01Facts
The plaintiff (respondent No. 1) claims that Plot No. 20, measuring 800 sq. ft. out of Khasra No. 32/8, was sold to him by a registered sale deed dated 31.03.2004 executed by defendant No. 1 through defendant No. 2 as attorney, and that his name was recorded in revenue records.
¶ 2Defendant No. 1 denied executing any power of attorney and pleaded that any such power had been cancelled.
¶ 3Defendant No. 2 sold 4,800 sq. ft. to defendant No. 3 by deed dated 25.05.2004 without specifying boundaries, allegedly including the plaintiff's land.
¶ 2Defendants Nos. 3 and 4 denied encroaching and asserted possession of their own land.
¶ 2, 3, 7The plaintiff sued for declaration of title, permanent injunction, and mandatory injunction for delivery of encroached land.
¶ 1The trial court declared his title and possession but dismissed the injunction claims for want of proof of interference.
¶ 4The first appellate court reversed in part, directing delivery of the encroached land and granting a permanent injunction.
¶ 4The appellants (defendants Nos. 3 and 4) filed this second appeal.
¶ 1No local commission was appointed at any stage.
¶ 7–802Issues
i.1. Whether, in a dispute concerning boundaries and/or encroachment, the courts below were obliged to appoint a local commissioner under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC for demarcation of the suit land and submission of a spot inspection report.
¶ 5 · ¶ 8–903Law Applied
Order 26 Rule 9 CPC empowers a court to issue a commission for local investigation where it deems this requisite to elucidate a matter in dispute.
¶ 8Where a boundary dispute or dispute as to encroachment cannot be resolved without an agreed map, appointment of a competent Commissioner is a legal necessity and "the law of land"; no application is required and the court may act suo motu; and such an application may be raised at any stage, including appeal.
¶ 8Bagdiram v. Ramsingh (S.A. No. 23 of 2005, decided 06.03.2025) laid down the principles quoted at length in the judgment.
¶ 8Estoppel cannot override the mandatory course of appointing a Commissioner for boundary disputes.
¶ 8Prembai v. Ghanshyam, 2010 (3) MPLJ 345.
¶ 8Encroachment cannot be decided absent an agreed map except through a Commissioner, following Durga Prasad v. P. Foujdar, 1975 JLJ 440, and Beejanwala Talukdar v. Radhakrishna Rai, 2012 (III) MPWN 62.
¶ 8Loknath Gautam v. State of M.P., 2018 SCC OnLine MP 600.
¶ 8An Order 26 Rule 9 application may be filed at any stage, including appeal.
¶ 8Suman Pandagre v. Madhu Pandagre, 2022 SCC OnLine MP 6030.
¶ 8In demarcation disputes, the court must itself issue the commission, as held in Jaswant v. Dindayal, 2011 (2) MPLJ 576.
¶ 8Where no Commissioner has been appointed, remand for appointment of a Commissioner is appropriate, as held in Vayathinattar v. Sakkubai Ammal, AIR 2004 Mad 419.
¶ 8The court may appoint a Commissioner suo motu, as held in Baliram v. Melaram, AIR 2003 HP 87.
¶ 8Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
The court first characterised the dispute. The plaintiff alleged encroachment by defendants Nos. 3 and 4, while they denied it and asserted possession of their own land.
¶ 7No agreed map exists on record. Applying the principles in Bagdiram and the authorities it collects, the court held that such a dispute cannot be determined on oral and documentary evidence alone, because the fact of encroachment and the identity of the land can be established only through a local investigation by a Commissioner.
¶ 8, 9The courts below decided the encroachment question without taking this step, and the first appellate court granted possession and injunction on that basis.
¶ 9The court treated the absence of any party application as immaterial, since the power may be exercised suo motu and at any stage.
¶ 8The plaintiff's title was not in issue in the substantial question and had not been challenged in the appeal, so the court left the title finding undisturbed.
¶ 1105Holding
The substantial question is answered in favour of the appellants: in a boundary or encroachment dispute, the courts below were obliged to appoint a local commissioner under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC.
¶ 9–10The judgments and decrees of the courts below are set aside insofar as they failed to appoint a commissioner.
¶ 10The matter is remanded to the Trial Court to appoint a local commissioner, obtain the report, and decide afresh in accordance with law.
¶ 10Parties may lead evidence only to the extent of the Commissioner's report, and the finding on the plaintiff's title is maintained.
¶ 11The second appeal is allowed, with no order as to costs.
¶ 12Original Court PDF
Ghulam AmbiyavsAjay Kumar Lahari
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
