Madhya Pradesh High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Retired Stenographer Who Accepted Higher Pay Scales Without Protest Loses 1983 Seniority Plea: MP HC Cites Delay

Mohammad Fazal Husainv.M.P. Power Transmission Company Limited

Retired Stenographer Who Accepted Higher Pay Scales Without Protest Loses 1983 Seniority Plea: MP HC Cites Delay. Mohammad Fazal Husain vs M.P. Power Transmission Company Limited. Madhya Pradesh High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the writ petition is liable to be dismissed on account of inordinate and unexplained delay and laches, given that the petitioner remained silent during service and accepted the higher pay scale benefits without protest.

The court held

The petitioner's claim is barred by inordinate and unexplained delay and laches, as he silently accepted service benefits throughout his career and approached the Court only after retirement.

It also directed

The petitioner cannot claim seniority from his initial temporary appointment date.

The Court allowed I.A. No. 9347/2022 filed by the respondents and dismissed Writ Petition No. 22811 of 2017. The impugned order dated 23.11.2017 was not disturbed, and the consequential prayers (seniority from 18.04.1983, pay scale from that date, modification of the higher pay scale orders, third time-bound scale, and pension revision) stand rejected.

01Facts

The petitioner passed the English Typewriting Examination on 15.06.1980.

¶ 2

He was appointed as Steno-Typist vide order dated 15.04.1983 and joined on 18.04.1983.

¶ 2 · ¶ 5

He passed the English Stenography Examination on 09.04.1984.

¶ 2

He was appointed Junior Stenographer (formerly Stenographer, Ordinary Grade) vide order dated 12.11.1987, effective 05.12.1987.

¶ 2

He was granted the first higher pay scale vide order dated 31.03.1997, effective 02.12.1996, and the second higher pay scale, effective 18.04.2001 per the respondents or 05.12.2005 per the petitioner.

¶ 3 · ¶ 5

He retired on 31.12.2016.

¶ 3 · ¶ 5

The petitioner sought seniority from 18.04.1983, the pay scale of Stenographer (Ordinary Grade) from that date, the third time-bound scale on completion of 30 years' service, and revision of pensionary benefits.

¶ 1 · ¶ 2

He filed the writ petition on 17.12.2017.

¶ 3

The respondents contended that he never raised any grievance during service, accepted the higher pay scales without objection, and that the petition suffered from inordinate, unexplained delay. They filed I.A. No. 9347/2022 seeking dismissal.

¶ 3

The petitioner's own statement in the petition (para. 4) that there was no delay was noted as unexplained.

¶ 10

02Issues

i.1. Whether the writ petition is liable to be dismissed on account of inordinate and unexplained delay and laches, given that the petitioner remained silent during service and accepted the higher pay scale benefits without protest.

¶ 5 · ¶ 6–10

ii.2. Whether the petitioner can claim seniority and consequential benefits, including the Stenographer (Ordinary Grade) pay scale, from the date of his initial temporary appointment in 1983.

¶ 11

03Law Applied

Delay and laches are relevant to the exercise of discretionary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, and relief may be refused where a party's negligence in asserting a right, combined with lapse of time, prejudices the opposite party (Karnataka Power Corpn. Ltd. v. K. Thangappan, (2006) 4 SCC 322, paras 6–7).

¶ 8

A litigant cannot claim relief merely on the basis of a judgment in a similar case where the litigant itself slept over its rights (State of Orissa v. Mamata Mohanty, (2011) 3 SCC 436, para 54).

¶ 6

Equity favours a vigilant rather than an indolent litigant, and third-party rights crystallising in the interregnum weigh against interference (Focus Energy Ltd. v. Government of India, ILR (2011) MP 53, para 10).

¶ 7

A party who has slept over its rights is not entitled to discretionary relief (Ashok Kumar v. District Magistrate, Basti, (2012) 3 SCC 311, para 10).

¶ 9

04Reasoning

The Court examined the record and found that the petitioner never raised any grievance regarding non-grant of the Stenographer (Ordinary Grade) scale from 18.04.1983 during his service. He accepted his appointment terms, continued in service until retirement, and accepted the first and second higher pay scales without objection.

¶ 5

Applying Mamata Mohanty and Focus Energy, the Court held that acceptance of benefits without protest over decades is a classic case of conduct disentitling a party to equitable relief.

¶ 5–7

The writ was filed on 17.12.2017, roughly a year after retirement, and the petitioner did not explain the delay. His assertion in the petition that there was no delay was treated as an inadequate explanation, and on this ground alone the claim fails under Thangappan and Ashok Kumar.

¶ 8–10

The Court held independently that because the petitioner was initially appointed on a temporary basis and was later appointed as Junior Stenographer, he cannot claim seniority from the initial temporary appointment date.

¶ 11

The order refers to the appointment date as 15.04.1983 in para. 11, although para. 5 records the temporary appointment as 18.04.1983. The discrepancy does not affect the outcome. The consequential reliefs (third time-bound scale, pension revision, and arrears) depend on the seniority claim and were not separately adjudicated.

¶ 1 · ¶ 11

05Holding

The petitioner's claim is barred by inordinate and unexplained delay and laches, as he silently accepted service benefits throughout his career and approached the Court only after retirement.

¶ 5 · ¶ 10

The petitioner cannot claim seniority from his initial temporary appointment date.

¶ 11

The Court allowed I.A. No. 9347/2022 filed by the respondents and dismissed Writ Petition No. 22811 of 2017. The impugned order dated 23.11.2017 was not disturbed, and the consequential prayers (seniority from 18.04.1983, pay scale from that date, modification of the higher pay scale orders, third time-bound scale, and pension revision) stand rejected.

¶ 11
Madhya Pradesh High Court

Original Court PDF

Mohammad Fazal HusainvsM.P. Power Transmission Company Limited

Madhya Pradesh High Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment