Madhya Pradesh High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceInsurance Law

MP HC Sets Aside Three Motor Accident Death Awards, Finding FIR Witness a 'Planted' Eyewitness

Magma Hdi General Insurance Co. Ltdv.Chhuttan Ahirwar

MP HC Sets Aside Three Motor Accident Death Awards, Finding FIR Witness a 'Planted' Eyewitness. Magma Hdi General Insurance Co. Ltd vs Chhuttan Ahirwar. Madhya Pradesh High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the claimants proved the factum of the accident and the identity of the offending vehicle.

The court held

The claimants failed to prove the occurrence of the accident and the offending vehicle, and the FIR author's testimony was unreliable, with its 48-day delay unexplained.

It also directed

All three appeals are allowed, the Tribunal's award dated 13.9.2025 in M.A.C.C. Nos. 2812, 2967 and 3021 of 2022 is set aside, and the claim petitions are dismissed. The Tribunal's record is directed to be sent back forthwith. The delay of five days in filing M.A. No. 10213/2025 is condoned.

01Facts

The accident occurred on 1.3.2022, and the FIR was lodged on 18.4.2022, about 48 days later.

pp. 1–2

Deceased Deepak Choudhary was discharged from hospital on 16.4.2022 and later died.

p. 2

The Merg Intimations (Exs. P/8, P/31, P/47) do not name the FIR author as a person who brought the injured to hospital.

p. 2

The Claims Tribunal (22nd Addl. M.A.C.T., Jabalpur, M.A.C.C. Nos. 2812, 2967 and 3021 of 2022) allowed the claims by award dated 13.9.2025.

p. 1

The Insurer's witness (NAW-1) admitted that an investigator's report existed but was not produced.

pp. 2–3

AW-1 Faggi Bai admitted she was not an eye-witness and did not know the offending vehicle.

p. 4

AW-2 Milan Ahirwar admitted he did not see the accident, did not inform police of the vehicle, and did not meet AW-4 at hospital.

pp. 4–5 · p. 8

AW-3 Pradeep Choudhary admitted he did not see the accident and described the deceased Deepak as a student running a toy shop, contrary to the claim that he was a carpenter.

p. 5

AW-4 Surendra Kumar Kulaste, named as FIR author, denied lodging the FIR, could not describe the vehicle, admitted his friendship with AW-3, and admitted deposing at the family's request.

pp. 6–8

02Issues

i.1. Whether the claimants proved the factum of the accident and the identity of the offending vehicle.

p. 4 · p. 8

ii.2. Whether the testimony of AW-4 Surendra Kumar Kulaste, the FIR author, can be treated as eye-witness evidence, and whether the 48-day delay in lodging the FIR is satisfactorily explained.

pp. 8–10

03Law Applied

The onus lies on the claimants to prove both the occurrence of the accident and the vehicle involved.

p. 4

Under Ravi v. Badrinarayan & Others, (2011) 4 SCC 693, delay in lodging an FIR is not fatal where the informant offers satisfactory and cogent reasons, and the court must scrutinise the FIR and evidence closely in cases of delay.

pp. 9–10

Counsel for the claimants cited Raj Kumar Das (deceased) through LRs v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., 2026 ACJ 1235, for the preponderance-of-probabilities standard and the principle that FIR delay alone does not defeat a claim; the Court did not expressly discuss or apply it.

pp. 2–3, no citation

04Reasoning

The Court first examined the claimants' oral evidence against the onus of proof. AW-1 and AW-2 had no knowledge of the vehicle, and AW-2's failure to report the number for about 48 days was left unexplained.

pp. 4–5

The Court found that AW-4 was not an eye-witness but a "planted witness." It relied on his absence from the FIR as an eye-witness, his silence on the vehicle number despite attending the Lash Panchayatnama, his inconsistent account of the hospital transfer (contradicted by AW-2), his friendship with AW-3, and his admission that he testified at the family's request.

pp. 6–8

The Court found that AW-4's occupational account of the deceased conflicted with AW-3's evidence.

p. 5 · p. 8

Applying Ravi, the Court held that the FIR's author, being neither a relative of the deceased nor occupied with death rituals, was required to explain the delay, and no such explanation was offered. The Court distinguished Ravi on facts, since the informants there were attending to the injured or death rituals.

pp. 9–10

The Court did not expressly address the investigator-report argument or the Raj Kumar Das preponderance standard, and it treated the defects in AW-4's evidence as going to the existence of the accident, not as minor inconsistencies.

p. 4 · pp. 8–10

05Holding

The claimants failed to prove the occurrence of the accident and the offending vehicle, and the FIR author's testimony was unreliable, with its 48-day delay unexplained.

pp. 8–10

All three appeals are allowed, the Tribunal's award dated 13.9.2025 in M.A.C.C. Nos. 2812, 2967 and 3021 of 2022 is set aside, and the claim petitions are dismissed. The Tribunal's record is directed to be sent back forthwith. The delay of five days in filing M.A. No. 10213/2025 is condoned.

pp. 10–11 · p. 1
Madhya Pradesh High Court

Original Court PDF

Magma Hdi General Insurance Co. LtdvsChhuttan Ahirwar

Madhya Pradesh High Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment