Madhya Pradesh High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

MP HC Quashes Withdrawal of Teacher's Promotion Done Without Show-Cause Notice

Pratap Singh Keerv.The State Of Madhya Pradesh

MP HC Quashes Withdrawal of Teacher's Promotion Done Without Show-Cause Notice. Pratap Singh Keer vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh. Madhya Pradesh High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether cancellation or reversion of promotions granted years earlier, without a show-cause notice or hearing, is sustainable where the order entails civil consequences.

The court held

In W.P. No. 9601, reversal of a promotion with civil consequences without a show-cause notice or hearing violates natural justice and is not saved by the mistake-apparent-on-record exception. The absence of a hearing was a violation of natural justice warranting interference.

It also directed

The Court quashed the order dated 28.04.2015 and directed the respondents to grant all consequential benefits already extended to similarly situated persons within three months of receipt of a certified copy of the order. The excerpt does not reproduce the operative reasoning or final disposition for W.P. No. 9815 of 2018 or the other connected petitions, so the outcome in those matters cannot be confirmed from the text provided.

01Facts

The petitioners were appointed as Sweepers and were promoted to Multipurpose Health Worker and Dai by orders dated 16.01.2008 and 10.06.2008, following DPC meetings held in 2008.

pp. 4–5

Later, a complaint alleged illegalities in the DPC dated 10.01.2008. A Collector-level inquiry followed, and two increments of the erring officers were stopped.

p. 6

The State then reverted the petitioners, treating their promotions as void ab initio for undue favour, and issued cancellation orders dated 09.04.2018 without a show-cause notice or hearing.

pp. 5–6

The petitioners challenged those orders. The State relied on Raghuwar Pal Singh and Munna Lal Yadav to argue that no hearing was required.

pp. 6–7

In W.P. No. 9601 of 2018, the petitioner, a Mathematics teacher, was appointed as Samvida Shala Shikshak Grade-III in 2007, qualified as a Sahayak Adhyapak in 2011, and was promoted to Adhyapak on 31.03.2014.

p. 9

An order dated 28.04.2015 withdrew that promotion and treated her as a Laboratory Teacher, relying on a 29.04.2014 departmental instruction, without notice or hearing.

pp. 9–10

The State contended that the Laboratory Teacher cadre is not eligible for promotion and that the mistake was apparent on the record.

p. 10

02Issues

i.1. Whether cancellation or reversion of promotions granted years earlier, without a show-cause notice or hearing, is sustainable where the order entails civil consequences.

pp. 6–7 · p. 14

ii.2. Whether the cancellation may be upheld on the ground that the promotion was void ab initio or that the mistake was apparent on the face of the record, so that no hearing was required.

p. 6 · p. 10 · pp. 13–14

03Law Applied

An opportunity of hearing is mandatory before an order with civil consequences is passed, including the recall or reversal of a promotion, as held in Pratap Babu Sen v. State of M.P., W.P. No. 4111/2006(S), decided 02.03.2009.

p. 12

Suresh Babu Kaurav v. State of M.P., W.P. No. 4215/2006(S), decided 11.09.2008, which relied on Gajanan L. Pernekar v. State of Goa, (1999) 8 SCC 378, holds that an adversely affected person must be heard before recall of an administrative order.

p. 12

Shekhar Ghosh v. Union of India, (2007) 1 SCC 331, requires a hearing where civil consequences arise.

p. 12

The exception for rectifying a mistake apparent on the face of the record without hearing, recognised in Union of India v. Bikash Kuanar, (2006) 8 SCC 192, and Ram Chandra Tripathi v. U.P. Public Services Tribunal, (1994) 5 SCC 180, is limited to cases where the mistake is evident and a hearing would make no difference.

pp. 12–13

A promotion made by a duly constituted DPC under the Recruitment Rules is not disturbed without hearing.

p. 14

04Reasoning

In W.P. No. 9601, the Court found that the petitioner had been promoted by a duly constituted DPC after seven years of service and possessed the minimum qualifications. The reversion therefore had civil consequences, and it was made without notice or hearing.

pp. 9–11

Following Pratap Babu Sen and Suresh Babu Kaurav, the Court held that the 2014 instruction did not apply to her case and that the State's "apparent mistake" argument could not dispense with a hearing, since the record required examination of the petitioner's eligibility and promotion.

p. 10 · p. 11 · pp. 13–14

The excerpt contains no reasoning on Raghuwar Pal Singh or Munna Lal Yadav, which the State cited in the lead petition, and does not expressly reconcile those authorities with the hearing requirement.

pp. 6–7

05Holding

In W.P. No. 9601, reversal of a promotion with civil consequences without a show-cause notice or hearing violates natural justice and is not saved by the mistake-apparent-on-record exception. The absence of a hearing was a violation of natural justice warranting interference.

p. 14

The Court quashed the order dated 28.04.2015 and directed the respondents to grant all consequential benefits already extended to similarly situated persons within three months of receipt of a certified copy of the order. The excerpt does not reproduce the operative reasoning or final disposition for W.P. No. 9815 of 2018 or the other connected petitions, so the outcome in those matters cannot be confirmed from the text provided.

p. 15
Madhya Pradesh High Court

Original Court PDF

Pratap Singh KeervsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh

Madhya Pradesh High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment