01Facts
The plaintiff (appellant) sued for a declaration of title and permanent injunction over Survey No. 232, admeasuring 0.460 hectares, village Dhakad Khiriya, Tehsil Bhitarwar, District Gwalior (the "suit land").
¶ 2He alleged that the owner, Bharosilal, agreed to sell the land for Rs. 2 lakh, received Rs. 1.50 lakh, and executed an agreement to sell dated 21.06.1998 (Ex. P/1), handing over possession on the condition that 1/4th of the crop be paid until the sale deed was executed.
¶ 3He alleged that Rs. 50,000 more was paid about a year later.
¶ 3Bharosilal died on 06.05.2013 without executing the sale deed, and the plaintiff continued in possession.
¶ 4The defendant (respondent no. 1), claiming to be Bharosilal's nephew, obtained mutation on the basis of a registered Will dated 15.04.2013 (Ex. D/1), and the plaintiff later obtained a finding of possession in proceedings under Section 145 Cr.P.C.
¶ 4The defendant denied the agreement, pleaded that Bharosilal was unmarried and died without Class-I heirs, and relied on the Will.
¶ 5The trial court (30.08.2022) held the agreement and Rs. 1.50 lakh payment proved, found the plaintiff in possession, rejected the Will, declined declaratory relief, and granted a permanent injunction.
¶ 6The defendant appealed (RCA No. 47/2022); the plaintiff's cross-appeal (RCA No. 50/2022) was pending before a different court.
¶ 7The first appellate court (27.07.2024) allowed RCA No. 47/2022, set aside the injunction, and dismissed the suit.
¶ 1The defendant had filed additional documents under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, including the SDO's order dated 22.06.2018 under Section 250 MPLRC and a Revenue Inspector's report of 15.11.2018 on delivery of possession.
¶ 15–1602Issues
i.1. Whether the first appellate court grossly erred in allowing the defendant's application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC and deciding the appeal on additional documents, without following the procedure under Order 41 Rule 28 CPC.
¶ 8ii.2. Whether documents relating to the period after the filing of the suit are relevant for determining possession as on the date of suit, and thus admissible under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC.
¶ 13, 16–1703Law Applied
The Court relied on Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, which permits additional evidence in appeal only where the statutory conditions are met.
¶ 13The Court applied the principles in Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin, (2012) 8 SCC 148, under which the discretion must be exercised judicially, considering: (a) the relevance of the document to the issues; (b) why the evidence could not be led in the trial court; (c) whether the applicant was diligent before the trial court; and (d) whether the evidence is required to pronounce judgment.
¶ 13, citing Ibrahim Uddin · ¶ 47–48Reasons must be recorded, and the application must not be belated.
¶ 13, citing Ibrahim Uddin · ¶ 47–48 · ¶ 14The Court treated the possession of the parties as a matter to be decided on the material existing on the date of suit.
¶ 17Order 41 Rule 28 CPC, which prescribes the procedure after additional evidence is admitted, was referred to in the substantial question.
¶ 8The Court noted the principle that cross-appeals against the same decree should be heard by the same court to avoid conflicting findings.
¶ 12Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 145
MP Land Revenue Code 1959 Section 250
04Reasoning
The Court held that the first appellate court reversed the trial court's finding on possession by relying on the defendant's additional documents.
¶ 13The Court found that these documents were not shown to be relevant to the date of suit. The defendant's Rule 27 application gave no reason for failing to produce them before the trial court, except stating that they were certified copies of revenue records.
¶ 15The Ex. P/3 and Ex. P/4 mutation orders were already on the trial court record and so were not fresh evidence.
¶ 15The SDO order of 22.06.2018 and the 15.11.2018 delivery report post-dated the suit and could not establish possession on the date of filing.
¶ 16The plaintiff had, through I.A. No. 10592 of 2026, disputed the 2018 delivery of possession, which remained under challenge before the Commissioner, and a later Tehsildar application had been rejected on 05.12.2024.
¶ 17Applying Ibrahim Uddin, the Court concluded that the appellate court did not consider relevance and did not justify admission of the documents.
¶ 17The possession question therefore had to be decided on the pre-suit record, and the appellate court's reliance on the post-suit documents was an error.
¶ 16–17The Court did not separately analyze the Rule 28 procedure. It disposed of the matter by rejecting the Rule 27 application.
05Holding
The Court answered the substantial question in the affirmative: the first appellate court erred in allowing the defendant's Order 41 Rule 27 application without considering the relevance of the documents, and the documents were not relevant to the just decision of the case.
¶ 17The application was rejected.
¶ 17The judgment and decree dated 27.07.2024 in RCA No. 47/2022 was set aside and the matter was remitted to the first appellate court for fresh decision.
¶ 18The Principal District Judge, Gwalior was directed to assign the appeal to a single court to be decided together with RCA No. 50/2022 for analogous decision.
¶ 18The second appeal was allowed.
¶ 19Original Court PDF
Khushal SinghvsRamlakhan Sharma
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
