Madras High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Madras HC Acquits Man Of Rape And SC/ST Act Charges In Case Of Disabled Dalit Woman, Upholds Kidnapping Conviction

Muthurajv.The State of Tamilnadu

Madras HC Acquits Man Of Rape And SC/ST Act Charges In Case Of Disabled Dalit Woman, Upholds Kidnapping Conviction. Muthuraj vs The State of Tamilnadu. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the trial court correctly convicted the accused under S.3(1)(w)(i) and S.3(2)(v) of the SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989, requiring proof that the offence was committed on the sole ground that the victim is a member of a Scheduled Caste.

The court held

The Court held that the trial court was right in convicting the accused under S.450 IPC and S.366 IPC, but wrong in convicting him under S.376(2)(l) IPC r/w S.3(2)(v) and S.3(1)(w)(i) SC/ST (POA) Act.

It also directed

The appeal was partly allowed. The convictions and sentences under S.450 and S.366 IPC were maintained.

The convictions and sentences under S.376(2)(l) r/w S.3(2)(v) and S.3(1)(w)(i) SC/ST (POA) Act were reversed, and the accused was acquitted of both.

Any fine paid under the reversed counts is to be refunded, and other incidental orders of the trial court remain unaltered.

01Facts

The victim, a 28-year-old woman with spastic cerebral palsy, locomotor dysfunction, and speech and hearing disabilities, is a member of a Scheduled Caste.

p. 3 · p. 17

The accused, a non-Scheduled Caste resident of the same village, was alleged to have trespassed into the victim's house on 18.05.2018 at about 17.00 hrs while her mother was away, lifted her, carried her into thorny bushes behind the house, and raped her; he fled when witnesses raised an alarm.

p. 3

The mother lodged a complaint on 23.05.2018, and FIR Crime No. 84/2018 was registered at Krishnankovil Police Station.

p. 4

The accused was arrested on 26.05.2018.

p. 4

The final report charged offences under S.450, S.366, S.376(2)(j)(i) IPC r/w S.3(2)(va) and S.3(1)(w)(i) SC/ST (POA) Act.

p. 5

The trial court framed charges under S.450, S.366, S.376(2)(l) IPC r/w S.3(2)(v), and S.3(1)(w)(i) SC/ST (POA) Act; the accused pleaded not guilty.

pp. 6–7

The prosecution examined PW1–PW19 and marked Exs. P1–P25 and MO1–MO4.

pp. 7–9

The victim was not examined because the special interpreter (PW13) could not communicate with her.

p. 17

PW2 admitted he had not witnessed the occurrence.

p. 18

PW4–PW6 and PW10 (observation/seizure mahazar and confession witnesses) turned hostile.

pp. 7–8

The defence led no evidence.

p. 9

The trial court convicted the accused on all four counts; sentences are 5 years RI under S.450 IPC, 5 years RI under S.366 IPC, life imprisonment under S.376(2)(l) r/w S.3(2)(v), and 1 year RI under S.3(1)(w)(i), all concurrent.

p. 2

The accused appealed.

p. 2 · p. 10

02Issues

i.1. Whether the trial court correctly convicted the accused under S.3(1)(w)(i) and S.3(2)(v) of the SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989, requiring proof that the offence was committed on the sole ground that the victim is a member of a Scheduled Caste.

p. 11, para 17 · pp. 12–17, para 19

ii.2. Whether the prosecution proved the offence of rape under S.376(2)(l) IPC.

p. 11, para 17 · pp. 21–22, para 20(10)

iii.3. Whether the prosecution proved the offence of kidnapping/abduction under S.366 IPC.

p. 11, para 17 · pp. 22–23, para 20(11)

iv.4. Whether the prosecution proved house-trespass under S.450 IPC.

p. 11, para 17 · p. 24, para 20(12)

v.5. Whether the five-day delay in lodging the complaint is fatal to the prosecution.

p. 10, para 15 · p. 25, para 21

03Law Applied

The Court applied S.3(1)(w)(i) and S.3(2)(v) of the SC/ST (POA) Act, which require that the accused know the victim's caste and that the offence be committed against her because she belongs to a Scheduled Caste.

pp. 12–13, para 19(1)

The Court applied S.8(c) of the Act, under which personal knowledge of the victim or her family raises a presumption of the accused's awareness of caste, unless rebutted.

p. 14, para 19(2)

The Court relied on Hitesh Verma v. State of Uttarakhand (2020) 10 SCC 710, holding that an offence under the Act is not established merely because the victim is a Scheduled Caste member absent intent to humiliate on that account.

p. 14, para 19(3)

The Court relied on Khuman Singh v. State of M.P. (2019 SCC OnLine SC 1104), holding that the offence must be committed on the ground of the victim's caste membership.

p. 15, para 19(3)

The Court applied Balu Sudam Khalde v. State of Maharashtra (2023 SCC OnLine SC 355), holding that incriminating suggestions put by defence counsel in cross-examination bind the accused and that counsel's concessions on facts bind the client.

pp. 19–20, para 20(9)

Under S.366 IPC, kidnapping or abduction of a woman must be with intent that she be compelled to marry or be forced or seduced into illicit intercourse.

p. 22, para 20(11)(a)

Under S.450 IPC, house-trespass must be committed to facilitate an offence punishable with imprisonment for life.

p. 24, para 20(12)(a)

The Court applied the principle that a torn hymen, without supporting material linking the accused, does not establish rape.

p. 21, para 20(10)(c)

Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 425

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 450Section 366Section 376

Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 Section 3Section 8

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 228Section 428

04Reasoning

On the SC/ST (POA) Act counts, the Court accepted that the accused knew the victim's caste, as the accused did not deny it.

p. 16, para 19(5)(a)

It found, however, that PW1 did not state that the offences were committed solely because the victim was a Scheduled Caste member, despite the complaint being drafted to invoke the Act.

p. 16, para 19(5)(b)

Applying Hitesh Verma and Khuman Singh, the Court held the "sole ground" requirement unmet and the Act's charges not established.

p. 17, para 19(6)

On the rape charge, the Court discounted PW3's testimony because she did not describe any act referable to rape.

p. 21, para 20(10)(a)

Medical evidence showed no injury around the genitalia and a non-intact hymen, which the Court held insufficient without linking material.

pp. 21, para 20(10)(b)–(c)

Spermatozoa were found in vaginal smears, but the grouping test (Ex.P25) was inconclusive.

p. 21, para 20(10)(d)

The smear was taken five days after the occurrence, which the Court held significantly weakened the prosecution's case. The Court therefore found rape unproven.

p. 22, para 20(10)(e)

On the S.366 count, the Court relied on PW3's account that she saw the accused lifting and carrying the victim into thorny bushes at about 20.00–20.30 hrs and that he dropped her and fled when shouted at.

p. 19, para 20(7)

It treated the defence suggestion to PW1 (that the accused carried the victim to relieve herself) as an admission of the accused's presence and lifting of the victim.

p. 20, para 20(9)

Given the victim's disabilities, the time, and the act of carrying her into bushes, the Court inferred intent for illicit intercourse.

p. 23, para 20(11)(c)

PW1's evidence of bleeding injuries was discarded because it conflicted with PW3's timeline, and the seized clothing bore no blood stains.

p. 18, para 20(6)

On the S.450 count, the Court held that the intended offence was rape, punishable with life imprisonment, and that the accused committed house-trespass when the mother left the disabled victim alone at home.

pp. 24, para 20(12)(b)–(c)

On delay, the Court noted that no witness was cross-examined on the five-day delay, and no evidence showed it was fatal to the prosecution.

p. 25, para 21

05Holding

The Court held that the trial court was right in convicting the accused under S.450 IPC and S.366 IPC, but wrong in convicting him under S.376(2)(l) IPC r/w S.3(2)(v) and S.3(1)(w)(i) SC/ST (POA) Act.

pp. 25–26, para 22

The appeal was partly allowed. The convictions and sentences under S.450 and S.366 IPC were maintained.

pp. 26, paras 23(a)–(b)

The convictions and sentences under S.376(2)(l) r/w S.3(2)(v) and S.3(1)(w)(i) SC/ST (POA) Act were reversed, and the accused was acquitted of both.

pp. 26–27, paras 23(c)–(f)

Any fine paid under the reversed counts is to be refunded, and other incidental orders of the trial court remain unaltered.

pp. 27, paras 23(g)–(h)
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

MuthurajvsThe State of Tamilnadu

Madras High Court · November 13, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment