01Facts
The petitioner sought a writ directing CBSE to change his date of birth in his Class X certificate (Roll No. 4126628, issued 14.08.2002) from 02.06.1984 to 02.06.1987, and to quash the Regional Officer's order dated 30.08.2023 refusing the change.
¶ 1He relied on a birth certificate issued by the Registrar of Births and Deaths, Firozabad, a Maharashtra Government Gazette publication, and his Aadhaar and PAN records.
¶ 2He first applied to CBSE on 29.01.2021. After rejection, he filed W.P. No. 27802 of 2022. On 01.02.2023 the Court directed CBSE to reconsider under Jigya Yadav, placing the burden on the petitioner to establish the claimed date. CBSE rejected the request again on 30.08.2023.
¶ 3CBSE contended that the request came about nineteen years after the examination and that the certificate matched school records. The Kendriya Vidyalaya, Panvel, reported that the petitioner was admitted to Class V on 15.10.1993 on transfer, and that the previous school records and scholar register showed 02.06.1984.
¶ 4The Firozabad birth certificate recorded 05.01.2021 as both the registration and issue date, over thirty-three years after the asserted birth.
¶ 6The Gazette entry was published on the petitioner's request, and the Aadhaar and PAN entries were derived from the birth certificate.
¶ 7For the first time in the writ petition, the petitioner produced a Hindi Gram Sabha certificate (No. 2574, dated July 1987) with translation, recording 02.06.1987, which was not before CBSE.
¶ 902Issues
i.1. Whether the CBSE's refusal to substitute the date of birth in the Class X certificate warrants interference under Article 226.
¶ 5ii.2. Whether the Firozabad birth certificate and the Gazette, Aadhaar and PAN entries are sufficient to establish the claimed date of birth so as to require correction.
¶ 6–8iii.3. Whether the Gram Sabha certificate, produced for the first time before the writ court, can be considered in deciding the disputed date of birth.
¶ 903Law Applied
The Court framed the claim as a request for correction based on public documents within the framework of para. 171(a) of Jigya Yadav v. CBSE, (2021) 7 SCC 535.
¶ 5The Court treated the Firozabad birth certificate as admissible evidence of a registered entry under Section 17(2) of the Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969.
¶ 6A later-generated document is not independent corroboration where it derives from the same declaration, so Gazette, Aadhaar and PAN entries add nothing where they rest on the birth certificate.
¶ 7The authority must consider documentary conflict and give reasons, and speculative motives (such as an age-related benefit) cannot be relied upon.
¶ 8A writ court will not determine a disputed fact of date of birth on unverified material not placed before the authority.
¶ 9The 01.02.2023 order's allocation of the burden of proof on the petitioner was a precondition for the claim.
¶ 3Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969 Section 17
04Reasoning
The Firozabad certificate, registered in 2021 for a 1984 or 1987 birth, carried limited probative weight, and the school records, admission in 1993, and the petitioner's age of about six years and four months at Class V supported CBSE's view. The Gazette, Aadhaar and PAN entries were disregarded as derivative.
¶ 6, 7, 8The Court excluded CBSE's suggestion of an age-related motive as speculative. It found that CBSE had weighed the public documents and given reasons for preferring the school entries, and that the documentary conflict remained unresolved. This did not justify interference with the refusal.
¶ 8The Hindi Gram Sabha certificate was not produced before CBSE, even on the court-directed reconsideration. CBSE therefore had no opportunity to verify it, and the writ court would not decide the disputed date on that unverified material. The certificate and translation were excluded, and their genuineness and evidentiary value were left open.
¶ 905Holding
CBSE's refusal does not warrant interference, and the documentary material before CBSE supplies no basis to direct substitution of the date of birth.
¶ 8The writ petition is dismissed without costs. The petitioner may seek a declaration of his correct date of birth and consequential relief before the competent civil court, subject to limitation and other requirements of maintainability. The actual date of birth, and the genuineness and evidentiary value of the Gram Sabha certificate, are left open for adjudication in those proceedings.
¶ 9–10Original Court PDF
GAURAV KUMAR ANANDvsTHE CHAIRMAN,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
