01Facts
The petitioner was appointed as an Anganwadi Karyakarta on 25.04.2007.
¶ 2She took medical leave from 07.11.2014 to 30.11.2014, and the Anganwadi Centre's charge was given to a helper, Jayanti Yadav.
¶ 2The petitioner rejoined on 01.12.2014, but the helper did not return the charge to her.
¶ 2A show-cause notice was issued on 08.05.2015, to which the petitioner replied.
¶ 2The Project Officer/CDPO then terminated her services by an order dated 25.05.2015, which the petitioner alleges was stigmatic, non-speaking and passed without considering her reply.
¶ 2The termination order was challenged in appeal before the Additional Collector, who by order dated 03.03.2016 dismissed the appeal and upheld the termination (Annexure P/1).
¶ 6, 11That order relied on supervisor inspection reports recording the petitioner's prolonged absence, quarrels with the helper, non-response to calls, and a complaint from a resident, and it described her conduct as negligent and indisciplined.
¶ 6The petitioner contended that no charge-sheet was issued, no inquiry officer or presenting officer was appointed, and no regular departmental inquiry was held.
¶ 3The State contended that clause 10 of the appointment order permits termination without inquiry or show-cause notice.
¶ 4Admittedly, no regular departmental inquiry was conducted.
¶ 7, 1302Issues
i.1. Whether the termination order dated 25.05.2015, as upheld by the appellate order dated 03.03.2016, is stigmatic in nature such that it could not be passed without a regular departmental inquiry.
¶ 7, 9, 14ii.2. Whether the termination of a contractual/Anganwadi worker can be sustained without an inquiry on the strength of clause 10 of the appointment terms, in light of the State's 10.07.2007 policy on removal of Anganwadi workers.
¶ 4, 1303Law Applied
A termination founded on acts of commission or omission amounting to misconduct is stigmatic and entails serious consequences for future prospects, and therefore must follow an inquiry, drawing on Rahul Tripathi v. Rajeev Gandhi Shiksha Mission (2001 (3) MPLJ 616) and Jitendra v. State of M.P. (2008 (4) MPLJ 670).
¶ 8, 10The reasonable opportunity framework in Khem Chand v. Union of India (1958 SCR 300) requires notice of charges, an opportunity to cross-examine and defend, and a hearing on the proposed punishment.
¶ 8Malkhan Singh Malviya v. State of M.P. (ILR 2018 MP 660) was followed.
¶ 8In Rajesh Kumar Rathore v. High Court of M.P. (W.P. No. 18657/2018, order dated 23.11.2021), applying Krishna Pal v. District Sessions Judge, Morena, a contingency-paid employee cannot be terminated by a stigmatic order without inquiry despite Rule 9 of the 1980 Rules.
¶ 11Devkaran Patidar v. State of M.P. (W.P. No. 5856/2020, order dated 02.02.2024) was relied upon.
¶ 12Coordinate bench decisions in Omprakash Gurjar (W.P. No. 23267/2019, order dated 25.04.2022), Arvind Malviya (W.P. No. 14663/2022, order dated 19.07.2023) and Hukumchand Solanki (W.P. No. 19117/2022, order dated 12.09.2023) were relied upon.
¶ 7, 10, 15The State's policy dated 10.07.2007 provides that an Anganwadi worker may be removed only after a hearing and an inquiry finding misconduct.
¶ 1304Reasoning
The court examined the language of the appellate order and found it to be stigmatic on its face, because it attributed dereliction of duty, indiscipline and quarrelsome conduct to the petitioner.
¶ 6, 9Such findings cast a stigma on her conduct, character and work, so the termination could not be effected without a charge-sheet, a regular inquiry and a meaningful hearing.
¶ 9, 14The court held that the impugned order was issued without proper opportunity of hearing and without any departmental inquiry.
¶ 9Because the State's own 2007 policy makes removal contingent on an inquiry after a hearing, the court did not accept that clause 10 of the appointment terms dispensed with that requirement.
¶ 13The reasoning implicitly treats the stigma doctrine and the policy as overriding the contractual term, consistent with the coordinate bench rulings it followed.
¶ 12, 15The court found the present case squarely covered by Omprakash Gurjar.
¶ 15The reliance on the 2007 policy and on the supervisor reports, which were never tested through inquiry, reinforces the conclusion that the termination was procedurally infirm.
¶ 6, 1305Holding
The termination, being stigmatic, could not be imposed without a regular departmental inquiry, and no charge-sheet or inquiry had been conducted.
¶ 14, 15The court set aside the impugned order dated 03.03.2016 (Annexure P/1) and directed the respondents to reinstate the petitioner forthwith with all consequential benefits except back wages, on the principle of "no work, no pay". The State retains liberty to proceed against the petitioner afresh in accordance with law. The writ petition was disposed of accordingly.
¶ 15, 16The operative direction refers to the order dated 03.03.2016; the court did not expressly set aside the 25.05.2015 termination order and the 24.11.2015 order, which were also sought to be quashed in the prayer.
¶ 1Original Court PDF
Archana TripathivsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
