01Facts
The petitioner sought a writ under Article 226 directing the State and the bank (HDFC Bank, Munshipulia Branch, Lucknow) to remove a debit freeze on her current account and to restore its operation.
¶ 1Her counsel contended that the case was squarely covered by Malcolm Murayis and Ors. v. State Bank of India (W.P. No. 1100/2024, decided 26.04.2024).
¶ 2In Malcolm Murayis, the court had disposed of petitions against account freezes ordered on cyber-cell requests by directing the disputed amount to be kept in fixed deposits, liquidable only after a Magistrate's order within three months.
¶ 3A subsequent Standard Operating Procedure dated 10.04.2026 (MHA) governing grievance redressal for holds placed through NCRP-CFCFRMS had been framed, and the Principal Seat at Jabalpur had addressed it in Archana v. State of Madhya Pradesh (order dated 27.07.2026), whose paras 11–18 were reproduced.
¶ 4The order does not record the disputed amount in the present case, the account balance, or the status of any grievance filed under the SOP.
02Issues
i.1. Whether the freezing of the petitioner's entire bank account, in respect of a disputed amount forming part of it, can be sustained, or whether the freeze must be confined to the disputed amount under the principles of reasonableness and proportionality.
¶ 4–5 · Archana paras 12–13, 15(I)ii.2. Whether the disputed amount should be secured in fixed deposits, with the account restored to the petitioner, pending the investigating agency's action under the BNSS.
¶ 5–603Law Applied
The Court relied on Article 226 of the Constitution as the basis for writ jurisdiction.
¶ 1The principles in Malcolm Murayis (paras 8–9) apply: the disputed amount is to be kept in fixed deposits, liquidable only after a competent Judicial Magistrate's order within three months, failing which the petitioner may withdraw it on intimation to the police.
¶ 3Archana (paras 12–18) holds that police power to freeze bank accounts must be exercised reasonably and proportionately, that a lien or debit freeze limited to the suspected amount is ordinarily preferred over freezing the whole account, and that the investigating officer must inform the Magistrate of any freeze "forthwith".
¶ 4, citing Archana paras 13, 15(I)–(II)Under the SOP dated 10.04.2026, as summarised in Archana, the bank is the first point of contact for grievances, the investigating officer must decide within fifteen days, the District Grievance Redressal Officer handles review, and a writ petition ordinarily lies only after 90 days, subject to exceptional circumstances.
¶ 4, citing Archana paras 14, 15(XV)–(XVIII), 17–18Articles 19(1)(g) and 300-A of the Constitution require a balance between the right to carry on business and the right to property, and the statutory power of investigation.
¶ 4, citing Archana para. 12Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 102
04Reasoning
The orders in Malcolm Murayis and Archana apply mutatis mutandis to the present case.
¶ 5The Court did not undertake fresh fact-finding and accepted that the freeze was on a disputed amount and that the account remained operative for legitimate business.
¶ 5The Court followed the earlier twin approach: the disputed amount is protected through a fixed deposit, which preserves the investigating agency's ability to secure proceeds of crime, while the remaining balance is released to avoid disproportionate prejudice to lawful business.
¶ 6, read with Archana paras 12–13, 16The three-month outer limit for Magistrate action ensures that the freeze does not continue indefinitely without judicial oversight.
¶ 6, citing Malcolm Murayis para. 9The Court left open that the bank may act on any other complaint about separate entries, in accordance with law and the SOP.
¶ 6, citing Archana para. 15The order does not discuss whether the petitioner exhausted the SOP grievance route, and it does not address the 90-day threshold for writ relief in this case.
05Holding
The disputed amount is to be kept in fixed deposit and may be liquidated only after a competent Judicial Magistrate passes orders within three months. If the police do not act within that period, the petitioner may withdraw the amount on intimation to the police.
¶ 6The petitioner's bank account is to be unfrozen and she is permitted to operate it.
¶ 6The writ petition is disposed of.
¶ 7The holding confines the freeze to the disputed amount and makes it subject to judicial oversight, applying Malcolm Murayis and Archana as binding guidance for similar cases.
¶ 5–6Original Court PDF
Jagritee SinghvsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
