01Facts
The appellant (wife) was accused of murdering her husband, Kannan, by cutting him with a knife/billhook on the night of 11.06.2014 at their house in Sitharevu
¶ 2 · p. 2The prosecution case was that Kannan was a chronic drunkard who tortured the appellant, which motivated the killing
¶ 2 · p. 2 · ¶ 21 · p. 13The mother of the deceased (PW1) allegedly lodged a complaint (Ex.P1) at about 02:00 hrs on 12.06.2014
¶ 2 · p. 3 · ¶ 24 · p. 18The appellant allegedly surrendered before the VAO (PW15), who recorded a confession and sent her to the police. The investigating officer (PW21) then arrested her, recorded a second confession, and recovered a billhook (MO1) and blood-stained clothing
¶ 2 · p. 3 · ¶ 25 · pp. 19–21The prosecution examined 21 witnesses, of whom PW12, PW13 and PW14 turned hostile, and PW9–PW11 were hearsay witnesses
¶ 22(1) · pp. 14–15The defence led no evidence
¶ 10 · p. 9The trial court convicted the appellant under s.302 IPC and sentenced her to life imprisonment and a fine of Rs.10,000/-
¶ 11 · p. 9During trial, the prosecution's eyewitness case was recast as one based on circumstantial evidence
¶ 19 · pp. 12–1302Issues
i.1. Whether the prosecution established motive for the murder, namely the deceased's alcoholism and cruelty towards the appellant.
¶ 21 · pp. 13–14ii.2. Whether the prosecution proved that the appellant was seen standing with a billhook at the house of occurrence immediately after the incident.
¶ 22 · pp. 14–16iii.3. Whether the prosecution proved that the appellant was seen running with a billhook through the street immediately after the incident.
¶ 23 · pp. 16–17iv.4. Whether the complaint (Ex.P1) was genuine and reliable, given the surrounding inconsistencies and suppression of a complaint from the accused.
¶ 24 · pp. 17–19v.5. Whether the arrest and the two confessions of the appellant were reliable.
¶ 25 · pp. 19–21vi.6. Whether the recovery of the billhook pursuant to the confession was reliable.
¶ 26 · pp. 21–22vii.7. Whether the appellant could be called upon to explain under s.106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, and whether the prosecution proved the "last seen together" circumstance.
¶ 27 · pp. 22–25viii.8. Whether the prosecution proved guilt beyond reasonable doubt, so that the trial court's conviction under s.302 IPC is sustainable.
¶ 16 · p. 11 · ¶ 30–31 · p. 2603Law Applied
The court applied s.302 IPC, the offence of murder under challenge.
¶ 1 · p. 2As an appellate court, it was bound to re-appraise the evidence independently and assess the credibility of witnesses, as stated in Iqbal Abdul Samiya Malek v. State of Gujarat (2012) 11 SCC 312 and Jogi v. State of M.P. (2021 LiveLaw SC 639).
¶ 17 · p. 12 · ¶ 18 · p. 12For circumstantial evidence, it applied the five golden principles in Abdul Nassar v. State of Kerala (2025 INSC 35): each circumstance must be fully established, the facts must be consistent only with guilt, and the chain must exclude every reasonable hypothesis of innocence.
¶ 29 · pp. 25–26Under s.106 of the Evidence Act, the court relied on State of M.P. v. Balveer Singh (2025 INSC 261), holding that the section cannot relieve the prosecution of proving a prima facie case and cannot be used to fill gaps in its evidence.
¶ 27(6) · pp. 23–24It also relied on Anand Jakkappa Pujari @ Gaddadar v. State of Karnataka (2026 INSC 417), holding that "last seen together" does not by itself establish guilt and requires corroboration.
¶ 27(6) · p. 24The court reiterated the principle that the prosecution must prove guilt beyond all reasonable doubt and that the accused is entitled to the benefit of every reasonable doubt.
¶ 30 · p. 26Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 374
04Reasoning
The court tested each of the seven circumstances pleaded by the prosecution and found that most failed.
¶ 20 · p. 13On motive, no witness stated that the deceased was a chronic drunkard or that he harassed the appellant, so the motive was unproved.
¶ 21 · p. 14On the standing and running circumstances, the court discounted PW4–PW7 and PW11 as either hearsay or unable to speak to the relevant moment. PW8's cross-examination showed that PW1–PW3 and PW6 reached the house only after the incident, so their accounts could not be relied on.
¶ 22(5)–(6) · pp. 15–16 · ¶ 23(4)–(6) · pp. 16–17The complaint Ex.P1 was held "shrouded in mystery." It was inconsistent in timing (02:00 hrs against 06:00 hrs in cross-examination), its drafting was attributed to the police, and a prior complaint from the appellant was suppressed.
¶ 24(1)–(7) · pp. 17–19The arrest and confession were also doubtful, because the second confession was filed but the VAO's confession was not, and the appellant was allegedly held at the police station overnight.
¶ 25(1)–(6) · pp. 19–21The recovery of MO1 was undermined by PW16's evidence that the fatal punctured wound could not have been caused by the billhook, and by PW2 and PW3's references to a different knife.
¶ 26(2)–(5) · pp. 21–22On s.106, the prosecution did not establish the foundational facts. No witness said the deceased was last seen with the appellant, the neighbours were not examined, and the children who were present were not produced.
¶ 27(2)–(5) · pp. 22–23The forensic evidence was inconclusive.
¶ 28 · p. 24Because the circumstances failed individually, no complete chain of guilt remained, and the case rested on suspicion, which the court held insufficient.
¶ 29–30 · pp. 25–2605Holding
The court held that the prosecution failed to prove the appellant's guilt beyond reasonable doubt, and that the trial court was not right in convicting her under s.302 IPC.
¶ 31 · p. 26The appeal is allowed. The trial court's finding and sentence in S.C. No. 10/2017 are reversed, and the appellant is acquitted of the s.302 IPC charge. She is to be set at liberty and released forthwith unless required in any other case. Any fine paid is to be refunded, and her bail bond is cancelled.
¶ 32(a)–(g) · pp. 26–27Original Court PDF
ChilambarasivsThe Inspector of Police
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
