01Facts
The Section 4(1) notification under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was issued on 10.01.2008 for a Lift Irrigation project
¶ 3.1The SLAO passed the general award on 20.10.2010, fixing compensation at Rs. 26,000/acre on the basis that the land was dry (Khushki)
¶ 3.2The claimants sought reference to the Land Acquisition Court (LAC Nos. 47–77, 79 and 80 of 2011)
¶ 3.3 · ¶ 11The project was transferred from PWD to the appellant, KNNL, on 01.04.2014. The claimants denied knowledge of this transfer, and the parties dispute whether it was notified
¶ 12The appellant was not arrayed as a party; the cause title named only the SLAO and the Executive Engineer, Canal Division
¶ 3.4 · ¶ 17On 26.03.2015 the LAC enhanced compensation to Rs. 10,00,000/acre
¶ 3.5 · ¶ 11The appellant learned of the order only upon notice in execution proceedings
¶ 3.6It obtained administrative approval and filed MFA No. 101686/2018, which was withdrawn with liberty to appeal before the District Court following the pecuniary jurisdiction amendment
¶ 3.7–3.8 · ¶ 13The appeal was filed on 20.10.2019 with an application for condonation of delay
¶ 3.9, 11The District Court dismissed the application, declining to condone a 1,036-day delay and imposing costs of Rs. 5,000, on the basis that the explanation was inadequate and that the appellant's witness admitted that 50% of the amount had been deposited and withdrawn by beneficiaries
¶ 3.11–3.12The appellant filed the present second appeal
¶ 3.1202Issues
i.1. Whether the First Appellate Court was right in rejecting the condonation of delay application without considering the reasons stated in the application
¶ 2, Q.1ii.2. Whether the First Appellate Court was right in appreciating the evidence led by the Authority in support of the condonation application
¶ 2, Q.2 · ¶ 1903Law Applied
The Court relied on Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1908, under which condonation of delay is a matter of judicial discretion and not a right, and must be exercised on judicially acceptable grounds rather than by counting days
¶ 9, 20The Court applied the principle, drawn from State of Orissa v. Managing Committee, Namrata Girls High School (SLP(C) Diary No. 54941/2025, decided 09.02.2026), that a judicially acceptable explanation must be considered on its merits
¶ 8, 14The Court relied on Commissioner of Wealth Tax v. Amateur Riders Club (as quoted in Namrata), which holds that governmental delay must still be explained credibly and that bureaucratic inaction does not automatically qualify as sufficient cause
¶ 8The Court followed Deputy Commissioner & SLAO v. M/s SV Global Mills Ltd. (decided 09.02.2026), which holds that courts should adopt a pragmatic rather than pedantic approach to condonation applications
¶ 10The Court also applied the natural justice principle that a person not heard before a judgment affecting its interest must be afforded an opportunity to contest the matter on merits
¶ 18Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 5
04Reasoning
The Court distinguished Namrata on its facts. In that case the explanation was found inadequate, whereas here the explanation was supported by the LAC cause title, which did not array KNNL as a party
¶ 15, 17The LAC reference predated the 2014 transfer, and KNNL was never impleaded, so it had no notice of the proceedings or any opportunity to lead evidence on the enhancement claim
¶ 15, 13The Court held that the appellate court failed to consider the explanation and misread the evidence, including the cross-examination of the authority's witness
¶ 18–19It stated that the appellate court dismissed the appeal on technicality without hearing the merits of the enhancement claim
¶ 19The Court also found "some force" in the appellant's submission on non-impleadment and transfer of the project, and held that the appellant must be given an opportunity to challenge the enhanced compensation evidence
¶ 21The Court did not rely on the 50% deposit and withdrawal as a ground for refusing condonation
¶ 3.12, 6.1Costs were imposed to balance the prejudice to the land losers
¶ 22(iii)05Holding
Both substantial questions were answered in favour of the appellant. The Court held that the appellate court failed to consider the explanation and misappreciated the evidence, and that the appellant was entitled to a hearing on the merits of the enhancement claim
¶ 22 · ¶ 18–19, 21The order of the District Court was set aside, and the delay applications were allowed subject to costs of Rs. 10,000 per case, payable to the land losers within two weeks, failing which the order stands recalled. The appeal was restored to the First Appellate Court, with parties to appear on 07.12.2026. The LAC Court was directed to decide the reference on merits, with all contentions left open. Trial Court records are to be returned by 30.11.2026, and disposal is to be completed within six months of first appearance
¶ 22(ii), (iii), (vii) · ¶ 22(iv) · ¶ 22(v)–(vi) · ¶ 22(viii)–(ix)Original Court PDF
KARNATAKA NEERAVARI NIGAM LIMITEDvsTHE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
