01Facts
The petitioner-plaintiff filed Civil Suit No. RCS A-01/2024 (Tarana, District Ujjain) on 2.1.2024 for declaration of title, cancellation of a sale deed, and permanent injunction, relying on a Hibanama (gift deed) of 1996 executed by his father, Bhure Khan, in his favour.
p. 1 · p. 3Defendants 1 to 3 appeared. Defendant No. 1 filed a written statement on 6.7.2024, specifically disputing the signature of Bhure Khan on the Hibanama and alleging forgery and fabrication.
p. 1 · p. 3Issues were framed on 16.10.2025 and evidence was recorded. The matter was then listed for final arguments.
p. 3On 18.8.2026, at this stage, the petitioner applied under Section 39 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) for a handwriting expert's opinion on the Hibanama.
p. 1 · p. 3By order dated 24.10.2026, the trial court rejected the application on the ground of delay, and the petitioner challenged that order under Article 227 of the Constitution.
p. 1 · p. 402Issues
i.1. Whether the trial court was justified in rejecting, on the ground of belated filing at the final-arguments stage, the petitioner's application under Section 39 BSA seeking a handwriting expert's opinion on the disputed signature in the Hibanama.
p. 1 · p. 4 · p. 5ii.2. Whether the Division Bench decision in Asharam v. Suraj Singh Baghel requires that a belated application for expert opinion be allowed merely because delay alone is not a ground for rejection.
p. 1 · p. 4 · p. 503Law Applied
Section 39(1) BSA makes the opinion of persons specially skilled in questions of handwriting identity relevant, with Illustration (c) describing a comparison of disputed and admitted writings.
p. 2 · p. 3The Division Bench judgment in Asharam v. Suraj Singh Baghel (2010 SCC Online 424) holds that procedural law exists to secure substantial justice, that neither the Evidence Act provisions on proof of documents prescribe a particular mode of proof, and that examination of a handwriting expert is one permissible mode, so a party should not be denied that opportunity merely because of delay, subject to conditions such as costs and limits on further evidence.
p. 4Under the BSA, the presiding officer may itself compare signatures.
p. 5The court exercised supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution, interfering only where there is perversity or illegality in the trial court's order.
p. 5Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 Section 43Section 39
04Reasoning
The court accepted that Asharam holds that delay alone is not a ground to reject a Section 39 application and that expert evidence is a legitimate mode of proving a document. It nonetheless held Asharam inapplicable on facts. The defendant's specific challenge to the Hibanama signature was raised in the written statement of 6.7.2024, so the petitioner had notice of the dispute for over a year before issues were framed, evidence was recorded, and the matter reached final arguments. The application was therefore filed at a belated stage, with the object of filling a gap in the evidence.
p. 4Given the petitioner's conduct and the stage of the proceedings, the court held that granting relief would serve no fruitful purpose and would amount to filling a lacuna. The court also observed that the trial court retains the power to compare signatures itself, so the petitioner was not left without a means of resolving the dispute. Because the trial court's exercise of discretion showed no perversity or illegality, the court declined to interfere.
p. 505Holding
The court answered the issues in favour of the trial court. The rejection of a Section 39 BSA application for handwriting expert opinion at the final-arguments stage, on account of the petitioner's conduct and the delay in seeking it, was not perverse or illegal, and Asharam did not require a different result on these facts.
p. 4 · p. 5No interference was required under Article 227 of the Constitution, and the Misc. Petition No. 7039 of 2026 was dismissed. No costs were awarded.
p. 5Original Court PDF
Abdul Samal KhanvsRiyasat Khan
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
