01Facts
The petitioner was appointed as Upper Division Teacher on 18.01.1980 and retired as Headmaster on 31.10.2025.
¶ 2The respondents deducted ₹68,553 from his salary, allegedly as excess payment received while he served as Headmaster, as reflected in pay slips for January 2014 to October 2015.
¶ 2The Block Education Officer informed the Joint Director, Treasuries, on 25.01.2016 that the petitioner's service book and pay fixation had not been verified or approved by the competent authority, and forwarded the service book for verification so the excess could be recovered.
¶ 2The petitioner had earlier obtained a favourable order in W.P. No. 2056/2015 dated 11.02.2015. When no action followed, he filed W.P. No. 8497/2016, which was dismissed as withdrawn with liberty to refile on 13.05.2016.
¶ 2The petitioner contends that no show-cause notice or hearing was given, that a Class III post is involved, that recovery after retirement is impermissible, and that the overpayment arose from a wrong fixation in 1998 for which he was not responsible.
¶ 3The State contends that the petitioner gave an undertaking at the time of pay upgradation to return any excess amount, and that Rafiq Masih therefore does not apply.
¶ 402Issues
i.1. Whether the State may recover excess payments made due to a wrong pay fixation in 1998 from the salary and retiral dues of a retired Class III employee, without a show-cause notice or opportunity of hearing.
¶ 3 · ¶ 11ii.2. Whether an undertaking given by the employee at the time of pay refixation, to repay any excess amount, permits recovery where the undertaking was not shown to have been given voluntarily.
¶ 4 · ¶ 9 · ¶ 1003Law Applied
State of M.P. v. Jagdish Prasad Dubey (2024) 2 M.P.L.J. 198 (Full Bench) holds that recovery may be made on the basis of a voluntary undertaking, but that recovery of excess pay refixed decades earlier cannot be enforced on the strength of an undertaking, and that a forced undertaking is unenforceable under Central Inland Water Transport Corporation v. Brojo Nath Ganguly (1986) 3 SCC 136.
¶ 6State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) (2015) 4 SCC 334 lists situations where recovery is impermissible: (i) recovery from Class III and IV employees; (ii) recovery from retired employees, or those retiring within one year; (iii) recovery where the excess payment was made over more than five years before the recovery order; and (v) recovery that is iniquitous, harsh, or arbitrary.
¶ 7Jogeswar Sahoo v. District Judge, Cuttack (2025) 3 M.P.L.J. (S.C.) 25 holds that recovery is unsustainable where no opportunity of hearing was given and the employee had retired from a non-gazetted post.
¶ 8Ravindra Kumar Joshi v. State of M.P. (W.P. No. 17831/2019, order dated 13.05.2024), citing High Court of Punjab and Haryana v. Jagdev Singh, treats an undertaking as unenforceable where the State fails to establish it was given voluntarily.
¶ 904Reasoning
The court first examined the undertaking relied on by the State. Following Ravindra Kumar Joshi and Jagdish Prasad Dubey, it held that the State had not established that the petitioner gave the undertaking voluntarily. The undertaking was therefore treated as forced and could not sustain recovery.
¶ 9 · ¶ 10The petitioner was a Class III employee (Headmaster), and he had retired, which brings him within categories (i) and (ii) of Rafiq Masih.
¶ 11The overpayment dated from 1998, and recovery was initiated in 2016, well beyond five years, which brings the case within category (iii) of Rafiq Masih.
¶ 11 · ¶ 7The recovery was initiated without any show-cause notice or hearing, which the court treated as decisive in light of Jogeswar Sahoo. Together, these factors made the recovery impermissible.
¶ 11 · ¶ 805Holding
The impugned recovery of ₹68,553 is not permissible.
¶ 11The impugned recovery is set aside. The respondents are directed to refund the amount with 6% simple interest per annum from the date of retirement until actual payment. The direction is to be completed within 90 days of receiving a certified copy of the order, failing which 12% interest is payable from the date of entitlement. The relief is available only if no recovery is made from retiral dues. The petition is disposed of.
¶ 11 · ¶ 12 · ¶ 13Original Court PDF
Shiv Dayal SonivsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
