01Facts
The petitioner sought to hold the annual festival at the Sri Sappanikaruppu and Kottai Karuppu temple. Following objections by private respondents, the Revenue Divisional Officer conducted a peace committee meeting and issued proceedings dated 10 August 2026 prohibiting the festival and related poojas, with directions to the police to prevent them.
p. 3The petitioner challenged those proceedings under Article 226, contending that apprehended law-and-order problems did not justify a blanket ban.
pp. 2–4The State submitted that the proposed festival date had passed.
p. 402Issues
i.1. Whether a mere apprehension of a law-and-order problem justifies a blanket prohibition on conducting the temple festival.
pp. 3–5ii.2. Whether the impugned prohibition should be set aside and the festival request reconsidered through a fresh representation, notwithstanding that the proposed date had elapsed.
pp. 4–503Law Applied
The Court applied the principle that a mere apprehension of a law-and-order problem cannot, by itself, justify a blanket prohibition on a temple festival.
p. 5Where concerns exist, the authority should consider whether the event can instead be regulated by imposing appropriate conditions and providing necessary police protection.
p. 5No statute or precedent was cited in the order as the basis for this principle.
pp. 2–504Reasoning
The Court accepted that the impugned proceedings imposed an outright ban, while the stated concern was the possibility of a law-and-order problem.
pp. 3–5It held that apprehension alone was insufficient to sustain such a prohibition and required the police authority, on a fresh representation, to assess the matter on its merits, hear both parties, and issue a reasoned order. Any identified risk was to be addressed by considering conditions and police protection rather than automatically prohibiting the festival.
p. 5Although the proposed date had elapsed, the Court directed a fresh process rather than granting permission for the festival on that date.
pp. 4–505Holding
The Court set aside the Revenue Divisional Officer’s proceedings dated 10 August 2026 and allowed the writ petition.
p. 5It directed the petitioner to submit a fresh representation to the fourth respondent, the Inspector of Police, who must give notice to both parties and pass a reasoned order within two weeks of receiving the order, bearing in mind that mere apprehension is not a ground for a blanket ban and considering regulation and police protection where appropriate.
p. 5The connected miscellaneous petitions were closed.
p. 5Original Court PDF
SubramanivsThe District Collector
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
