his right through a registered sale deed dated 19.7.2006, and the defendant relied on a rectification deed dated 20.11.2006.
¶ 7, 9The plaintiff alleged that obstruction began in 2015, and the suit was filed in 2016.
¶ 12The defendant filed I.A. No. 1 of 2020 under Order VII Rule 11 CPC to reject the plaint.
The defendant contended that (a) no declaration of right was sought, (b) the suit was barred by limitation because it was filed roughly nine years and three months after the 2006 sale deed, and (c) no cause of action existed.
¶ 7, 9, 10The trial court dismissed the application by order dated 31.3.2023, holding that these issues required appreciation of evidence and could be decided only at trial.
¶ 8The defendant separately filed O.S. No. 88 of 2019 for injunctions over the same property.
By order dated 05.4.2019 in Transfer O.P. No. 23 of 2019, the suits were transferred and tried together.
¶ 11, 15PW-1 had been examined in chief and was under cross-examination.
¶ 11, 15The petition was filed under Article 227 but was converted into a revision under Section 115 CPC.
¶ 2The defendant died during the pendency, and his legal heirs were brought on record.
¶ 302Issues
i.1. Whether the plaint in O.S. No. 1520 of 2016 is liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 CPC because the plaintiff did not seek a declaration of his title/right.
¶ 7, 9, 13ii.2. Whether the suit is barred by limitation, such that the plaint should be rejected at the threshold.
¶ 7, 10, 17iii.3. Whether the trial court's refusal to reject the plaint discloses any jurisdictional error or perversity warranting revisional interference.
¶ 8, 1703Law Applied
Order VII Rule 11 CPC permits rejection of a plaint only on the grounds specified in it, and a plaint cannot be rejected merely because a particular relief, such as declaration, was not claimed.
¶ 13Questions of limitation and the need for a declaration are treated as mixed questions of fact and law requiring framing of issues and recording of evidence.
¶ 13, 17The construction of documents and the scope of a permanent injunction require independent consideration at trial.
¶ 14Revisional jurisdiction under Section 115 CPC is confined to jurisdictional error, illegality, or material irregularity, and does not extend to reappraisal of findings.
¶ 2, 17No useful purpose is served by rejecting one of two plaints when both suits concern the same property and parties and are tried together.
¶ 16The judgment cites no specific precedents.
Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 115
04Reasoning
The Court found that the plaint sought mandatory and permanent injunctions, and that the omission of a declaration was not a ground for rejection under Order VII Rule 11.
¶ 12–13It held that whether such a relief is sustainable without a declaration must be decided after framing an issue and recording evidence.
¶ 13The permanent injunction claim also turned on the interpretation of the sale deed and rectification deed, which required trial.
¶ 14The limitation plea was similarly held to depend on facts, including the date on which the cause of action arose, and the plaintiff's averment that obstruction began in 2015 was a factual matter.
¶ 12, 17The defendant's own suit (O.S. No. 88 of 2019) concerned the same property, and both suits were being tried together with PW-1 under cross-examination.
¶ 15–16Rejecting one plaint in these circumstances would serve no useful purpose.
¶ 16Finding no perversity in the trial court's reasoning, the Court declined to interfere under Section 115 CPC and preserved the defendant's right to raise limitation and the declaration defect as independent issues at trial.
¶ 1705Holding
Non-claiming of a declaration is not a ground for rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11.
¶ 13The limitation plea requires evidence and cannot be decided at the threshold.
¶ 16–17The trial court's order dated 31.3.2023 in I.A. No. 1 of 2020 is not perverse and does not warrant revisional interference.
¶ 13, 16–17The revision is dismissed and the order is sustained; the trial court is directed to dispose of O.S. No. 1520 of 2016 and O.S. No. 88 of 2019 within four months from receipt of the order, no costs are awarded, and the connected CMP is dismissed.
¶ 18Original Court PDF
N. DHEVARAJANvsD. JAISHANKAR
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
