01Facts
The Additional District and Sessions Court, Kancheepuram (Chengalpattu), convicted the petitioner's son, Seenu @ Srinivasan, under Section 302 IPC on 30.08.2019 in S.C. No. 148 of 2012 and imposed life imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 5,000.
p. 2This Court dismissed his appeal in Crl.A. No. 613 of 2019 on 28.04.2025.
p. 2He has been confined in Central Prison-1, Puzhal, for about nine years.
pp. 2–3The petitioner, his 65-year-old mother, has health issues requiring treatment. She applied on 12.08.2026 to the 1st and 2nd respondents for 28 days' ordinary leave without police escort, enclosing medical reports.
p. 3The 1st respondent rejected the request by order dated 28.09.2026 on the ground that the Chengalpattu Probation Officer had found the stated reason untrue.
p. 3In an earlier writ (W.P.Crl. No. 24 of 2025, order dated 04.07.2025), this Court had granted the son 28 days' leave, and he returned to prison on time.
p. 4The Inspector of Police, E3 Satras Police Station, by communication dated 12.11.2026, reported that the medical reports were genuine and the petitioner was ill.
pp. 4–5The son's conduct in prison is good.
p. 5The Additional Public Prosecutor stated that the Poondhandalam Police Station had been bifurcated and the petitioner's residence fell within Thirukalukundram Police Station limits.
p. 502Issues
i.1. Whether the 1st respondent's refusal of 28 days' ordinary leave, based on the Probation Officer's finding that the stated reason was untrue, was sustainable in law.
p. 3, 5 (paras 2, 6)ii.2. Whether a life convict who has served about nine years with good prison conduct, and whose mother has a documented medical need, is entitled to 28 days' ordinary leave without escort.
p. 5 (para 6)03Law Applied
The Court's order rests on its writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, invoked to quash an administrative order and issue mandamus.
p. 2 (prayer) · p. 6 (para 7)The grant of leave is governed by the Prison Manual, which the Court made applicable to the leave conditions; the Court did not identify the specific Manual provision.
p. 6 (para 7(i))The Court treated the length of incarceration, good conduct, and the surrounding circumstances as the relevant considerations for leave.
p. 5 (para 6)The Court relied on its earlier order in W.P.Crl. No. 24 of 2025 as a precedent for similar leave, but did not state any independent legal principle from it.
p. 4 (para 3.1)No statutory provision or binding precedent is expressly cited for the rule on ordinary leave.
Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302
04Reasoning
The Court held the impugned order unsustainable by weighing the convict's nine years of imprisonment and good conduct against the petitioner's documented health needs.
p. 5 (para 6)It gave weight to the Inspector of Police's report, which confirmed the medical reports were genuine, and this report undermined the basis of the 1st respondent's rejection that the reason was untrue.
pp. 4–5 (para 3.2)The earlier grant of leave and the son's timely return showed no risk of non-return.
p. 4 (para 3.1)The Court then set aside the order and directed grant of leave, subject to conditions that mitigate risk: daily reporting at Thirukalukundram Police Station at 6.30 p.m., use of leave only for its stated purpose, and surrender on expiry.
p. 6 (para 7)The order does not explain how the Probation Officer's adverse finding was displaced beyond relying on the Inspector's contrary report.
pp. 4–5 (para 3.2)05Holding
The Court answered both issues in favour of the petitioner. The refusal dated 28.09.2026 was set aside as unsustainable, given the medical evidence, the convict's nine years' custody, and his good conduct.
pp. 5–6 (paras 6–7)The 1st respondent was directed to grant 28 days' ordinary leave without escort within one week of receipt of the order, subject to: (i) daily reporting before the Inspector of Police, Thirukalukundram Police Station, at 6.30 p.m.; (ii) use of leave solely for the stated purpose; and (iii) surrender to prison authorities on expiry.
p. 6 (para 7)The writ petition was disposed of without costs, and the connected miscellaneous petition was closed.
p. 6 (para 8)Original Court PDF
LakshmivsThe Deputy Inspector General of Prisons,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
