Madhya Pradesh High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Removed Railway Constable Gets Fresh Appeal Hearing As MP HC Quashes Non-Speaking Rejection

Daya Shankar Dubeyv.Union Of India

Removed Railway Constable Gets Fresh Appeal Hearing As MP HC Quashes Non-Speaking Rejection. Daya Shankar Dubey vs Union Of India. Madhya Pradesh High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the appellate authority's order dated 18.10.2011, which rejected the departmental appeal without dealing with the grounds raised, is non-speaking and sustainable in law.

The court held

The appellate order dated 18.10.2011 is non-speaking and devoid of reasons.

It also directed

The appellate order dated 18.10.2011, along with the consequential revisional order dated 29.02.2012, is quashed and set aside.

The matter is remitted to the appellate authority for fresh consideration. The petitioner may file a fresh appeal or representation with grounds and documents within three weeks. The appellate authority must consider it along with the earlier appeal, grant a personal hearing, and pass a reasoned and speaking order within three months of receiving a certified copy of the order.

The court expressed no opinion on the merits, and the appellate authority is to decide independently.

The writ petition is disposed of accordingly.

01Facts

The petitioner, a Constable posted at Guna, was served a charge-sheet dated 28.06.2010 alleging misconduct.

¶ 2

He replied, but the disciplinary authority appointed an Enquiry Officer and Presenting Officer without considering the reply.

¶ 2

The Enquiry Officer submitted a report, which was supplied to the petitioner, who replied on 15.11.2010.

¶ 2

By order dated 29.01.2011, the disciplinary authority imposed the penalty of removal from service.

¶ 2 · ¶ 5

The petitioner filed a departmental appeal dated 25.02.2011, raising detailed factual and legal grounds spanning six pages.

¶ 2

The appellate authority rejected the appeal by order dated 18.10.2011, holding that the charges were proved, the punishment was proportionate, and no new fact or argument had been raised.

¶ 5

The petitioner's revision was dismissed by order dated 29.02.2012.

¶ 2, 10

The petitioner contended that the appellate order was cryptic and non-speaking and did not address his grounds.

¶ 2

The respondents contended that the authorities had duly considered the material and that judicial review does not permit reappreciation of evidence.

¶ 3

02Issues

i.1. Whether the appellate authority's order dated 18.10.2011, which rejected the departmental appeal without dealing with the grounds raised, is non-speaking and sustainable in law.

¶ 6 · ¶ 10

ii.2. Whether the revisional order dated 29.02.2012, being consequential to the appellate order, is liable to be set aside.

¶ 10

03Law Applied

A quasi-judicial authority exercising discretion must act with due diligence, reasonably and rationally, and must give reasons.

¶ 6

Under State of Punjab v. Bandip Singh (2016) 1 SCC 724, every administrative or executive decision must be composite and self-sustaining, containing all the reasons that led the authority to its conclusion, and must not be capricious, arbitrary or prejudiced.

¶ 7–8

Under Kranti Associates Pvt. Ltd. v. Masood Ahmed Khan (2010) 9 SCC 496, the order of a quasi-judicial or administrative authority affecting rights must speak and not be "like the inscrutable face of a sphinx"; reasons are an indispensable component of decision-making and a facet of fairness, and the affected party must know how his case or defence was considered.

¶ 6, 9

The authorities cited in Bandip Singh, including Tata Cellular v. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 651 and Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa (2007) 14 SCC 517, as quoted therein, were also relied upon.

¶ 8

04Reasoning

The court examined the appellate order, quoted in full at para. 5, and found that it recorded the proof of charges and the proportionality of the punishment but did not engage with the specific factual and legal grounds in the six-page memo of appeal.

¶ 10

Because the appellate authority, as a quasi-judicial body, was obliged to independently consider those grounds and record reasons addressing them, its failure to do so rendered the order non-speaking and unsustainable under the Bandip Singh and Kranti Associates principles.

¶ 6, 10

The court did not evaluate the merits of the charges or the penalty.

¶ 10

Since the revisional order was founded on the defective appellate order and was consequential to it, it could not stand independently.

¶ 10

The court's intervention was therefore confined to the procedural defect of absent reasons, not to the adequacy of the evidence.

¶ 11

05Holding

The appellate order dated 18.10.2011 is non-speaking and devoid of reasons.

¶ 10

The appellate order dated 18.10.2011, along with the consequential revisional order dated 29.02.2012, is quashed and set aside.

¶ 10

The matter is remitted to the appellate authority for fresh consideration. The petitioner may file a fresh appeal or representation with grounds and documents within three weeks. The appellate authority must consider it along with the earlier appeal, grant a personal hearing, and pass a reasoned and speaking order within three months of receiving a certified copy of the order.

¶ 10

The court expressed no opinion on the merits, and the appellate authority is to decide independently.

¶ 11

The writ petition is disposed of accordingly.

¶ 12
Madhya Pradesh High Court

Original Court PDF

Daya Shankar DubeyvsUnion Of India

Madhya Pradesh High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment