01Facts
The petitioner was appointed as Assistant Cashier-cum-Godown Keeper on 11.11.1973, promoted to Chief Cashier in 1979, and later promoted to Senior Manager, from which he retired on 29.02.2012
¶ 2While working as Branch Manager, he was prosecuted under Sections 7 and 13(1) read with Section 12(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The Special Judge (Lokayukt) convicted him on 02.02.2005
¶ 2The respondent-Bank dismissed him from service on 28.03.2005
¶ 2In Criminal Appeal No. 121 of 2005, the dismissal was partly modified to compulsory retirement with consequential terminal benefits, by order dated 31.12.2005
¶ 2The criminal appeal was allowed on 09.12.2010 and the petitioner was reinstated on 26.04.2011
¶ 3He then sought back wages and consequential benefits for the dismissal period. The Bank's orders dated 26.04.2011 and 30.11.2011 declined pay, allowances and increments for that period
p. 1, relief (ii)The petitioner sought payment of pay, allowances, increments and promotion consideration for 28.03.2005 to 26.04.2011, relying on W.P. No. 7680 of 2012 (Arun Kumar Shukla v. Union of India)
¶ 3, 1 (relief (iii)–(iv))The respondents contended that the petitioner's own criminal involvement caused the loss of service, that there was no fault on the Bank's part, and that he was reinstated immediately upon acquittal, so no back wages were payable
¶ 402Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to back wages for the period from 28.03.2005 to 26.04.2011, during which he remained out of service following dismissal
¶ 7, 8ii.2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to other consequential benefits, including increments and consideration for promotion, for the same intervening period, notwithstanding the principle of "no work no pay"
¶ 3, 803Law Applied
The Court relied on the Supreme Court's decisions in Deepali Gundu Surwase v. Kranti Junior Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya, (2013) 10 SCC 324, and U.P. State Brassware Corporation Ltd. v. Uday Narayan Pandey, (2006) 1 SCC 479
¶ 7These decisions hold that reinstatement with continuity of service and back wages is the normal rule in wrongful termination cases, subject to the adjudicator's consideration of length of service, nature of proved misconduct, the employer's financial condition and similar factors
¶ 7, quoting Deepali · ¶ 38.1–38.2The burden is on the employer to plead and prove gainful employment where it seeks to reduce back wages
¶ 7, quoting Deepali · ¶ 38.3Full back wages are justified where the employer acted in gross violation of statutory or natural justice principles, victimised the employee, or foisted a false charge, while discretion to deny them arises where the punishment is disproportionate to a proved misconduct
¶ 7, quoting Deepali · ¶ 38.4–38.5The Court also relied on Arun Kumar Shukla (W.P. No. 7680 of 2012), as cited by the petitioner, for the proposition that consequential benefits other than back wages are payable on the principle of "no work no pay"
¶ 3 · ¶ 8The respondents relied on Raj Narain v. Union of India, Civil Appeal No. 3339 of 2019, but the judgment does not record its reasoning
¶ 5Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 Section 7Section 13Section 12
04Reasoning
The Court held that back wages are not automatic and depend on the facts of each case
¶ 7It applied the Deepali framework to the present facts. The petitioner's dismissal followed his own conviction for corruption-related offences, and the Court found that the petitioner himself was involved in the criminal case and that there was no fault on the part of the Bank
¶ 8The Bank did not act in gross violation of statutory provisions or victimise the petitioner, and it reinstated him immediately after acquittal in appeal
¶ 4, 8On these findings, the Court concluded that the case fell outside the category in which full back wages are warranted under Deepali (paras. 38.4–38.5) and that denial of back wages was justified
¶ 8The Court then separated back wages from other service benefits. It held that the petitioner was entitled to all other consequential benefits for 28.03.2005 to 26.04.2011, while the "no work no pay" principle barred only the back wages component
¶ 8The judgment does not expressly analyse the length of service, the Bank's financial position or the gainful-employment burden under Deepali, and it does not explain its reasons for not following Raj Narain
05Holding
The Court held that the petitioner is not entitled to back wages for the period 28.03.2005 to 26.04.2011, because his own criminal involvement caused the dismissal and the Bank was not at fault
¶ 8He is entitled to all other consequential benefits for that period, except back wages, on the principle of "no work no pay"
¶ 8The Bank was directed to comply within three months from receipt of a certified copy of the order
¶ 9The writ petition was disposed of accordingly
¶ 10Original Court PDF
M.S. ThakurvsUco Bank
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
