Madras High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Madras HC Upholds Murder Conviction Of Landlord Who Hit Former Tenant With Hammer, Despite Doubts Over Weapon Recovery

G.MOSES SHARAKv.STATE REP.BY

Madras HC Upholds Murder Conviction Of Landlord Who Hit Former Tenant With Hammer, Despite Doubts Over Weapon Recovery. G.MOSES SHARAK vs STATE REP.BY. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the prosecution established the cause of death as a result of injuries inflicted by the appellant, given the non-examination of treating doctors and the absence of the viscera report, when these points were not raised at trial.

The court held

The ocular evidence of PW1, PW2, PW3, PW5 and PW6 is trustworthy and corroborated by medical evidence, and the hammer-recovery discrepancy does not vitiate the case.

It also directed

The conviction and sentence under Section 302 IPC (life imprisonment and ₹10,000 fine) are confirmed.

The evidence did not establish the essential ingredients of the offence under Section 294(b) IPC or Section 506(ii) IPC.

The appeal is partly allowed. The conviction and sentence under Section 294(b) IPC and Section 506(ii) IPC are set aside.

01Facts

The appellant was the sole accused in S.C. No. 179 of 2019 before the Sessions Judge, Mahalir Neethimandram, Chennai, and was convicted under Sections 294(b), 302 and 506(ii) IPC on 24.02.2023.

¶ 2

The appellant received life imprisonment under Section 302, with concurrent terms for the other offences.

¶ 2

The appellant had been the landlord of PW1 Kaliyaperumal and his family, who were tenants at Rex Street, Chintadripet. After the appellant's wife left him, he blamed the deceased, Karpagam, and the family vacated the premises but continued to visit the neighbourhood on Sundays.

¶ 4

On 09.09.2018, around 7–8 p.m., while the deceased was talking with PW5 and PW6, the appellant allegedly emerged from his house with a hammer and struck her on the head, and abused her in filthy language.

¶ 5–6

PW1–PW3 allegedly rushed forward but were threatened.

¶ 6

The deceased was admitted to hospital, where no external injuries were noted. She died on 10.09.2018.

¶ 7

The post-mortem revealed multiple head injuries, including fractures, and PW9 opined that death was due to head injuries.

¶ 12, 29–30

The appellant was arrested on 10.09.2018, allegedly gave a disclosure statement, and produced a hammer (MO1).

¶ 9–10

PW4 turned hostile. PW1, PW2, PW3 and PW6 said the blow fell on the back of the head, while PW5 said the right side.

¶ 14

PW5 and PW6 stated in cross-examination that PW1–PW3 were absent, and PW5 and PW6 said the hammer was recovered the day after the occurrence.

¶ 22, 24

The appellant's Section 313 statement denied the charges and alleged a property dispute; he examined himself as DW1.

¶ 18

02Issues

i.1. Whether the prosecution established the cause of death as a result of injuries inflicted by the appellant, given the non-examination of treating doctors and the absence of the viscera report, when these points were not raised at trial.

¶ 25, 29, 32

ii.2. Whether the eyewitness testimony of PW1, PW2, PW3, PW5 and PW6 is reliable despite discrepancies regarding the side of the head struck and the presence of PW1–PW3 at the scene.

¶ 21–23, 33–36

iii.3. Whether the discrepancy regarding the time and manner of recovery of the hammer (MO1) vitiates the prosecution case.

¶ 24, 38–40

iv.4. Whether the appellant's conviction under Section 302 IPC can be sustained, including whether any exception under Section 300 applies.

¶ 41

v.5. Whether the offence under Section 294(b) IPC is made out on the evidence of obscene or abusive words.

¶ 42–44

vi.6. Whether the offence under Section 506(ii) IPC (criminal intimidation) is made out.

¶ 45–46

03Law Applied

The court applied Section 302 IPC for murder and Section 300 IPC, including its exceptions, which were not invoked on these facts.

¶ 29, 41

The court relied on the principle that the accused's culpable homicide must be established before culpability is assessed.

¶ 29

The court applied the rule that defence objections not raised at trial, especially in cross-examination, cannot be raised for the first time on appeal.

¶ 32

The court followed T.G. Krishnamurthy v. State of Karnataka (2023 LiveLaw (SC) 671) and Mahendran v. State of Tamil Nadu (AIR 2019 SC 1719) for the rule that falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus has no application in India, so the court must separate the chaff from the grain.

¶ 35

The court relied on Madan v. State of U.P. (2023 SCC OnLine SC 1473) and Darbara Singh v. State of Punjab (AIR 2013 SC 840) for the rule that where eyewitness testimony is trustworthy, motive loses significance.

¶ 37

The court relied on Om Pal v. State of U.P. (2025 INSC 1262) and Nankaunoo v. State of U.P. (2016 (3) SCC 317) for the rule that non-recovery or doubtful recovery of the weapon does not, by itself, vitiate a prosecution case supported by ocular and medical evidence.

¶ 39

The court applied Mani @ Subramaniyan v. State of Tamil Nadu (2025 INSC 719) for the proposition that mere utterance of swear words does not constitute Section 294(b) unless the words are lascivious, appeal to prurient interest, or cause annoyance in a public place.

¶ 42

The court applied Mani @ Subramaniyan v. State of Tamil Nadu (2025 INSC 719) for the proposition that Section 506(ii) requires proof of a threat intended to cause alarm.

¶ 45

Provisions in the judgment · 11 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 374Section 313

Indian Penal Code, 1860 9 provisionsSection 294Section 302Section 506Section 341Section 324Section 307Section 509Section 301Section 300

04Reasoning

On the cause of death, the court held that the post-mortem certificate (Ex. P5) and PW9's testimony showed fractures and other head injuries consistent with a hammer assault.

¶ 29–31

The defence had not challenged the doctor's opinion at trial, and the absence of the treating doctors and viscera report was raised too late.

¶ 32

On the eyewitnesses, the court held that the discrepancy about the side of the head was explained by the panic that a sudden attack causes, and the core account of a hammer blow to the head matched the medical evidence.

¶ 33–34

On the presence of PW1–PW3, the court held that PW5 and PW6 had first affirmed their presence in examination-in-chief and admitted their absence only under suggestion in cross-examination. This created an inconsistency that required caution, but did not require rejecting the testimony wholesale.

¶ 35

PW5 and PW6 were found to be neighbours acquainted with the parties, with no suggested motive to falsely implicate the appellant, and their account was held believable.

¶ 36

On motive, the court held that the weak motive pleaded was immaterial given reliable eyewitness testimony.

¶ 37

On the hammer recovery, the court treated the discrepancy (the police apparently recovered it on 09.09 or 10.09 at the scene, per PW5 and PW6) as an investigative lapse that could not defeat the case.

¶ 38–40

On Section 302, the court found no basis to apply any Section 300 exception.

¶ 41

On Section 294(b), the court found that PW1 alleged specific words, PW2 alleged different words, and PW3, PW5 and PW6 said nothing about the words used. Neither the words nor their obscene character were established.

¶ 42–44

On Section 506(ii), PW1 was silent about any threat, and PW2's account did not show an intent to cause alarm.

¶ 45

05Holding

The ocular evidence of PW1, PW2, PW3, PW5 and PW6 is trustworthy and corroborated by medical evidence, and the hammer-recovery discrepancy does not vitiate the case.

¶ 40–41, 47

The conviction and sentence under Section 302 IPC (life imprisonment and ₹10,000 fine) are confirmed.

¶ 40–41, 47

The evidence did not establish the essential ingredients of the offence under Section 294(b) IPC or Section 506(ii) IPC.

¶ 44, 46–47

The appeal is partly allowed. The conviction and sentence under Section 294(b) IPC and Section 506(ii) IPC are set aside.

¶ 44, 46–47
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

G.MOSES SHARAKvsSTATE REP.BY

Madras High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment