01Facts
The appellant, Sarath Kumar, was the sole accused in S.C. No. 150 of 2018 before the Sessions Judge, Magalir Neethi Mandram (Fast Track Mahila Court), Villupuram, and was convicted under Section 302 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 5,000.
¶ 2The prosecution case is that the accused, a friend of P.W.3 Parasuraman, had been entrusted with centring materials and with collecting debts owed to Parasuraman, and that he failed to pay rent to Parasuraman's parents, the deceased Anjalai Ammal and P.W.1 Singaravelu, causing enmity.
pp. 2–3 · ¶ 3On 09.12.2017 at about 6.00 p.m., the accused took the deceased on his two-wheeler; at about 8.00 p.m., near agricultural land of one Perumal, a quarrel allegedly arose, she was pushed into a canal, and she was struck on the head and face with a rough stone.
pp. 3–4 · ¶ 3.1–3.2She was found unconscious, treated at local hospitals and at JIPMER, Puducherry, and died on 14.12.2017.
p. 4 · ¶ 3.3–3.4 · p. 6 · ¶ 3.9P.W.1's complaint was lodged on 10.12.2017 at 8.00 a.m. and registered under Section 307 IPC; the FIR was later altered to Section 302 IPC.
pp. 4–6 · ¶ 3.5, 3.9The accused was allegedly arrested on 10.12.2017 at about 1.30 p.m. and, on his disclosure, the stone (M.O.1) was recovered.
p. 6 · ¶ 3.7–3.8The defence examined D.W.1 and D.W.2, who stated the accused was taken from home by police on 10.12.2017 at about 10.00 a.m., and suggested that P.W.1 caused the assault.
p. 16 · ¶ 7The prosecution relied entirely on circumstantial evidence.
¶ 9, 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the prosecution established the alleged motive arising from the accused's failure to pay rent and collect debts.
¶ 9, 12–15ii.2. Whether the last-seen theory, that the deceased was last seen in the accused's company on 09.12.2017, was established, given the contradictions in the evidence and the delay in lodging the FIR.
¶ 11(ii), 16–24iii.3. Whether the arrest of the accused, his disclosure statement, and the recovery of M.O.1 at his instance were proved, so as to attract Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
¶ 11(iii), 25–29iv.4. Whether the Trial Court was justified in drawing an adverse inference against the accused under Section 106 of the Evidence Act.
¶ 9.1, 34v.5. Whether the prosecution proved the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt.
¶ 32, 3503Law Applied
The court considered Section 302 IPC, under which the accused was convicted.
¶ 2The principles governing circumstantial evidence: the circumstances from which guilt is inferred must first be fully established, must be conclusive in nature and tendency, must be consistent only with the hypothesis of guilt, and must exclude every other hypothesis.
¶ 33Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, which the Trial Court invoked for an adverse inference, cannot be applied to draw an adverse inference until the prosecution first establishes foundational circumstances pointing to guilt.
¶ 9.1, 34Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act on discovery of facts pursuant to a disclosure statement: recovery contradicted by other evidence cannot be treated as a discovery of fact under that provision.
¶ 26Counsel for the appellant relied on Laxman Prasad alias Laxman v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (2023) 6 SCC 399, and Kanhaiya Lal v. State of Rajasthan, (2014) 4 SCC 715, on the Section 106 point; the judgment does not expressly discuss these authorities in its reasoning.
¶ 9.1Section 437-A Cr.P.C. was invoked for bail bond cancellation.
¶ 36(ii)Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 374Section 313Section 437
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302Section 307
04Reasoning
The court first examined motive and found it unproven. P.W.1 did not speak of any earlier dispute about rent or debts. P.W.2 and P.W.7 were hearsay witnesses, and P.W.4 and P.W.5 spoke only from what they heard.
¶ 12P.W.3, who lived in Chennai, could have known of the quarrels only through his parents, and his mother is deceased while P.W.1 did not depose to any prior quarrel. The court also found implausible P.W.3's account that he entrusted Rs. 50,000 to the accused and then continued to give him collection instructions.
¶ 13–14Because the Trial Court did not identify the evidence on which motive was accepted, its finding was held unsustainable.
¶ 15On the last-seen theory, the court found material contradictions. P.W.1 said Murugadas returned and took him to the scene, whereas P.W.6 said he was informed by Mani after midnight and went alone, and P.W.4, P.W.5 and P.W.7 showed similar discrepancies.
¶ 16–18The FIR was lodged more than eight hours after the deceased reached hospital, and forwarded to the Magistrate about 28 hours later, with no explanation for either delay. The court also noted that no hospital information was recorded to the police before the complaint.
¶ 19–20The Investigating Officer began investigation on 10.12.2017 but examined P.W.5 only on 28.12.2017. No material explained how the Bajaj Platina bearing TN 32 AC 4358 was identified as the vehicle used by the accused, and P.W.14's evidence on ownership and return of the vehicle was vague and not linked to the accused.
¶ 22–24On recovery, the court held that P.W.1, P.W.5, P.W.6 and P.W.12 each spoke of a stone lying near the deceased at the scene, contradicting the claim that M.O.1 was concealed and recovered at the accused's instance. P.W.8 was also inconsistent on whether the accused was already at the police station on 09.12.2017.
¶ 26–27Even if recovery were accepted, no forensic evidence linked blood on M.O.1 to the deceased's blood group. The court also found no clarity on who first found the deceased and who took her to hospital.
¶ 28, 30Since none of the foundational circumstances was established, the court held that the Trial Court erred in invoking Section 106 of the Evidence Act to draw an adverse inference. The chain of circumstances was therefore incomplete, and the prosecution failed to exclude other hypotheses.
¶ 32–34The appellant's contention that the deceased was assaulted by P.W.1 was noted but not separately adjudicated; the court's reasoning rests on failure of prosecution proof.
¶ 7, 10.105Holding
The prosecution failed to establish motive, the last-seen circumstance, and the arrest, disclosure and recovery of M.O.1.
¶ 32The adverse inference under Section 106 could not be drawn.
¶ 34Guilt was not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
¶ 35The Criminal Appeal was allowed, the judgment of conviction and sentence dated 02.09.2023 in S.C. No. 150 of 2018 was set aside, and the appellant was acquitted of the charge under Section 302 IPC. Any bail bond stands cancelled subject to Section 437-A Cr.P.C., any fine paid is to be refunded, and the appellant is to be released forthwith unless required in any other case.
¶ 36(i)–(iii)Original Court PDF
SARATH KUMARvsSTATE REP BY
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
